Researchers discover a tiny twist in bilayer graphene that may solve a mystery

Aug 12, 2013 by Lynn Yarris
New twist in the graphene story
The Dirac spectrum of bilayer graphene when the two layers are exactly aligned (left) shifts with a slight interlayer twist that breaks interlayer-coupling and potential symmetry, leading to a new spectrum with surprisingly strong signatures in ARPES data. Credit: Keun Su Kim, Fritz Haber Institute

Researchers with the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE)'s Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory (Berkeley Lab) have discovered a unique new twist to the story of graphene, sheets of pure carbon just one atom thick, and in the process appear to have solved a mystery that has held back device development.

Electrons can race through graphene at nearly the – 100 times faster than they move through silicon. In addition to being superthin and superfast when it comes to conducting electrons, graphene is also superstrong and superflexible, making it a potential superstar material in the electronics and fields, the basis for a host of devices, starting with ultrafast transistors. One big problem, however, has been that graphene's electron can't be completely stopped, an essential requirement for on/off devices.

The on/off problem stems from monolayers of graphene having no bandgaps – ranges of energy in which no electron states can exist. Without a , there is no way to control or modulate electron current and therefore no way to fully realize the enormous promise of graphene in electronic and photonic devices. Berkeley Lab researchers have been able to engineer precisely controlled bandgaps in bilayer graphene through the application of an external electric field. However, when devices were made with these engineered bandgaps, the devices behaved strangely, as if conduction in those bandgaps had not been stopped. Why such devices did not pan out has been a scientific mystery until now.

Working at Berkeley Lab's Advanced Light Source (ALS), a DOE national user facility, a research team led by ALS scientist Aaron Bostwick has discovered that in the stacking of graphene subtle misalignments arise, creating an almost imperceptible twist in the final bilayer graphene. Tiny as it is - as small as 0.1 degree - this twist can lead to surprisingly strong changes in the bilayer graphene's .

"The introduction of the twist generates a completely new electronic structure in the bilayer graphene that produces massive and massless Dirac fermions," says Bostwick. "The massless Dirac fermion branch produced by this new structure prevents bilayer graphene from becoming fully insulating even under a very strong electric field. This explains why bilayer graphene has not lived up to theoretical predictions in actual devices that were based on perfect or untwisted bilayer graphene."

Bostwick is the corresponding author of a paper describing this research in the journal Nature Materials titled "Coexisting massive and massless Dirac fermions in symmetry-broken bilayer graphene." Keun Su Kim of the Fritz Haber Institute in Berlin is the lead author Other coauthors are Andrew Walter, Luca Moreschini, Thomas Seyller, Karsten Horn, and Eli Rotenberg, who oversees the research at ALS Beamline 7.0.1.

Monolayers of graphene have no bandgaps – ranges of energy in which no electron states can exist. Without a bandgap, there is no way to control or modulate electron current and therefore no way to fully realize the enormous promise of graphene in electronic and . Berkeley Lab researchers have been able to engineer precisely controlled bandgaps in bilayer graphene through the application of an external electric field. However, when devices were made with these engineered bandgaps, the devices behaved strangely, as if conduction in those bandgaps had not been stopped.

To get to the bottom of this mystery, Rotenberg, Bostwick, Kim and their co-authors performed a series of angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy (ARPES) experiments at ALS beamline 7.0.1. ARPES is a technique for studying the electronic states of a solid material in which a beam of X-ray photons striking the material's surface causes the photoemission of electrons. The kinetic energy of these photoelectrons and the angles at which they are ejected are then measured to obtain an electronic spectrum.

"The combination of ARPES and Beamline 7.0.1 enabled us to easily identify the electronic spectrum from the twist in the bilayer graphene," says Rotenberg. "The spectrum we observed was very different from what has been assumed and contains extra branches consisting of massless Dirac fermions. These new massless Dirac fermions move in a completely unexpected way governed by the symmetry twisted layers."

Massless Dirac fermions, electrons that essentially behave as if they were photons, are not subject to the same bandgap constraints as conventional . In their Nature Materials paper, the authors state that the twists that generate this massless Dirac fermion spectrum may be nearly inevitable in the making of bilayer graphene and can be introduced as a result of only ten atomic misfits in a square micron of bilayer graphene.

"Now that we understand the problem, we can search for solutions," says lead author Kim. "For example, we can try to develop fabrication techniques that minimize the twist effects, or reduce the size of the bilayer graphene we make so that we have a better chance of producing locally pure material."

Beyond solving a bilayer graphene mystery, Kim and his colleagues say the discovery of the twist establishes a new framework on which various fundamental properties of bilayer graphene can be more accurately predicted.

"A lesson learned here is that even such a tiny structural distortion of atomic-scale materials should not be dismissed in describing the electronic properties of these materials fully and accurately," Kim says.

Explore further: Atom-thick CCD could capture images: Scientists develop two-dimensional, light-sensitive material

Related Stories

Imperfect graphene renders 'electrical highways'

Jul 12, 2013

(Phys.org) —Just an atom thick, 200 times stronger than steel and a near-perfect conductor, graphene's future in electronics is all but certain. But to make this carbon supermaterial useful, it needs to ...

Recommended for you

The simplest element: Turning hydrogen into 'graphene'

Dec 16, 2014

New work from Carnegie's Ivan Naumov and Russell Hemley delves into the chemistry underlying some surprising recent observations about hydrogen, and reveals remarkable parallels between hydrogen and graphene ...

Future batteries: Lithium-sulfur with a graphene wrapper

Dec 16, 2014

What do you get when you wrap a thin sheet of the "wonder material" graphene around a novel multifunctional sulfur electrode that combines an energy storage unit and electron/ion transfer networks? An extremely ...

User comments : 3

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

El_Nose
5 / 5 (1) Aug 12, 2013
paragraphs 3 and 7 are the same weird....

other than that -- all hours put into graphene will eventually pay off -- especially if a perfecting macroscale graphene ribbons pan out.

-- and i wish physorg would add graphene to their dictionary of terms so it isn;t underlined when i type

GSwift7
2.5 / 5 (2) Aug 13, 2013
and i wish physorg would add graphene to their dictionary of terms so it isn;t underlined when i type


That must be your web browser. I don't get any spell check in Internet Explorer, so it isn't the web site.

As for graphene, by the time it is ready (assuming it will be ready one day) it will just seem like steady progress in computer and device progress. They'll have to take a step backwards in design at first, as they learn how to work with new material, like how the first video games for a new console are never as good as the console is capable of.
FastEddy
1 / 5 (4) Aug 19, 2013
… all hours put into graphene will eventually pay off -- especially if perfecting macroscale graphene ribbons pan out. ...


We are working on that very thing. Looking for a site to test, engineer and manufacture such, Chicago area or Texas or ...

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.