Physicists demonstrate first time reversal of water waves

August 23, 2012 by Lisa Zyga feature
In the water tank, Point A is the original source of the wave, while the surrounding R points correspond to positions where the wave is measured and re-emitted after the time reversal operation. Image credit: A. Przadka, et al. ©2012 American Physical Society

(—In spite of its name, the time reversal of a wave doesn't involve sending the wave back in time, but for scientists, the process is almost as compelling. After a source generates a wave, the wave propagates through a medium and is recorded at a few points in its surroundings by an optical method. Then, the wave is re-emitted in a way so that its energy focuses back at the initial source position, as though the wave were being played backwards. Because the wave precisely retraces its original path as it travels back to its source, its mathematical description is reversed in time but is otherwise exactly the same.

While scientists have extensively studied the time reversal of acoustic, elastic, and in previous research, a new study marks the first experimental demonstration of the time reversal of water waves. The researchers, from ESPCI ParisTech and CNRS in Paris and Le Mans, France, have published their results from the demonstration in a recent issue of Physical Review Letters.

The scientists explain that, although water waves are very common and easily observable, they are much more complicated than acoustic, elastic, and electromagnetic waves. For example, water waves are dispersive by nature and experience strong damping at small scales, meaning that wave decreases due to and with the bottom and walls of the water tank. Due to these complications – damping in particular – water waves have never been tested in a time reversal experiment, although they have been investigated theoretically.

But as the scientists demonstrate here, water waves in a small laboratory tank can still exhibit time reversal in spite of the strong damping. The researchers filled a 53 x 38 cm2 (21 x 15 in2) tank with water to a depth of 10 cm (4 in). To generate waves, they used a vertical vibrator in the middle of the tank, which can be considered as a point source. The surface elevation was measured in six different locations, then time-reversed and re-emitted, leading to the spatial and temporal wave refocalization at the source. The researchers demonstrated that the use of only one re-emitter can successfully refocus a wave.

This video is not supported by your browser at this time.
Experimental measurements of the surface elevation during the refocusing of a time-reversed wave: The waves begin as random waves, then converging wavefronts emerge and refocalize on the source point (at time t=0s). Then the wave diverges and at the end it creates a complex random pattern again. Image credit: A. Przadka, et al.

"This work clearly shows that time-reversal symmetry is really a universal concept in wave physics," coauthor Mathias Fink at CNRS in Paris told "It applies to any kind of waves: seismic, acoustic, electromagnetic, and water waves. It can be used to build time-reversal mirrors that are very robust devices, and despite the fact that we conducted water-wave time-reversal experiments in a reverberating cavity of chaotic shape, the time-reversed wave refocuses back exactly towards its source. We were surprised to see that despite the dissipative nature of water waves, the multiply reflected signals by the tank boundaries were strong enough to participate efficiently to the time-reversed waves, providing a better focusing quality even with a small number of vibrators."

To measure the waves, the researchers used an optical method called Fourier Transform Profilometry (FTP). The method enabled them to measure surface elevation with good spatial and temporal resolution, allowing them to recreate a map of surface elevation at different times.

"Once we measure the propagating wave, we choose a few points," explained coauthor Adam Przadka at CNRS in Paris. "At those points, we have a signal in time that we time-reverse numerically (we switch the signal). Then we generate waves by the conical wavemaker that moves vertically, inputting energy to the system."

The researchers also investigated how to improve the quality of the refocusing by using the multiple reflections from the tank boundaries, or in other words, the similarity of the original wave to the time-reversed wave. As expected, they found through their simulations that decreasing the damping to a negligible amount increases quality. However, negligible damping would be difficult to achieve in a lab experiment since it would require a the size of a swimming pool to minimize the contributions of damping. Another factor that increases quality is increasing the number of re-emitting channels.

While the current experiment illustrates the feasibility of the time reversal of water waves using just a few channels and with damping, simulations at larger scales, with negligible damping and more channels, indicate the possibility of very high-quality time reversal. These findings could pave the way toward a variety of ocean-based applications.

"The fact that time-reversed can be easily focused at any location in complex media can lead to interesting applications as water wave control in a harbor," Fink said. "For example, if in a harbor, there is a zone where there are usually high-amplitude waves due to constructive interference and to the geometry of the shallow water structure, you can imagine controlling this phenomenon by using a set of vibrators immersed in the sea that focuses waves out of phase of these patterns to allow the wave field. It is like an anti-noise technique for acoustics. There can also be interesting applications by time-reversing the wake radiated by a moving boat. The anti-wake created by this process can be an efficient way to remotely push a boat or a solid structure along the water surface."

Explore further: New research sheds light on freak wave hot spots

More information: A. Przadka, et al. "Time Reversal of Water Waves." PRL 109, 064501 (2012). DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.109.064501

Fluid Dynamics Video for the Gallery of Fluid Motion: arXiv:1010.3311v1 [physics.flu-dyn]

Journal reference: Physical Review Letters search and more info website


Related Stories

New research sheds light on freak wave hot spots

August 5, 2009

Stories of ships mysteriously sent to watery graves by sudden, giant waves have long puzzled scientists and sailors. New research by San Francisco State professor Tim Janssen suggests that changes in water depth and currents, ...

Rogue wave recreated in laboratory tank

May 24, 2011

( -- A team of researchers have used a mathematical equation to create a so called "rogue" wave; the giant kind that appear out of nowhere in the open ocean to topple ships and drown their crews. Using one solution ...

Coke cans focus sound waves beyond the diffraction limit

July 12, 2011

( -- When trying to focus sound waves into as small an area as possible, scientists run into a fundamental limit called the diffraction limit. That is, when sound waves are focused into a region smaller than one ...

Scientists discover new water waves

July 19, 2011

( -- By precisely shaking a container of shallow water, researchers have observed wave behavior that has never been seen before. In a new study, Jean Rajchenbach, Alphonse Leroux, and Didier Clamond of the University ...

Lego pirate proves, survives, super rogue wave

April 4, 2012

( -- Scientists have used a Lego pirate floating in a fish tank to demonstrate for the first time that so-called ‘super rogue waves’ can come from nowhere in apparently calm seas and engulf ships.

Recommended for you

Exploring the physics of a chocolate fountain

November 24, 2015

A mathematics student has worked out the secrets of how chocolate behaves in a chocolate fountain, answering the age-old question of why the falling 'curtain' of chocolate surprisingly pulls inwards rather than going straight ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

1 / 5 (4) Aug 23, 2012
Wow! Freaking magic. Smart people are kicking my booty all over the place. How do they do that?
1 / 5 (4) Aug 23, 2012
While scientists have extensively studied the time reversal of acoustic, elastic, and electromagnetic waves in previous research, a new study marks the first experimental demonstration of the time reversal of water waves.

By the way, it is interesting to note that conventionally electromagnetic waves need no medium to be the carrier, so how could they work in the same way as the others? May be the believed that electromagnetic waves could be travel by themselves (via mutual creation between electric and magnetic field) was misinterpreted! The reason is that both the fields are created at the same time, then how could they do that; it violates the principle of causality (explained below)!
not rated yet Aug 24, 2012
Help me understand this. They call it time-reversal, but they are not sending the waves back in time; they are causing the waves to reverse themselves so they arrive back at their original propagation point. So why do they call it "time-reversal" and not "wave propagation reversal"?
Aug 24, 2012
This comment has been removed by a moderator.
5 / 5 (3) Aug 24, 2012
@ vacuum-mechanics:

Time reversal and wave mechanics physics has nothing to do with a medium. EM waves are waves in a fundamental field, mechanical water, acoustical or elastic waves are waves in matter.

@ theskepticalpsychic:

That is a very good question!

The unwritten context is that of physics, where the time-reversal symmetry the article mentions is both standing out from the non-reversible everyday physics we note (a dropped egg can't be reassembled) and an important characteristic of fundamental physical theories.

You can only make sense of systems like chemistry if they are time-reversal symmetric at the lowest scales. (Non-reversible physics happens on large, system, scales, such as heat dissipation to the environment.)

The existence of this characteristic in many systems results in that physicists want to test that physics where they can predict it, such as in water waves.

And that preexisting context is why the term comes out funny.
not rated yet Aug 24, 2012
These articles are being dumbed down so that the average person can understand it. Why didn't they also explain the scientific context?
not rated yet Aug 24, 2012
I am not seeing any breakthroughs here.

Waves can be reflected. "Time reversal" seems to be the special case where the angles of reflection return the waves to their origin.

Neutralizing waves - as in sound-canceling systems - is not new. But the idea of applying it to canceling dangerous waves in a harbor is kinda new. It's new because you'd need to expend tremendous energy to accomplish that cancelation. Water waves in a harbor can carry huge amounts of energy; there's a lot of mass being displaced.

Nothing in this experiment suggests that there is a low-energy, efficient way to cancel harbor waves. So the researchers are overreaching to suggest that application.

Now if they had demonstrated that they could get more efficient propulsion out of a boat by canceling its wake than by investing the same energy in other ways, then that might be interesting. But they did not demonstrate it. Speculation is great, but it's not a breakthrough until the point is proven.
Aug 24, 2012
This comment has been removed by a moderator.
not rated yet Aug 24, 2012
not rated yet Aug 27, 2012
Does it follow from this experiment that it is possible, at least in theory, to reverse-engineer the tides of oblivion? That'd be a neat trick.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.