Working on the railroad? Using concrete could help environment

May 07, 2009
Working on the railroad? Using concrete could help environment
Concrete railway cross ties could be an eco-friendly alternative to those made of wood, scientists report. Credit: Tomasz Sienicki

Wood or concrete? Railroads around the world face that decision as they replace millions of deteriorating cross ties, also known as railway sleepers, those rectangular objects used as a base for railroad tracks. A new report concludes that emissions of carbon dioxide — one of the main greenhouse gases contributing to global warming -- from production of concrete sleepers are up to six times less than emissions associated with timber sleepers. The study is scheduled for the June 1 issue of ACS’ Environmental Science & Technology.

In the study, Robert Crawford points out that there have been long-standing concerns about environmental consequences of manufacturing railway sleepers because it involves harvesting large amounts of timber. Reinforced concrete sleepers are an alternative that offer greater strength, durability and long-term cost savings, he said. Critics of using concrete sleepers have charged that their manufacture increases greenhouse gas emissions as it involves higher consumption of fuel when compared to production of wood sleepers.

Crawford studied the greenhouse gas emissions of wooden and reinforced concrete sleepers based on one kilometer (0.62 miles) length of track over a 100-year life cycle. He found that emissions from reinforced concrete sleepers can be from two to six times lower than those from timber. “The results suggest strongly that reinforced concrete sleepers result in lower life cycle greenhouse emissions than timber sleepers,” the report states.

More information: “Greenhouse Gas Emissions Embodied in Reinforced Concrete and Timber Railway Sleepers”, Environmental Science & Technology

Provided by American Chemical Society (news : web)

Explore further: Actions on climate change bring better health, study says

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Pricing can cut CO2 emissions from electric generators

Apr 28, 2008

Levying a price on carbon dioxide released by electric generators could considerably reduce greenhouse gas emissions — even before the deployment of any environmentally friendly technology — according to scientists in ...

Recommended for you

Implications for the fate of green fertilizers

19 hours ago

The use of green fertilizers is a practice that has been around since humans first began growing food, but researchers are warning that modern techniques for the creation of these fertilizers could have implications ...

User comments : 3

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

docknowledge
not rated yet May 07, 2009
It's news to me that there are any emissions from concrete. Since Roman concrete has been around for thousands of years, it can't be deteriorating very quickly.



But also, there's the creosote or asphalt used to preserve wood ties. The creosote is quite toxic? Is now considered a problem for those who were recycling railroad ties to build garden planters?
lengould100
not rated yet May 08, 2009
doc: It's the manufacturing of the cement which makes up 1/6th of concrete, and a lesser amount the steel reinforcing, where the fossil fuels are burned and GHG's reeased.
wawadave
not rated yet May 09, 2009
The cement ties will out last wooden ties at least 10x