Dissonant music brings out the animal in listeners: researchers

Jun 12, 2012 By Meg Sullivan
Dissonant music brings out the animal in listeners: researchers
Jimi Hendrix

(Phys.org) -- Ever wonder why Jimi Hendrix's rendition of "The Star-Spangled Banner" moved so many people in 1969 or why the music in the shower scene of "Psycho" still sends chills down your spine?

A UCLA-based team of researchers has isolated some of the ways in which distorted and jarring is so evocative, and they believe that the mechanisms are closely related to distress calls in animals.

They report their findings in the latest issue of the peer-reviewed scientific journal Biology Letters, which publishes online June 12.

"Music that shares aural characteristics with the of distressed animals captures human attention and is uniquely arousing," said Daniel Blumstein, one of the study's authors and chair of the UCLA Department of Ecology and .

Blumstein is an authority on animal distress calls, particularly among . In 2010, he and a team of researchers captured media attention with a study of the soundtracks of 102 classic movies in four genres: adventure, drama, horror and war. They determined that the soundtracks for each genre possessed characteristic emotion-manipulating techniques. Scores for dramatic films, for example, had more abrupt shifts in frequency, both up and down. Horror films, on the other hand, had more screaming females and distorted sounds. The researchers were even able to detect recordings of animal screams in some scores.

The latest findings are based on a series of experiments that Blumstein designed and conducted with Peter Kaye, a Santa Monica–based composer of movie and television scores, and Greg Bryant, an assistant professor of communication studies at UCLA who specializes in research on vocal communication and evolutionary psychology. In addition to being an academic, Bryant is a musician and recording engineer.

Using synthesizers, Kaye and Bryant composed a series of original music pieces of several types or "conditions," with each piece lasting just 10 seconds. "We wanted to see if we could enhance or suppress the listener's feelings based on what's going on with the music," Blumstein said.

In the control condition, the music was generic and emotionally neutral, without noise or abrupt transitions in frequency or pitch. Bryant likened it to rather plain elevator music.

Another condition began in an easy-listening manner but then suddenly broke into distortion, much like Hendrix famously did at Woodstock.

This video is not supported by your browser at this time.
an example of the control condition

This video is not supported by your browser at this time.
the distortion condition

Undergraduate students were asked to listen to an example of each condition and then rate the examples based on two factors: how arousing they found the music and whether the emotional feeling in the music was positive (such as happy) or negative (such as fear-inducing or sad). No subject heard more than one example from any condition.

When the music featured distortion, subjects rated it as more exciting than the compositions without distortion. They also were more likely to describe the music as charged with negative emotion.

The researchers believe the effect of listening to music with distortion is similar to hearing the cries of animals in distress, a condition that distorts animals' voices by forcing a large amount of air rapidly through the voice box.

"This study helps explain why the distortion of rock 'n' roll gets people excited: It brings out the animal in us," said Bryant.

The researchers also believe their study is the first work to incorporate what scientists know about animal communication into the study of music perception.

"Composers have intuitive knowledge of what sounds scary without knowing why," Bryant said. "What they usually don't realize is that they're exploiting our evolved predispositions to get excited and have negative emotions when hearing certain sounds."

Most of the effects, however, are undermined if the music is paired with unevocative imagery, the researchers found.

In a second study, they paired the same music compositions with 10-second video clips designed to be minimally evocative, showing, for example, people walking or drinking a sip of coffee. The researchers presented the pairings to another group of undergraduates. When the subjects heard the distorted musical pieces in the context of the videos, they did not find the music arousing but they did find the pieces more negative than when they were not paired with the videos.

"The video eliminated how exciting the distorted-sounding music seemed, but it didn't trump the emotional content of the music," Bryant said.

In the future, the researchers plan to test how different types of music affect a listener's nervous system. Past research has shown that calls of distress raise heart rates and skin conductance among animals.

"We need to study this more to understand the physiological mechanisms by which this works," Kaye said.

Explore further: Lupin bread rises to the quality challenge

Related Stories

Feeling chills in response to music

Dec 07, 2010

Most people feel chills and shivers in response to music that thrills them, but some people feel these chills often and others feel them hardly at all. People who are particularly open to new experiences are most likely to ...

Music choice reflects mood

Jun 08, 2012

(Phys.org) -- What kind of music are you in the mood for? A new smartphone app designed to recommend music according to how listeners feel could provide insight into teen mental health.

Music reduces anxiety in cancer patients

Aug 10, 2011

(Medical Xpress) -- Cancer patients may benefit from sessions with trained music therapists or from listening to music. A new Cochrane systematic review shows using music can reduce anxiety in cancer patients, and may also ...

Recommended for you

Secret wing colours attract female fruit flies

2 hours ago

Bright colours appear on a fruit fly's transparent wings against a dark background as a result of light refraction. Researchers from Lund University in Sweden have now demonstrated that females choose a mate ...

Crowdsourced power to solve microbe mysteries

4 hours ago

University of New South Wales scientists hope to unlock the secrets of millions of marine microbes from waters as far apart as Sydney's Botany Bay and the Amazon River in Brazil, with the help of an international ...

Pigeons and people play the odds when rewards are higher

5 hours ago

(Phys.org) —If you were weighing the risks, would you choose to receive a guaranteed $100, or take a 50/50 chance of winning either $200 or nothing? Researchers at the University of Alberta have shown that ...

User comments : 6

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

MrVibrating
2 / 5 (2) Jun 12, 2012
A pathetically wishy-washy analysis, if typical of much psychomusicology... Consonance and dissonance are but degrees of equivalence - the objective value we're analysing is degree of difference (as compared to octave equivalence), as a function of complexity (complexity in terms of the size of the resolving ratio between two tones and thus the size of the temporal integration window necessary to resolve their relationship). Music is the creative afterbirth of how we represent meta-information - the relationships between frequency stimuli can only be weighted with respect to equivalence because all frequencies in a factor of two relationship are perceived as containing no meta-information (ie. there is no information about their difference, hence they sound "the same")... Octave equivalence is an informational "zero point" in the language of our operating system..

It's all organised by efficiency... Dissonance costs CPU time...
Haaa Haaa0
not rated yet Jun 13, 2012
This is really cool...I just wrote my High School Senior paper on this subject, very nice to see my thesis confirmed by somebody other than, well, a high-schooler. Can't wait to see more on this!
MrVibrating
2.5 / 5 (2) Jun 13, 2012
..right, so the tritone sounds dissonant because it's reminiscent of a pained animal? And similarly a fifth sounds consonant because it's evocative of our mother's vocal reassurances during infancy? And rhythm reminds us of her heartbeat..? Etc..

This is not scientific understanding, it is vacuous hand-wavy conjecture. Music is far more fundamental than this... It's an innate consequence of how we process information, across the board, at the lowest level.
Archea
1 / 5 (1) Jun 13, 2012
Actually on the dissonance of Brownian noise and similar sounds the various online hypnotist sound generators are based - the brain simply gets tired soon with attempts to analyse some patterns in it.
Anda
not rated yet Jun 13, 2012
Hey "mr. Vibrating"... You talk too much sh.. about consonance and dissonance like a BIG expert...

The article is about distortion and yes... It gets me excited like an animal.
Long life R&R
MrVibrating
not rated yet Jun 13, 2012
You ARE an animal, and distortion = amplitude clipping, it's generally characteristic of a stressed system, be it an animal or a saturated amplifier circuit. Hell, some of the scores analysed even contained animal screams - it's a completely trite correlation with nothing whatsoever to say about causation.

And sorry but i am prone to rant when i read such nebulous attempts at reasoning. No i'm not an expert in pyschoacoustics but i am a long-time afficionado... Prof. Blumstein on the other hand is an expert on animal distress calls (especially marmots, apparently).. Thus the conclusions are about as objective as an oceanologist claiming un-distorted tones are calming because they're reminiscent of waves at sea... it's "not even wrong".