New technique for additive manufacturing design

May 30, 2018, Sandia National Laboratories
Sandia National Laboratories project lead and mechanical engineer Ted Winrow with the telescope he and his team built using advanced manufacturing techniques. Credit: Randy Montoya

A Sandia National Laboratories team built a telescope to demonstrate how to design for additive manufacturing, familiarly known as 3-D printing, to take advantage of the technique's strengths and weaknesses.

Sandia's three-year Laboratory Directed Research and Development project proved the feasibility of using additive manufacturing as an entirely new design tool, vastly different from the standard technique of moving from hand drawing to computer-assisted design to machining parts, said Ted Winrow, a mechanical engineer who led the project.

Instead of concentrating on printing precision parts, the project focused on how to put less precise 3-D printed parts together with precise tools, taking advantage of the rapid prototyping, design and manufacturing possible with additive manufacturing.

"That's the nuance that seems to get lost, that you have to design differently," Winrow said. "It doesn't plug into a standard design process."

The team created a lighter weight, less expensive ground-based telescope in about a third of the time of a traditionally made telescope for about a fifth of the cost, he said. They used 3-D printed components, modular design and, for the telescope optical design, image-correction algorithms that also helped save money.

Credit: Sandia National Laboratories

The technique shifts money from recurring costs, "where every part has to be precise, to nonrecurring costs, where you're just buying one set of tools that you can use for maybe 10 years," Winrow said. "So when you're making production runs you get cost savings. You've got time savings because you're not waiting for each piece to be made" by machining.

Exact tolerances versus precise assembly

There are two ways to approach building any precision structure: make every piece to exact tolerances so assembly is simple, or make rougher pieces and use a very precise assembly process that compensates for shortfalls in dimensions.

Machining creates parts with extremely precise dimensions, but it can't cheaply make, or in some cases, make at all, the strange 3-D printed designs that may have advantages in function and weight. Additive manufacturing forms the material—polymer, ceramic or metal—at the same time it creates a part. Research is ongoing into how that affects the properties of materials and whether changes in properties matter in a particular use.

Design, however, is a separate question.

Expanded detail view of the telescope created by a Sandia National Laboratories team using additive manufacturing techniques. Credit: Sandia National Laboratories

"Can we design a system that doesn't care if your material is not as good as you expected it to be? Can you design a system that doesn't care that your parts aren't as dimensionally accurate?" Winrow said. "If you make yourself insensitive to the things that additive's not very good at, you take advantage of all its good things."

For example, a standard camera has a ledge, which must be very precise because the position of that ledge defines exactly where a lens sits. Sandia's project, working with lenses for the telescope, created a straight cylinder with no ledges. Instead, "we hold the lens at a very precise position using very precise tooling. We hold the lens in the right spot and then we inject epoxy around it and lock it into place," Winrow said. "We can make parts that are less precise as far as dimensions are concerned because of the epoxy in the process. It's the tooling that's precise."

Sandia applied for a patent for a monolithic, titanium flexure that's part of the telescope mirror mount. A flexure refers to a broad range of elements used like joints between rigid bodies. The joint motion, either linear or rotating, is produced by bending the element. Rigidly mounting metal to glass doesn't work because the two materials expand and contract at different rates as temperature changes, and the glass could deform or even crack.

A flexure acts like a spring, although it doesn't look like a coil spring. Sandia's design is roughly cylindrical, about 2 inches long and 3/4 of an inch in diameter, with very thin flexure blades. Three flexure mounts attach to the mirrors with epoxy, relieving expansion and contraction stress where mirrors attach to a carbon fiber backbone.

Software correction results in a clear, sharp image from the original taken with a telescope created by a Sandia National Laboratories team using additive manufacturing techniques. Credit: Sandia National Laboratories

Sandia seeks patent for piece designed during project

The precision mechanical design team worked on the project with Sandia optical designer Jeff Hunt and algorithm authors Dennis Lee and Eric Shields. Winrow said the lens design creates a raw image with distortions and other errors. The software algorithms correct certain types of errors better than others, so errors in the lens design are the type the algorithms are good at correcting, he said.

"The thought was you could have less precise optics and correct for it with software, essentially after the fact. Similar to how we designed the mechanical hardware to be insensitive to shortfalls and take advantage of its benefits, Jeff optimized the optics of the system so the software maintained the image properties the algorithms could not have done as good a job correcting," Winrow said. "You could get the same performance you could have if you spent three times as much money on better optics."

The project has ended, but Sandia structural designers now are using information from it, he said.

"That was what the project was looking at, how these ways could make it faster and cheaper and just as good," Winrow said. "If you talk about things you can give up, things you can compensate for after the fact, it opens up realms on the side."

Explore further: Scientists successfully print glass optics

Related Stories

Scientists successfully print glass optics

March 30, 2018

For the first time, researchers at Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory (LLNL) have successfully 3-D-printed optical-quality glasses, on par with commercial glass products currently available on the market.

Lighter weights, lower costs in additive manufacturing

September 18, 2017

It's never long before the most advanced technology needs its own innovations. Additive manufacturing, the gold standard for innovative industry production, has reached that point. With its use steadily increasing, there ...

Toward additive manufacturing

July 26, 2017

Automation, robotics, advanced computer-aided design, sensing and diagnostic technologies have revolutionized the modern factory, allowing the building of complex products, from microchips to cars and even airplanes, with ...

Recommended for you

Printing microelectrode array sensors on gummi candy

June 22, 2018

Microelectrodes can be used for direct measurement of electrical signals in the brain or heart. These applications require soft materials, however. With existing methods, attaching electrodes to such materials poses significant ...

EU copyright law passes key hurdle

June 20, 2018

A highly disputed European copyright law that could force online platforms such as Google and Facebook to pay for links to news content passed a key hurdle in the European Parliament on Wednesday.


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.