You scratch my back and I'll scratch yours

Sep 02, 2013 by Angela Herring
Filippo Simini is a postdoctoral research associate in the Center for Complex Network Research, led by Distinguished Univeristy Professor Albert-László Barabási. Credit: Mary Knox Merrill

Suppose you held in your hands a bunch of individuals from different species, sort of like a miniature Jumanji set. You have some cows, some bacteria, some plants, some bugs, and a whole bunch of other living things. You throw the lot up in the air and let them land where they will, randomly positioning themselves next to one another.

Like a social network, links between the individuals will form based simply on who's nearby. One cow takes a bite of grass; another cow eats a bug. A sets up shop on a bug's back, so now it's in a cow's stomach, and so on. Not all of these interactions will be the most ideal for a species' survival. But a few, called mutualistic interactions, will be great for everyone involved.

"Species select their mutualistic partners to maximize their population," said Filippo Simini, a postdoctoral research associate in Northeastern's Center for Complex Network Research. While on its own this fact isn't all that surprising, its implications have puzzled ecologists and network scientists like Simini for some time.

Here's the conundrum: As random networks become progressively more organized, with less favorable interactions being cast aside for more favorable ones, the community becomes less resilient while simultaneously becoming more stable. That's because the network topology that emerges from this kind of optimization is less capable of bouncing back after small perturbations, like disease or a storm or short drought.

So why does it happen at all?

In a paper recently released in the journal Nature, Simini and his colleagues Samir Suweis and Amos Maritan of the University of Padova and Jayanth Banavar of the University of Maryland present a so-called "variational principle" to explain the unexpected, though commonly observed, topology of mutualistic networks.

Called "nestedness," this type of architecture looks like a set of Russian Matryoshka dolls. The smallest doll comprises the most specialized species—for instance, the bacteria that can only survive inside a cow's stomach, where it pays rent by keep the cow's gut clean and healthy. The rest of the network, the outermost dolls, are made up of the links between more generalist species—the cows, the grass, and the bugs that can interact with each other plus a host of other species in the ecosystem.

By analyzing theoretical mutualistic networks via computational modeling, the researchers were able to show that communities with strong mutualistic interactions tended to be less nested, and thus more resilient. "When interaction strengths are weak, it becomes crucial for the community to organize into a highly nested architecture in order to maximize its population," said first author Suweis.

In mutually beneficial interactions, everyone wins. So, if a process maximizes one species' abundance, the community's total population will increase and thus tend further toward this nested architecture.

The system becomes more stable overall, but in the face of distress, it will take more time to return to normal. The system's resilience, according to the team's findings, is ultimately determined by the population of the rarest species: "The lower the population of the rarest species," said Simini, "the longer the time to recovery."

It turns out mutualistic networks don't just show up in the natural world. Other examples include creditors and debtors, academic collaborations, and even manufacturing networks. Regardless of their setting, be it a marine ecosystem or a financial boardroom, mutualistic networks will tend toward nestedness and Simini's work could go a long way toward explaining that phenomenon and its implications in a variety of settings.

Explore further: Beetles modify emissions of greenhouse gases from cow pats

More information:… ull/nature12438.html

Related Stories

Maths experts question key ecological theory

Jun 20, 2012

Mathematicians at the University of York in the UK and the University of Canterbury in New Zealand say they have disproved a widely accepted theory underpinning the operation of complex networks of interactions in the natural ...

Researchers examine 'nestedness' of industrial ecosystems

Nov 28, 2012

(—Biodiversity is a complex phenomenon that emerges from the combination of a large number of ecological mechanisms. Yet, despite the complexity of its origins, there is one prevalent pattern that always appears ...

Recommended for you

Chinese mosquitos on the Baltic Sea

26 minutes ago

The analysis of the roughly 3,000 pieces is still in its infant stage. But it is already evident that the results will be of major significance. "Amazingly often, we are finding–in addition to Asian forms–the ...

Baby zebra is latest success in research partnership

1 hour ago

The recent birth of a female Grevy's zebra foal at the Saint Louis Zoo marks another milestone in a long-running Washington University in St. Louis research partnership that is making significant contributions ...

'Killer sperm' prevents mating between worm species

19 hours ago

The classic definition of a biological species is the ability to breed within its group, and the inability to breed outside it. For instance, breeding a horse and a donkey may result in a live mule offspring, ...

Rare Sri Lankan leopards born in French zoo

22 hours ago

Two rare Sri Lankan leopard cubs have been born in a zoo in northern France, a boost for a sub-species that numbers only about 700 in the wild, the head of the facility said Tuesday.

Researcher reveals how amphibians crossed continents

Jul 29, 2014

There are more than 7,000 known species of amphibians that can be found in nearly every type of ecosystem on six continents. But there have been few attempts to understand exactly when and how frogs, toads, ...

User comments : 1

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

3 / 5 (2) Sep 02, 2013
Dang it, I really need to find a piece of glass to write math on so I can look cool too.