Study solves puzzle of snail and slug feeding preferences

December 5, 2018 by Alan Williams, University of Plymouth
A garden snail (Cornu aspersum) feeding on Oxeye daisy (Leucanthemum vulgare) seedling as part of the research Credit: Mick Hanley/University of Plymouth

Gardeners have puzzled for years as to why some seedlings are more commonly eaten by slugs and snails—and new research suggests it may be down to the smells produced by young seedlings in the early stages of their development.

A study led by the University of Plymouth analysed the feeding preferences of hundreds of snails when presented with of 14 different grassland plant .

Their work showed that snails were more likely to attack seedlings based on their preference for, or dislike of, naturally omitted volatile scents produced by the seedlings.

Scientists say the research, published in the journal Annals of Botany, provides us with a better understanding of the important role slugs and snails play in natural ecosystems.

The research was led by Dr. Mick Hanley, Associate Professor (Reader) in Plant-Animal Interactions, and Post-Doctoral Fellow Roger Shannon at the University of Plymouth. It also involved academics from the University of Southampton and the University of Lyon, France.

Dr. Hanley, the corresponding author for the research, said: "Slugs and snails are just as damaging to seedlings in natural habitats like grasslands as they are gardens. But we have known for many years that not all grassland species suffer the same likelihood of attack. This is important because variation in where and when terrestrial molluscs are active can have significant impacts on which species survive the vulnerable seedling stage. In effect, by removing some plant species as seedlings, slugs and snails help dictate the nature of the established vegetation."

The research builds on a previous smaller study which focused specifically on oilseed rape, and suggested that harnessing naturally occurring chemicals could be used as a means to protect crop seedlings being eaten by common pests.

For the current study, scientists collected snails from the Plymouth and Southampton areas and presented them with a variety of grassland seedlings, with their choices being recorded.

Each of the seedling species was then characterised for the presence of common defensive compounds associated with taste, and volatile organic compounds (VOCs) associated with smell, to determine whether the snails' choices were linked to either type of defence.

The results showed there was no relationship between the snails' choices and the presence of chemicals like phenolics and cyanide—which occur naturally within some plant species—but that seedling acceptability was strongly related to VOCs.

The study was funded by the Leverhulme Trust, and Dr. Hanley has recently received further funding from the trust to explore whether latitude and altitude make any difference to plant resistance

Dr. Hanley added, "Charles Darwin recognised long ago the destructive impact that snails and slugs have on young seedlings. Yet since Darwin's' observations, biologists have never fully understood why these herbivores select particular plant species at their most vulnerable life history stage.

"We had believed for many years that molluscs chose seedlings based on their taste. But for a tiny seedling, even a single bite from a snail would probably be fatal. Our research suggests seedlings of some species use repellent volatile chemicals to prevent slug or snail damage before it occurs and so avoid any damage at all. This will give seedlings with this ability a tremendous advantage in terms of their recruitment probability at times when slugs or snails are abundant."

Explore further: Snails select sources of food based on dislike for smells rather than acceptable taste

More information: Riding on the wind: volatile organic compounds dictate seedling selection by snails, Annals Of Botany (2018). DOI: 10.1093/aob/mcy190

Related Stories

Catching rice-invading snails in the act

May 23, 2016

Commonly available eco-friendly plants and materials can be used to trap rice-crop-invading snails in place of chemicals, according to new research in the Pertanika Journal of Tropical Agricultural Science.

Eavesdropping plants prepare to be attacked

August 7, 2013

( —In a world full of hungry predators, prey animals must be constantly vigilant to avoid getting eaten. But plants face a particular challenge when it comes to defending themselves.

Recommended for you

Big genome found in tiny forest defoliator

January 15, 2019

The European gypsy moth (EGM) is perhaps the country's most famous invasive insect—a nonnative species accidentally introduced to North America in the 1860s when a few escaped from a breeding experiment in suburban Boston. ...

Why haven't cancer cells undergone genetic meltdowns?

January 15, 2019

Cancer first develops as a single cell going rogue, with mutations that trigger aggressive growth at all costs to the health of the organism. But if cancer cells were accumulating harmful mutations faster than they could ...

Gene expression study sheds new light on African Salmonella

January 15, 2019

Scientists at the University of Liverpool have taken another step forward in understanding the bacteria that are causing a devastating Salmonella epidemic currently killing around 400,000 people each year in sub-Saharan Africa.


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.