Isolating an elusive phosphatetrahedrane

Isolating an elusive phosphatetrahedrane
Chart of compounds relevant to the present study. Credit: Science Advances, doi: 10.1126/sciadv.aaz3168

A research team in the Department of Chemistry at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT), Cambridge U.S., explored a synthetic pathway to generate a phosphatetrahedrane framework. During the synthetic route, the team replaced a single carbon vertex with another p-block element within a highly strained tetrahedrane molecule. Highly strained molecules possess unusually acute bond angles at carbon and are species of high energy. In order to replace a single carbon vertex for less strain in this work, Martin-Louis Y. Riu and colleagues selected phosphorous due to its stable, tetrahedral molecular form. They accomplished the task through dehydrofluorination of fluorophosphine [H(F)P(CtBu)3] generated during the synthetic route. The team isolated a 19 percent yield of the Tri-tert-butyl phosphatetrahedrane [P(CtBu)3] product of interest as a low-melting, volatile and colorless solid. They characterized the product spectroscopically and with single-crystal X-ray diffraction to confirm the tetrahedral nature of the molecule's PC3 core and noted the unexpected thermal stability of the molecule.

Strained cages such as tetrahedrane are interesting structural components used to design new high-energy density materials. Although the parent tetrahedrane molecule has remained elusive, it is a viable target and chemists aim to successfully isolate molecules containing the tetrahedrane core with four and encage it with substituents to synthesize new materials. In a complementary approach, researchers can substitute other elements into the tetrahedral core including phosphorous, known as "the carbon copy" due to its approximation to carbon—based on electronegativity and the ability to form multiple bonds—which forms the basis of phospha-organic chemistry. In highly strained organic systems where contain unusually acute bond angles at carbon, Riu et al. replaced a carbon atom of tetrahedrane with phosphorous to yield a stable molecular entity. The potential to create a phosphatetrahedrane is logical due to the tetrahedral nature of the P4 molecule—the only stable molecular form of elemental phosphorous. For instance, theoretical work has predicted that phosphatetrahedrane will behave similarly to carbon bases after gas-phase protonation (addition of a proton or hydrogen).

Isolating an elusive phosphatetrahedrane
Synthesis of phosphaketene 2, diphosphene 5, and phosphorus analogs of tricyclopentanone 4 and housene 6. r.t., room temperature. Credit: Science Advances, doi: 10.1126/sciadv.aaz3168

Since substituting bulky groups is key to stabilize (CR)4 tetrahedranes, in this work Riu et al. selected P(CtBu)3 as their target molecule. Based on their experience with phosphinidene transfer activity, the team prepared a compound, AP(CtBu)3 where A was anthracene or C14H10 and analogous to phosphaketene. During the process, the team deprotonated a secondary phosphine HPA and collected the product by filtration after precipitating the crude reaction mixture, to eventually produce cyclopropenyl phosphine as a ninth product in the synthetic route. They characterized compound nine with single-crystal X-ray diffraction to reveal its molecular structure. The cyclopropenyl phosphine product was thermally stable at least to its melting point of 1300C and Riu et al. conducted photochemical experiments to induce anthracene elimination.

After brief periods of irradiation, they produced a species containing a 31P nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) signal, which they identified as one component of the desired phosphatetrahedrane molecule (named as compound 1) within a complex mixture. Extended periods of irradiation led to a loss of the intriguing high-field NMR signal that represented the product, while showing increased complexity of the reaction mixture. Since halides (chloride, bromide, fluoride) can also induce elimination of anthracene, the team studied an alternative strategy to generate HXP(CtBu)3 cyclopropenyl halophosphines from compound nine, as a potential precursor to form the phosphinidenoid of interest. The team treated compound nine to eliminate the anthracene molecule and formed HXP(CtBu)3, where X could either be fluoride to form compound 10, or chloride to form compound 11, which they identified using NMR.

Isolating an elusive phosphatetrahedrane
Synthesis of tri-tert-butyl phosphatetrahedrane 1. TBA, tetra-n-butyl ammonium; TMA, tetramethylammonium; TMP, tetramethylpiperidide; TMPH, tetramethylpiperidine. Credit: Science Advances, doi: 10.1126/sciadv.aaz3168

Dehydrohalogenation of compound 10 –fluorophosphine was efficient and reproducible to produce phosphatetrahedrane (compound 1) – the structure of interest. The team optimized the protocol to deliver compound 1 as the major product and characterized the result with NMR signals to confirm its purity/identity. Riu et al. first obtained crude samples of the phosphatetrahedrane product as a pale yellow oil, which they purified through a silica plug to deliver colorless solid samples. They then credited the low yield of the isolated compound to volatility during isolation and purification.

Isolating an elusive phosphatetrahedrane
Molecular structures of key intermediates obtained from single-crystal x-ray diffraction experiments. (A) Drawing of Na[8] with thermal ellipsoids shown at the 50% probability level. Hydrogen atoms have been omitted. (B) Drawing of compound 9 with thermal ellipsoids shown at the 50% probability level. Hydrogen atoms have been omitted. Science Advances, doi: 10.1126/sciadv.aaz3168

The scientists ultimately grew crystals of the product of interest—phosphatetrahedrane for X-ray diffraction investigations and used sublimation to overcome volatility for smoother product development. Using the data, they determined the structure of phosphatetrahedrane, which agreed well with those predicted using quantum chemical calculations. The final compound showed considerable thermal stability and stability in air (at room temperature) for half hour, although they were unstable under 254 nm ultraviolet irradiation. Riu et al. used quantum chemical calculations to illuminate the bonding and explained the stability of the molecular framework, while illustrating how three bulky substitutions were sufficient to produce an isolated tetrahedrane.

Isolating an elusive phosphatetrahedrane
LEFT: Structural drawing of tri-tert-butyl phosphatetrahedrane 1 from a single-crystal x-ray diffraction experiment. Thermal ellipsoids are shown at the 50% probability level, and hydrogen atoms have been omitted. RIGHT: Analysis of bonding in compound 1 using quantum chemical calculations. (A) Molecular graph of P(CtBu)3 (1) showing paths linking pairs of bonded atoms, bond critical points as small orange spheres, the phosphorus atom as a large orange sphere, carbon atoms as beige spheres, and hydrogen atoms as white spheres. (B) Standard heats of formation in kcal/mol at 298.15 K for tetrahedrane, P4, and phosphatetrahedrane from G3(MP2, CCSD(T)) calculations performed using GAMESS quantum chemistry package. The phosphatetrahedrane ΔH∘f value can be approximated as the sum of three-quarters the value for tetrahedrane and one-quarter the value for the P4 molecule. Science Advances, doi: 10.1126/sciadv.aaz3168

In this way, Martin-Louis Y. Riu and colleagues synthesized tri-tert-butyl phosphatetrahedrane to produce proof of existence of a molecule with the smallest sum of bond angles conceivable for a trivalent phosphorous atom. To successfully synthesize phosphatetrahedrane, the team relied on novel phosphinidenoid reaction chemistry that remains to be explained in mechanistic detail. The strategy described in this work will be applicable to other strained synthetic targets.

Explore further

A map of reactions helps control molecular properties

More information: Martin-Louis Y. Riu et al. Isolation of an elusive phosphatetrahedrane, Science Advances (2020). DOI: 10.1126/sciadv.aaz3168

David J. Liptrot et al. London dispersion forces in sterically crowded inorganic and organometallic molecules, Nature Reviews Chemistry (2017). DOI: 10.1038/s41570-016-0004

Gabriele Hierlmeier et al. Di‐ tert ‐butyldiphosphatetrahedrane: Catalytic Synthesis of the Elusive Phosphaalkyne Dimer, Angewandte Chemie International Edition (2019). DOI: 10.1002/anie.201910505

© 2020 Science X Network

Citation: Isolating an elusive phosphatetrahedrane (2020, April 3) retrieved 3 June 2020 from
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

Feedback to editors

User comments