US scrambles to dig out of a rare earths hole

Feb 24, 2011 By Tiffany Hsu

In the Mojave Desert just off Interstate 15 on the way to Las Vegas, workers are digging for dirt that may be worth far more than a casino full of chips.

The massive hole is about to get even bigger. Molycorp Inc., which owns the open mine, plans to dig out about 40,000 tons of dirt a year by 2014, up 1,200 percent from the current rate of about 3,000 tons.

The Colorado company is boosting production to meet an insatiable global appetite for rare earth elements - minerals that have become a hot commodity because they're used in all kinds of electronics, including smart phone touch screens, and fuel cells.

The U.S. clean-tech industry, which relies heavily on the minerals, is elated by the stepped-up production rate, but some believe it is not coming soon enough. In recent months the industry has been in a bit of a panic after China, which produces 97 percent of the world's supply of , slashed its exports to a trickle to feed its growing domestic needs.

Rare earth shortages could cause companies already weakened by the recession to shrivel or stall, industry officials say. Molycorp's Mountain Pass mine produces about 3 percent of the world's rare earths, but the company plans to eventually turn out a quarter of the total supply.

"The use of these materials has really skyrocketed, with demand outstripping supply literally overnight," said Molycorp Chief Executive Mark A. Smith. "We've got some serious issues in this industry. It's going to be a tough year."

The mine, about 16 miles from the Nevada border, has one of the world's largest deposits of rare earth elements outside Asia and is the only commercial producer in the Western Hemisphere. The elements - 17 total, all with tongue-twisting names such as neodymium and dysprosium - are crucial to the clean-tech and high-tech industries.

aren't actually rare, having picked up the misleading name in the 18th and 19th centuries before it was clear how common they actually are. Cerium, one of the elements that is sometimes used as a catalyst for self-cleaning ovens, is more abundant in the Earth's crust than copper or lead.

But mining for rare earths is difficult and expensive. The elements are usually found scattered in small fragments among rocks and must be separated and then processed.

The procedure is rarely eco-friendly, creating hundreds of gallons of salty wastewater per minute, consuming huge amounts of electricity, requiring toxic materials for the refining process and occasionally unearthing dirt that is radioactive.

The high costs and damaging techniques pushed most rare earth mines out of business in the early 1990s. Only China kept its mines going, positioning itself for the ensuing high-tech boom and the resulting rare earth-hungry products.

"Bottom line, we fell asleep as a country and as an industry," Smith said. "We got very used to these really low prices coming out of Asia and never really thought about it from a supply-chain standpoint."

But recently, China began cracking down on illegal rare-earth mining operations that had cropped up there because of the high demand. As shipments of the materials dwindled in the last year, prices have soared. Cerium, for example, jumped more than 600 percent, from less than $10 a kilogram to nearly $70.

The supply squeeze has raised tensions in the delicate relationship between the U.S. clean-tech industry and its Asian counterpart. The U.S. trade representative's office has said that if China continues to rebuff requests to ease export limits on rare earths, it may take the dispute to the World Trade Organization.

"We better get on the ball here, or our green industries are going to be at the complete mercy of China," said Jack Lifton, co-founder of the rare commodities research firm Technology Metals Research.

Many hope the Mountain Pass facility will help loosen China's chokehold on rare earths mining and manufacturing. Investors recently pushed Molycorp stock to $50 a share from its $13.25 debut price in July.

The company is spending more than $500 million to modernize and rebuild the 2,200-acre facility. The project is expected to create hundreds of permanent jobs and eventually produce rare earths at cheaper rates than mines in China.

The California mine was discovered in the 1940s by uranium prospectors and at one point became the world's largest supplier of rare earths as the demand for europium, which is used for color television screens, surged in the 1960s.

But the mine went dormant for several years after an uproar over environmental concerns in the early 2000s. Mining efforts left mounds of tailings, or leftover dirt, around the property.

Molycorp is now cleaning up the site, implementing a water recycling program, constructing an on-site natural gas power plant and planning to work the tailings back into the surrounding landscape.

San Bernardino County officials hope the activity attracts battery manufacturers and other clean-tech companies, creating a hub of research and innovation in the area.

The U.S. rare earths industry is hoping other domestic mines will open.

The U.S. Geological Survey has identified several sites where rare earths could be mined. Congress is considering proposals, some pushing for loan guarantees for rare earths suppliers, to encourage more domestic research and production. Other countries, including Australia, Canada and Brazil, are also on the hunt for more sites.

But developing a new mine from scratch requires prospecting, exploration, permitting and construction.

And even if more mines open in the U.S., the country has few companies that can process rare earths, use them to manufacture batteries and magnets and work them into products. Without a domestic supply chain, most of the material extracted in the U.S. would have to be shipped overseas anyway.

There aren't many researchers or industry workers in the U.S. with experience working with rare earths. Not long ago, Molycorp recruiters were unable to find potential hires or even universities that offered rare earths courses. The company has 22 scientists exploring uses and sources of the elements; China has thousands.

"It takes a lot to go from some dirt in the ground to magnets," said Lifton, the analyst. "Finding a deposit is like saying, 'George Washington slept here.' It doesn't mean much. We've got enough bananas, but now we've got to figure out how to make banana splits."

But some clean-tech executives said that the industry may be relying too much on rare earths. Metallurgy experts point to the cobalt crisis of the late 1970s as an example. The element - used in alloys, batteries, pigments and more - was in short supply as political unrest locked down the primary reserves in Africa just as demand was starting to boom.

"Tomorrow, it'll be something else," said Alexander King, director of the Ames Laboratory in Iowa, run by the Energy Department. "The thing we need to learn is how to control the economics, to develop alternative materials on a very short turnaround."

Some suggest recycling existing rare earths materials - known as "urban mining." Others are considering using substitute materials such as aluminum, copper and iron in place of rare earths.

Toyota Motor Corp., which uses rare earths for hybrids like the Toyota Prius, said it plans to switch to a special induction motor that doesn't require the elements. Battery-powered vehicles such as the Nissan Leaf and the Chevrolet Volt use rare earth magnets that are more compact than other options.

But managing fluctuating supply is a "normal risk of doing business," said Pete Savagian, chief engineer for electric motors for General Motors Co. If rare earths run low or are priced out of the market, the automaker will adapt, he said.

"Rare earth magnets are great to have, but they're also not the only way," he said. "We'll go forward using the best methods we have."

Explore further: Nokia turnaround since handset unit sale continues

4 /5 (7 votes)
add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Rare-earth mining operation to revive in US

Dec 21, 2010

After signing deals with major Japanese trading houses that have been rushing to secure new sources of rare earths, mining company Molycorp Inc. plans to restart its rare-earth mining in California by the end of the year.

China announces shakeup of rare earths industry

Feb 16, 2011

(AP) -- China plans to tighten control over rare earths producers and restrict output in a five-year development strategy, the Cabinet said Wednesday, amid concern abroad about plans to reduce exports of the exotic minerals ...

China tries to calm unease over rare earths curbs

Sep 03, 2009

(AP) -- A Chinese official tried to calm unease about curbs on exports of rare earths used in clean energy products and superconductors, saying Thursday that sales will continue but must be limited to reduce damage to China's ...

Toyota developing alternative electric motor

Jan 17, 2011

Toyota Motor Corp., maker of the popular Prius hybrid car, is developing a new type of electric motor to cut its dependence on rare earth metals and lower costs, a company spokesman said Monday.

China says rare earths not a 'bargaining tool'

Oct 28, 2010

(AP) -- China said Thursday it will not use exports of rare earths, exotic minerals required by high-tech industry, as a diplomatic "bargaining tool" while Washington pressed Beijing to clarify its policy following its de ...

Premier: China won't block rare earth exports

Oct 08, 2010

(AP) -- China is not using its control over supplies of rare earth - exotic metals crucial in advanced manufacturing - as a diplomatic "bargaining chip," state media quoted Premier Wen Jiabao as saying during ...

Recommended for you

Nokia turnaround since handset unit sale continues

5 hours ago

Nokia appears to have turned around its fortunes after the sale of its ailing cellphone unit to Microsoft, reporting a third-quarter net profit of 747 million euros ($950 million), from a loss of 91 million euros a year earlier. ...

Yahoo CEO defends strategy in face of criticism

5 hours ago

Signaling her reign has reached a pivotal juncture, Yahoo CEO Marissa Mayer is trying to convince restless shareholders that the long-struggling Internet company is heading in the right direction.

Sk Hynix logs all-time high Q3 earnings

5 hours ago

SK Hynix, the world's second-largest memory chip maker, reported Thursday a record high quarterly net profit for the three months to September on strong sales and currency earnings.

User comments : 8

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

holoman
not rated yet Feb 24, 2011
Molycorp process is really nice, looks like they
have a great solution for preventing pollution and
recycling toxic materials.
unknownorgin
4.3 / 5 (3) Feb 25, 2011
It looks like the new "clean /green" tech is just like the old tech in that it all depends on mining. The choice is simple ,stop all mining and squat in a cave somewhere or realize we all depend on mining and work with it ,not against it.

StandingBear
2.6 / 5 (5) Feb 25, 2011
Let the environmentalists give up their secret Chinese pay checks and squat their unemployed butts in a cold cave while we of the real world take full advantage of the technology that the ingenuity of man has provided with God's help. More power to our brother Californians in their mining venture in breaking the Chinese cartel in rare earths. We will need some of this stuff for our nuclear/electric space propulsion engines among a great many other uses.
ereneon
5 / 5 (1) Feb 25, 2011
Clean tech isn't so clean after all... It is sad when people let marketing overwhelm their reasoning. Molycorp sounds like they are on the right track at least (assuming things don't get all corrupt like they sadly often do). The world is better off with rare earths being mined under strict US pollution laws (or other countries with strict pollution laws) rather than lax Chinese laws. If not done carefully, rare earth mining can produce everything from radioactive runoff (from uranium and other radioactive elements often found with rare earths) to toxic gases from processing.
kaasinees
1 / 5 (1) Feb 25, 2011
As long as wastes are reused and dont enter ecological systems this is a very clean technique. However reading that they are going to use a gas plant, there is gas entered in the atmosphere. Atleast its cleaner...
CSharpner
not rated yet Feb 25, 2011
I thought the worries about China were considered a conspiracy theory and "racist"? Guess it's actually a real threat.

Hats off to Molycorp for helping with the world's needs and for doing it, apparently, in a clean way.
geokstr
1 / 5 (1) Feb 26, 2011
We should have a pool - closest to when the EPA shuts this down wins.
Justsayin
not rated yet Mar 08, 2011
Since at least 2005 China has been saying it would reduce exports of these rare earths and finally in 2006 it announced a 35% reduction in exports and they followed through some time later so this is not a surprise. I am no defender of communist China but I got to call it like it is.