Research duo discover why non-Newtonian fluids harden on impact

Jul 12, 2012 by Bob Yirka report

(Phys.org) -- Researchers and laymen alike know that some non-Newtonian fluids tend to harden quickly upon impact. Quicksand is a good example. If a person walks quickly, they won’t sink. But why this happens has been somewhat of a mystery, though many in the science community have suspected it had something to do with energy being transferred to the walls of the container. New research finds that’s not the case at all. Instead, after extensive testing and experimentation Scott Waitukaitis and Heinrich Jaeger of the University of Chicago have found, as they describe in their paper published in the journal Nature, that it’s because the particles suspended in the liquid temporarily mash together, creating a near solid.

Non-Newtonian liquids are those that don’t behave as Isaac Newton originally theorized, e.g. quicksand, ketchup, custard, blood, or in the case of the material studied by the research team, a water and cornstarch solution called oobleck.

This video is not supported by your browser at this time.
Cornstarch and water is a smart material derived from simple components. This video shows a bowling ball bouncing off the surface of the mixture, which also can catch a dropped egg without breaking it. Credit: Heinrich Jaeger/University of Chicago

To find out what goes on with oobleck when impacted from above, Waitukaitis set up several different sized tanks of the goo and filmed what happens when a flat bottomed rod strikes its surface from above at varying speeds. He also pointed an x-ray gun at the mix to see what happens underneath the surface and used a laser pointed across the surface to measure how its surface changed when impacted along with a force sensor on the bottom of the tank directly beneath the impact zone.

This video is not supported by your browser at this time.
This seven-second video shows a narrow aluminum rod striking the surface of a cornstarch and water mixture at a speed of one meter (3.2 feet) per second. Recorded at 10,000 frames per second with a high-speed camera, the video shows that the rod creates a bowl-like depression around the impact site but fails to penetrate the surface of the fluidic mixture. Credit: Scott Waitukaitis/University of Chicago

In studying the results, the two found that the size of the tank didn’t matter as the oobleck hardened the same amount regardless. Thus, theories about energy absorption by the walls accounting for the unusual liquid properties are wrong. Instead they found that the tiny particles that are normally suspended in the liquid are suddenly jammed together when impacted from above, creating a cone like shape inside the liquid that is dense enough to be described as a temporary solid; as it just as quickly dissolves back to its original state. The authors describe the action as akin to snow that is suddenly pushed into a denser state by a plow.

The study does answer the major question of why a non-Newtonian liquid hardens, but still a mystery is what happens with the suspended particles when in their hardened state. Do they touch each other or just come close and why do they move apart again after the initial impact? Also, are there differences in hardening as particles get smaller and smaller? Future researchers will no doubt be looking into answering such questions as non-Newtonian liquids might become more useful if their properties become better understood. They might serve as a lighter material in bullet-proof vests for example, or provide a better cushion for people involved in a car crash.

Explore further: Researchers study gallium to design adjustable electronic components

More information: Impact-activated solidification of dense suspensions via dynamic jamming fronts, Nature 487, 205–209 (12 July 2012). doi:10.1038/nature11187

Abstract
Although liquids typically flow around intruding objects, a counterintuitive phenomenon occurs in dense suspensions of micrometre-sized particles: they become liquid-like when perturbed lightly, but harden when driven strongly. Rheological experiments have investigated how such thickening arises under shear, and linked it to hydrodynamic interactions or…

See also: Press release

Related Stories

Cell membranes behave like cornstarch and water

Nov 03, 2010

(PhysOrg.com) -- Surprising discovery by physicists at the University of Oregon overturns a long-held belief, and raises fresh new scientific questions about the biology that regulates lipid and protein mobility.

Smashing fluids... the physics of flow

Nov 29, 2010

(PhysOrg.com) -- Hit it hard and it will fracture like a solid... but tilt it slowly and it will flow like a fluid. This is the intriguing property of a type of ‘complex fluid’ which has revealed ...

Recommended for you

User comments : 6

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

MrVibrating
5 / 5 (1) Jul 12, 2012
Fascinating - a kind of spontaneous phase change, almost..?

The article makes an analogy to snow being compacted by a plow, however another, perhaps closer analogy might be how ice is instantaneously compacted to water and back again as a skater passes over it...?
Bewia
2 / 5 (4) Jul 12, 2012
..theories about energy absorption by the walls accounting for the unusual liquid properties are wrong..
I doubt, someone could consider such theories seriously, because the dilatant behavior works even for materials without any walls, which is tested for body armor applications.
JRi
5 / 5 (2) Jul 12, 2012
I'm surprised this phenomenon hasn't been thoroughly studied already long time ago. A Nature article from starch-water suspension in 2012... Wooah!
jeandavid54
not rated yet Jul 16, 2012
I think that not only fluids do have this hardening reaction at impact. Any elastic material gets hardened at impact due to instant compression as the result of the deformation of the contact surface. Fluids, naturally penetrable at slow speed, just make it more obvious. For example, a bullet impact in a soft brick wall. The first layers of the brick get hardened enough to deform the solid metal bullet before a hole gets created. High speed impacts imply great inertial acceleration for those tiny components to get instant compression and higher material density.
Satene
1 / 5 (3) Jul 16, 2012
People often behave like the particle systems, when they get stuck against new ideas because of their mutual social interactions.
jeandavid54
not rated yet Jul 16, 2012
After the previous post, I just remember that we experience the compacting of fluid each time we swim. Without the hardening of water under our strokes, we are then unable to move forward. Olympic swimmers make speedy and powerful strokes to get "hardened water" to go faster.