Eminem publisher takes Apple to court over rights

Sep 24, 2009 By ED WHITE , Associated Press Writer
FILE - In this Sunday, Sept. 13, 2009 picture, Eminem accepts the "Best Hip Hop Video" award during the MTV Video Music Awards in New York. Eminem's music publisher wants a bigger slice from Apple. Eight Mile Style LLC is suing Apple Inc., claiming it never authorized the use of 93 songs in a downloadable format on the popular iTunes service. The publisher is alleging copyright infringement. A trial in federal court in Detroit is scheduled for Thursday, Sept. 24, 2009 unless a deal is reached Wednesday with the help of a judge. (AP Photo/Jason DeCrow)

(AP) -- An attorney for Apple Inc. defended the company's use of Eminem's songs on iTunes in court on Thursday, as a trial got under way to determine who had the right to offer digital downloads of the rapper's music.

Eight Mile Style LLC, Eminem's publisher, and an affiliated company, Martin Affiliated LLC, say their contract with Aftermath Records, which controls the recordings, did not entitle it to strike a deal with Apple to sell 93 songs over iTunes.

The case involves millions of dollars and the creative rights behind the hip-hop star. But the issue for the judge here in the rapper's hometown is narrow: What do contracts between Eight Mile and Aftermath say about the ability to peddle songs beyond traditional compact discs?

In his opening statement, Apple lawyer Glenn Pomerantz said it's a case of "common sense."

"Nowhere does it say only compact discs. Nowhere does it say ... not digital downloads," he told U.S. District Judge Anna Diggs Taylor.

Record companies like Aftermath have rights to use the recordings and the compositions - "otherwise they couldn't sell records," Pomerantz said.

Apple pays Aftermath 70 cents for each iTunes download, and Eight Mile gets 9.1 cents of that share as the music publisher, he said.

Despite the legal dispute, Eight Mile cashed checks and hasn't asked Apple to stop selling Eminem's songs, Pomerantz said.

"They've been paid a lot of money. We don't begrudge them that," he said. "But they're not entitled to that money and Apple's profits."

Eight Mile's lawyers claim Apple has wrongfully gained $2.5 million through iTunes downloads, including $466,915 from Eminem's biggest hit, "Lose Yourself." They say Aftermath has collected $4 million off his songs on iTunes.

Eight Mile attorney Richard Busch said the publisher has a history of making legal distinctions between digital downloads and other ways to distribute Eminem's music. He referred to an agreement with to offer "Lose Yourself" as a download before was created.

"The publisher owns these compositions, not Aftermath. ... If Eight Mile had a direct licensing relationship with Apple, this kind of nonsense would not happen," Busch said.

Pomerantz said Apple doesn't make that kind of deal.

The first witness was Eight Mile manager Joel Martin, who said the publishing company can't protect itself financially without a download license with Apple.

"We can't look at their records. We can't look at their books. We can never make a claim against - ever," he said.

Eminem, whose real name is Marshall Mathers, was not in court. He is not a plaintiff in the lawsuit and is not listed as a trial witness.

"He's well aware of what's going on," said Mark Bass, a songwriter and producer who, with his brother Jeff, is credited with launching Eminem's career. "It's important to all songwriters across the board."

The trial could last a week or more. The judge is not expected to hear any music, but Pomerantz held up an unusual prop during his opening statement: a 1940s album by late crooner Bing Crosby.

He used it to explain the history of a music "album" and how song delivery has changed over decades.

©2009 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Explore further: News Corp. to buy Move Inc. for about $950 million

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Eminem's music publisher takes Apple to court

Sep 22, 2009

(AP) -- Eminem's music publisher wants a bigger slice from Apple. Eight Mile Style LLC and a co-plaintiff, Martin Affiliated LLC, are suing Apple Inc., claiming they never authorized the use of 93 songs in ...

Jobs Says Apple Customers Not into Renting Music

Apr 27, 2007

Apple Chief Executive Steve Jobs indicates he is unlikely to give in to calls from the music industry to add a subscription-based model to Apple's wildly popular iTunes online music store.

Like Apple, Amazon, Wal-Mart change music prices

Apr 08, 2009

(AP) -- Apple's iTunes Store isn't the only one that has adjusted prices for its digital song downloads recently: Changes are showing up at Amazon's and Wal-Mart's online music stores, too.

Changes to Apple's iTunes prices take effect

Apr 07, 2009

(AP) -- The era of one-price-fits-all-songs on iTunes came to an end Tuesday as Apple Inc., the Internet's dominant digital music retailer, began selling some of its most-downloaded songs for $1.29 apiece.

Recommended for you

Microsoft to tap $2-trillion Indian cloud market

2 hours ago

Microsoft announced plans Tuesday to offer its commercial cloud services from Indian data centres as it seeks to tap what it calls a $2-trillion market in the country where Internet use is growing rapidly.

Canada demands Google, Netflix data, sets deadline

7 hours ago

Canada's broadcast regulator on Monday gave American companies Google and Netflix a three-day deadline to turn over subscriber data or have their testimony expunged from a major public hearing, media reported.

User comments : 0