Artificial intelligence not trusted for financial advice

robots and money
Credit: Pixabay/CC0 Public Domain

We trust Siri to give us directions, are happy to use a self-checkout at the supermarket, and the introduction of driverless cars is eagerly awaited by many, yet it seems bank customers are not ready to accept investment advice from artificial intelligence bots.

Banks have been investing heavily in the use of (AI) and automation, with virtual bots frequently replacing human service staff in -controlled self-service.

This has led to the growth of robo-advisers, which are that provide automated, algorithm-driven financial advice with little or no human supervision. In the U.S. alone, it is projected robo-advisers will soon be managing over $1 trillion of Americans' wealth.

A study by Griffith University researchers, titled "Man vs Machine," has assessed the faith customers had in computer-generated investment advice, and found that while things like opening an account and depositing smaller amounts (up to around $1,000) were seen as acceptable, when the amount increases customers are more likely to demand that a human is involved.

The study is published in the International Journal of Bank Marketing.

Lead author Dr. Gavin Northey said there were some notable advantages to AI.

"Artificial intelligence reduces the chance of human error, it reduces judgment bias and it gives greater forecasting accuracy and precision," he said. "Even though it may offer equally good, if not better, , consumers tend to consider the performance of AI as inferior to that of a human expert provider."

Co-author Vanessa Hunter emphasized that the doubt becomes a lot more apparent in higher risk environments.

"Even though technology is so ubiquitous, there's still that mistrust of AI and those Terminator sort of storylines," she said.

"Thinking back to when airlines introduced self-baggage drop, or supermarkets brought in self-checkouts, people embraced it to an extent, but there still needs to be a person nearby to guide people through the technology.

"We're incredibly social creatures. We want human interaction when risk is involved.

"The irony here, is the humans are using the same technology. They use the AI to form and provide their considered opinion."

In what's likely to be a multi-billion if not multi-trillion-dollar industry for digital online banking, Hunter suggests banks will need to be very careful with how they project themselves as being technologically based.

"It is sort of counter-intuitive considering where we're at in terms of digital marketing and online use, but the data shows customers, in particular wealthier investors, lose in the bank and are less willing to invest if they are only offered AI ."

More information: Gavin Northey et al, Man vs machine: how artificial intelligence in banking influences consumer belief in financial advice, International Journal of Bank Marketing (2022). DOI: 10.1108/IJBM-09-2021-0439

Citation: Artificial intelligence not trusted for financial advice (2022, October 11) retrieved 6 February 2023 from
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

Explore further

How likely are consumers to adopt artificial intelligence for banking advice?


Feedback to editors