Porpoises seem to cooperate in surprisingly sophisticated group hunting
When sailing along on the seas and you suddenly spot a porpoise's fin in the distance, chances are that you have only encountered a single animal. Porpoises are most often seen alone, but new research now suggests that they also roam in groups—and even enter into a sophisticated collaboration when hunting.
"The way they collaborate surprises us, because the common perception among biologists is that porpoises roam and hunt alone," says Associate Professor Magnus Wahlberg, who is an expert in marine mammals and heads the Marine Biological Research Centre at the University of Southern Denmark (SDU).
Drone footage has revealed group hunting among porpoises coming together to hunt schools of fish.
The research team has recorded almost 44 hours of drone footage from the waters around Funen, corresponding to 159 hunting sequences. In 95 of these, between two and six adult porpoises participated. The researchers expected to see the porpoises hunting alone. And if it turned out that several porpoises were in fact hunting together, the researchers expected that it would be an unstructured hunt without no cooperation whatsoever between the individual animals.
"Instead, a seemingly solitary animal has turned out to be more social than previously thought," says Ph.D. student Sara Torres Ortiz, who was at SDU when the research was conducted but is now at the Max Planck Institute for Ornithology in Germany. She researches animal cognition.
The footage also shows porpoises hunting alone. According to the researchers, solitary hunters are less successful at foraging food than the porpoises that hunt in groups.
In order to hunt in the observed way, the porpoises must be able to share information and coordinate their actions. They take on different roles during the hunt, and the drone footage has revealed six different roles:
- The distant gatherer (far bordering) swims around the school of fish at a distance of at least three body lengths.
- The close gatherer (close bordering) swims around the school of fish at a distance closer than three body lengths and with its body and head parallel to the school of fish.
- The shepherd (herding fish) swims close to the school of fish and influences its direction.
- The splitter (cross school) swims through the school
- The spear (hunting attempt) swims directly into the school at high speed
- Swimming away—swims away from the school.
Each porpoise can take on different roles during the hunt, and the result of the collaboration is that the school of fish eventually becomes so confused and exhausted that the individual hunters are able to capture the fish that stray away from the school.
"There are several different types of group hunting in the animal kingdom. The form observed can be called a form of collaborative hunting, and it is more sophisticated than the form called cooperative hunting," explains Ortiz.
Animals such as chimpanzees and raves exhibit cooperative hunting abilities. During this form of hunting, several hunters gather without taking on different roles.
The collaborative hunt, in which the individual hunters take on different roles, is more rare—or, rather: It is not observed very often because it is inherently difficult to follow. The use of drones opens up new possibilities of following a herd of animals from above—like this porpoise study—and this may in the future contribute with new and improved knowledge about hunting animals.
Until now, collaborative hunting has been scientifically described in animals such as lions, fossas, wolves and jackals. Wolves and jackals divide the hunting pack into two teams, where one team lurks while the other team drives the prey forward. Among lions, the strategy is for the entire pack to approach the prey from different directions, after which some hunters lie down to hide while the rest of the group drives the prey towards them.
Sea-dwelling predators are extra difficult to observe, meaning researchers cannot say with certainty whether animals like killer whales and dolphins hunt cooperatively and/or collaboratively. However, several researchers have observed complex hunting behaviors in killer whales and dolphins. For example, killer whales have been seen making waves that push seals off ice floes.
What other surprises await?
The drone footage now raises new questions:
Does the hunting group consist of the same individuals every time, or is it randomly composed? How often do participants change roles? And do porpoises enter into other social relations with each other?
"Drones have truly changed the possibilities of studying marine animals, and it will be exciting to see if they can surprise us again," says Ortiz.
More information: Sara Torres Ortiz et al, Group hunting in harbour porpoises (Phocoena phocoena), Canadian Journal of Zoology (2021). DOI: 10.1139/cjz-2020-0289
Provided by University of Southern Denmark