US tech giants split over corporate tax to help homeless

October 24, 2018 by Julie Charpentrat
San Francisco's homeless problem has been exacerbated by the tech boom that pushed housing prices sky high

Taxing San Francisco's wealthiest companies to rein in the city's homelessness problem makes sense to local campaigners—but the local tech giants aren't all so sure.

On November 6, voters in the city that is the home base of Twitter, Uber and Airbnb will decide the fate of "Proposition C," a local ballot measure brought about by a 28,000 signature petition this summer.

Designed to rake in $250 to $300 million in taxes per year, the Robin Hood-esque measure would fund housing for 5,000 people and finance mental health and housing aid services, its backers say.

Generally, San Francisco's tech bosses—including Twitter's Jack Dorsey and Patrick Collison of payment start-up Stripe—have resisted the proposal.

But billionaire Marc Benioff, head of cloud computing firm Salesforce, has pumped funding into the "Yes On C" campaign.

The campaign's blue and yellow banners are plastered around the city of 890,000, famed for the Golden Gate Bridge and its old-school cable cars.

"We have 70 billionaires in San Francisco [Bay Area region]. Not all of them are giving money away. A lot of them are just hoarding it," Benioff said in an interview with The Guardian.

'Not the best way'

Dorsey, who has argued frequently with Benioff about the issue on Twitter, instead calls for "long term solutions"—"not quick acts to make us feel good for one moment in time."

Wealth and poverty: homeless people in San Francisco asleep under the logos of the world's most expensive cars
"I want to help fix the homeless problem in SF and California," he tweeted earlier this month.

"I don't believe this (Prop C) is the best way to do it," he added, expressing his "trust" in Mayor London Breed to sort the issue.

According to the city council, which opposes the measure, some 7,500 people sleep outside every night in San Francisco. Every year, local services see around 20,000 different homeless people—and the city says it is spending $250 million per year on fighting the housing crisis.

San Francisco's homeless population is concentrated in the central Tenderloin district. Many suffer from mental and physical illnesses, and live among garbage and drug paraphernalia.

Pushing carts filled with shabby belongings, some roam along Market Street, not far from the headquarters of Uber and Twitter.

West coast problem

For San Francisco natives, the tech boom has worsened a housing crisis as real estate prices soared: $3,000 a month will get you a pokey studio, and unless you have at least $1 million to spend, you can wave goodbye to buying.

Salesforce head Marc Benioff (R) says his fellow billionaires are hoarding money and don't want to help the homeless
"These tech CEOs, they need to realize if they want to do business in San Francisco and use all of our civic resources ... then they should be more than happy to give a small amount—which is what it is for these companies," Benioff recently told CNN Business.

Benioff also said that some tech giants received tax breaks when they settled in Market Street, the city's main downtown thoroughfare.

Homelessness and high real estate prices are pressing issues up and down the US West Coast.

Other Californian cities such as nearby San Jose—located next to the home bases of tech behemoths Apple, Facebook and Google—are also plagued by astronomic real estate prices and homeless crises of their own.

Los Angeles faces tight housing and a large homeless population, as does Portland, Oregon.

Further north in Seattle, in the state of Washington, efforts earlier this year to pass a city tax to help the caved to pressure from companies based in the including Starbucks and Amazon.

Explore further: Snapcrap app steps in to take on public poop

Related Stories

Seattle poised to repeal new tax opposed by Amazon

June 12, 2018

Seattle leaders said Monday that they plan to repeal a tax on large companies like Amazon and Starbucks as they face mounting pressure from businesses, an about-face just a month after unanimously approving the measure to ...

Will Amazon's work to kill Seattle tax spook other cities?

June 13, 2018

A tax on large companies such as Amazon that was meant to fight a growing homelessness crisis got rolled back during a raucous Seattle City Council meeting that exposed divisions over how much companies that have fueled booming ...

AMA adopts new policy on housing for homeless

August 15, 2018

(HealthDay)—The American Medical Association (AMA) calls for stable, affordable housing, without mandated therapy or service compliance, in order to improve housing stability and quality of life among individuals who are ...

Recommended for you


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Oct 24, 2018
Well, the tax abatement on homes in CA was subverted to include big business, and the schools are broke as a result. Congress created the SuperFund legislation which required a tax on business polluters so the businesses claimed there was no pollution, including dumping heavy metals into fertilizer for farmers to add to cropland. All cross America toxic cleanups are delayed , postponed, omitted and forgotten about. Note that the Texas flooding exposed thousands to toxic dumps casually offloaded on empty lots in suburban streets. Big business doesn't care as long as its out of sight and not taxable. Bush did his best to comply.
1 / 5 (1) Oct 25, 2018
Or the city/county/state could just stop getting in the way of more housing being built.

If you do not have enough of something the best way to drive the price down is to create more of it. This is not some secrete formula, everyone knows this is the case but it never seems to be offered as a solution.


Because even in "Liberal" San Francisco the existing homeowners are all NIMBY with the attitude of I have mine, to bad for the rest of the people.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.