Unnecessary oil disasters

Sep 11, 2012

The BP oil disaster in the Gulf of Mexico 2010 could have been avoided if the experiences of earlier disasters had been put to use, researcher Charles Woolfson, Linköping university, claims. The United States government is now accusing BP of gross negligence and deliberate misconduct, and taking the company to court.

On April 20, 2010, the Deepwater Horizon exploded in the ocean south of the southern coast of the US. The explosion led to the deaths of eleven people and an unfathomable environmental catastrophe.

Charles Woolfson, former professor of Labour Sociology in Glasgow and currently professor of Labour Studies at REMESO, Linköping university, conducted a large study of the world's biggest – the Piper Alpha – in the 1990s. 167 people lost their lives when this production platform sank into the in 1988.

In a new study, he now compares the two disasters and the (inadequate) culture of that caused them. He finds, he writes, several depressing similarities. If the right lessons had been learned from Piper Alpha, the accident at Deepwater Horizon would never have happened, he claims. The recommendation issued at that time should have become a turning point.

Woolfson points out a fundamental contradiction between safety and profitable production. In both disasters, there are examples of cost-cutting decisions that worsened safety. In the Deepwater Horizon case, a final independent test of the fateful cement seal was cancelled. The test would have cost USD 128,000 (EUR 101,000).

Woolfson has received unexpected support – from the , which recently submitted an application for a summons indictment through its Justice Department. The words and actions of the company concerning safety "should not be tolerated even in a medium-sized company producing goods for a ," according to the 39-page document.

Two other critical factors Woolfson emphasizes are what's known as "regulatory capture" and the fear-stricken, disunited employees.

Regulatory capture means that the independent agency inspecting an industry identifies itself more and more with the companies of that industry and their interests. This happened the , where the number of exemptions from various environmental requirements increased from three in 1997 to 795 in 2000, all to avoid "cumbersome and unnecessary delays" in production. A program for tightened safety regulations dragged through endless consulting processes with the industry and ultimately never came to anything.

Cutbacks also affected the regulatory agency. The shrinking number of inspectors lacked sufficient training, and became more and more dependent on the expertise and information of the oil companies. This is according to the Obama-appointed independent National Commission's own 2011 report on Deepwater Horizon. The same weakness was pointed out after Piper Alpha. The industry's promises on self-regulation, voluntary enforcement and standards of conduct effectively torpedoed all demands for stricter supervision of safety arrangements.

The hesitation among the employees and the fear of making independent decisions also affected the catastrophic development of events in both cases, Woolfson states. On Deepwater Horizon, for example, the crew dared not make a decision about activating an emergency system that could have constrained the disaster.

In total, BP has claims for damages against it totalling almost USD 70 billion (EUR 55.1 billion). The company denies all the accusations of negligence and misconduct.

"The fundamental questions we must ask are: What went wrong, who is responsible, and how can we prevent it from happening again?" Woolfson says.

"Industrial accidents don't just 'happen', they are often the result of a weak culture of safety and companies systematically failing to prioritize safety."

The study will be published in 2013 under the title "Safety failures the offshore oil industry: from Piper Alpha to Deepwater Horizon" in the book Governance, Change and the Working Environment, Amityville: Baywood Press, USA.

Explore further: Air in US cities getting cleaner, EPA says

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

BP accused of gross negligence in US spill

Sep 05, 2012

The US Justice Department has accused oil giant BP of "gross negligence and willful misconduct" in the massive 2010 Gulf of Mexico oil spill, in court documents obtained Wednesday.

Gulf of Mexico oil crew ignored warnings: probe

Aug 19, 2011

The crew of an oil rig that exploded in the Gulf of Mexico last year causing one of the worst oil spills in US history ignored warning signs a disaster was imminent, an investigator said Friday.

US eyes first BP criminal charges over Gulf spill: WSJ

Dec 29, 2011

US prosecutors are readying criminal charges against British oil giant BP employees over the 2010 Deepwater Horizon accident that led to the catastrophic Gulf oil spill, The Wall Street Journal reported online.

US Coast Guard slams Transocean

Apr 23, 2011

The US Coast Guard slammed drilling rig operator Transocean's "poor safety culture" in a report Friday on the massive explosion and fire that unleashed the biggest maritime oil spill in history.

BP says US oil spill trial could 'last until 2014'

Feb 26, 2012

British energy giant BP is prepared for a multi-billion-dollar US legal case into the massive Gulf of Mexico oil spill to last until 2014, its chief executive told the Sunday Telegraph.

Recommended for you

Climate change: meteorologists preparing for the worst

3 hours ago

Intense aerial turbulence, ice storms and scorching heatwaves, huge ocean waves—the world's climate experts forecast apocalyptic weather over the coming decades at a conference in Montreal that ended Thursday.

Sunlight, not microbes, key to CO2 in Arctic

4 hours ago

The vast reservoir of carbon stored in Arctic permafrost is gradually being converted to carbon dioxide (CO2) after entering the freshwater system in a process thought to be controlled largely by microbial ...

Drying Sierra meadows could worsen California drought

4 hours ago

Carpeting the high valleys of Yosemite and other parts of the Sierra Nevada, mountain meadows are more than an iconic part of the California landscape. The roughly 17,000 high altitude meadows help regulate ...

User comments : 3

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

tadchem
not rated yet Sep 11, 2012
The US government should share some responsibility. The agency cutbacks that resulted in 'shrinking numbers of inspectors' were a direct contributing factor. Had independent Federal inspectors inspected many problems could have been found before the disaster. The MSHA should have been expanded to have authority over drilling operations many years ago, but instead the US Bureau of Mines was eliminated and MSHA along with a few surviving agencies were downsized.
hemitite
not rated yet Sep 11, 2012
So are there necessary oil disasters?
Caliban
5 / 5 (2) Sep 11, 2012
The US government should share some responsibility. The agency cutbacks that resulted in 'shrinking numbers of inspectors' were a direct contributing factor. Had independent Federal inspectors inspected many problems could have been found before the disaster. The MSHA should have been expanded to have authority over drilling operations many years ago, but instead the US Bureau of Mines was eliminated and MSHA along with a few surviving agencies were downsized.


Don't you mean the powerful corporate interests that influence decision/policy making within the US government?