A big space crash likely made Uranus lopsided

December 21, 2018 by Seth Borenstein
Science Says: A big space crash likely made Uranus lopsided
This image made from video provided by Durham University astronomy researcher Jacob Kegerreis shows a computer simulation generated by the open-source code SWIFT that depicts an object crashing into the planet Uranus. Kegerreis says the detailed simulations show that the collision and reshaping of Uranus 3 billion to 4 billion years ago likely caused the massive planet to tilt about 90 degrees on its side. (Jacob A. Kegerreis/Durham University via AP)

Uranus is a lopsided oddity, the only planet to spin on its side. Scientists now think they know how it got that way: It was pushed over by a rock at least twice as big as Earth.

Detailed computer simulations show that an enormous rock crashed into the seventh planet from the sun, said Durham University astronomy researcher Jacob Kegerreis, who presented his analysis at a large earth and space science conference this month.

Uranus is unique in the solar system. The massive planet tilts about 90 degrees on its side, as do its five largest moons. Its is also lopsided and doesn't go out the poles like ours does, said NASA chief scientist Jim Green. It also is the only planet that doesn't have its interior heat escape from the core. It has rings like Saturn, albeit faint ones.

"It's very strange," said Carnegie Institution planetary scientist Scott Sheppard, who wasn't part of the research.

The show that the collision and reshaping of Uranus—maybe enveloping some or all of the rock that hit it—happened in a matter of hours, Kegerreis said. He produced an animation showing the violent crash and its aftermath.

It's also possible that the big object that knocked over Uranus is still lurking in the solar system too far for us to see, said Green. It would explain some of the orbits of the planet and fit with a theory that a missing planet X is circling the sun well beyond Pluto, he said.

Green said it's possible that a lot of smaller space rocks—the size of Pluto—pushed Uranus over, but Kegerreis' research and Sheppard point to a single huge unknown suspect. Green said a single impact "is the right thinking."

The collision happened 3 billion to 4 billion years ago, likely before the larger moons of Uranus formed. Instead there was a disk of stuff that would eventually come together to form moons. And when that happened, Uranus' odd tilt acted like a gravity tidal force pushing those five large moons to the same tilt, Kegerreis said.

It also would have created an icy shell that kept Uranus' inner heat locked in, Kegerreis said. (Uranus' surface is minus 357 degrees, or minus 216 Celsius.)

Ice is key with Uranus and its neighbor Neptune. A little more than a decade ago, NASA reclassified those two as "ice giants," no longer lumping them with the other large planets of the solar system, the gas giants Saturn and Jupiter.

Pluto, which is tiny, farther from the sun and not even officially a planet anymore, has been explored more than Uranus and Neptune. They only got brief flybys by Voyager 2, the space probe that entered interstellar space last month.

Uranus and Neptune "are definitely the least understood planets," Sheppard said.

But that may change. A robotic probe to one or both of those planets was high up on the last wish-list from top planetary scientists and likely will be at or near the top of the next list.

Uranus was named for the Greek god of the sky. Its name often generates juvenile humor when it is wrongly pronounced like a body part. (It's correctly pronounced YUR'-uh-nus.)

"No one laughs when I say Uranus," NASA's Green said. "They have to mispronounce it to get the chuckles."

Explore further: 'Cataclysmic' collision shaped Uranus' evolution

Related Stories

Encouraging prospects for moon hunters

November 20, 2018

Astrophysicists of the University of Zürich, ETH Zürich and the NCCR PlanetS show how the icy moons of Uranus were born. Their result suggests that such potentially habitable worlds are much more abundant in the Universe ...

Image: Polar lights on Uranus

November 5, 2018

On the first day of the 15th annual European Space Weather Week, this image from the NASA/ESA Hubble Space Telescope fittingly shows a striking occurrence of celestial weather in the outer reaches of the Solar System: an ...

Five in a row—the planets align in the night sky

October 12, 2018

For the second time this year, the five brightest planets can be seen at the same time. You can catch them by looking towards the western sky after sunset. The planets will form a line rising up from the horizon.

Hubble spots auroras on Uranus

April 10, 2017

This is a composite image of Uranus by Voyager 2 and two different observations made by Hubble—one for the ring and one for the auroras.

Recommended for you

Galactic center visualization delivers star power

March 21, 2019

Want to take a trip to the center of the Milky Way? Check out a new immersive, ultra-high-definition visualization. This 360-movie offers an unparalleled opportunity to look around the center of the galaxy, from the vantage ...

Physicists reveal why matter dominates universe

March 21, 2019

Physicists in the College of Arts and Sciences at Syracuse University have confirmed that matter and antimatter decay differently for elementary particles containing charmed quarks.


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

4 / 5 (4) Dec 22, 2018
The impactor tilting theory is old, but this would go towards as firm a test as we could hope for.

But this comment from Green is odd, and while I found the conference abstract it was not mentioned there:

"It's also possible that the big object that knocked over Uranus is still lurking in the solar system too far for us to see, said Green. It would explain some of the orbits of the planet and fit with a theory that a missing planet X is circling the sun well beyond Pluto, he said."

This seems to imply an unlikely series of events, a glancing impact (?) followed by a wide "just so" orbit, instead of Batygin & Brown preferred early migration for P9. (Which now is strengthened by the binary Trojan dynamic that sets an upper limit for Jupiter/Saturn resonance of 100 Myrs after system formation.) Presumably a typical tilting impact was more head on and could have happened any time after Uranus settled in the outer system during clearing of its new orbit.
1 / 5 (2) Dec 22, 2018
Hmmm....I understood that every large charged body does not actually 'impact' but exchanges charge to equalize.
5 / 5 (2) Dec 23, 2018
uhh kate, your posting is confusing.
What charge? For that matter, what kind of charge?

If you are meaning a phenomena of electro-magnetism?
Do the math.
First, estimate the Mass of YUR'-uh-nus.

Then estimate the sheer quantity of Energy it would take to make that volume of Mass ring-like-a-bell & flip over on it's side.
To brutally shove it into it's present orbit.
Leaving rings of debris that will coalesce into satellites.

Next, reveal what kinda phenomena is there available? To produce the sheer total of EM force it would take, to move that gigatonnage of matter you estimated.

Sure in the EU woo youtube cartoons it looks easy. On a few micro-ounces of EM conductive material, Surreptitiously produced in a High School lab During a long-weekend with no instructors to jeer at the pitiful fakery of EU pseudoscience..

But to get to the big numbers?
Gravity Rules!
& is a real bitch about it!
5 / 5 (1) Dec 24, 2018
"I understood that every large charged body does not actually 'impact' but exchanges charge to equalize." Well, that could be true, but what does the legal manoeuvring of corpulent defendants have to do with planetary astronomy?

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.