Trappist-1 exoplanets may have too much water to support life

March 20, 2018 by Bob Yirka, report
Modelled χ2 goodness of fit for the masses of the TRAPPIST-1 planets as a function of the planet's radius and relative H2O mass fraction in wt% added to the system. Credit: Nature Astronomy (2018) doi:10.1038/s41550-018-0411-6

A team of researchers from Arizona State University and Vanderbilt University has found evidence that suggests the exoplanets surrounding the star Trappist-1 may be too wet to support life. In their paper published in the journal Nature Astronomy, the group describes using data from prior efforts that focused on determining the mass and diameter of the stars' planets to calculate densities, and from that, used a computer to model the likely building blocks of each.

Last year, scientists discovered the Trappist-1 star system—a red dwarf 39 light years away surrounded by seven , all of which are similar in size to Earth. This discovery set off speculation on the possibility of one or more of the planets harboring . The researchers with this new effort have thrown a wet blanket on such speculation by suggesting that all of the planets have too much water to support life. In modeling the planets, the researchers found that they all have far more water than Earth, from 50 percent of their mass to 10 percent. The Earth, by contrast, is just 0.2 percent water. So much likely means there are no exposed land masses, which suggests no geochemical cycles that could promote an atmosphere. Also, a planet covered by very deep oceans would experience extreme mantle pressure preventing rock from moving upward, likely resulting in a runaway snowball effect.

Slice through a model composition of TRAPPIST-1 'f' which contains over 50 percent water by mass. The pressure of the water alone is enough to cause it to become high-pressure ice. The pressure at the water-mantle boundary is so great that no upper mantle is present at all; instead the shallowest rocks would be more like those seen in the Earth's lower mantle. Credit: ASU

The seven planets are classified as rocky, which means they are not gaseous. Also, three of them reside in the "habitable zone," but their star is approximately 2,000 times dimmer than our own, which means that the planets most likely to support life reside very close to their star. But that could be a problem for a couple of reasons—one is that it means the planets are likely tidally locked, resulting in one side always being too hot while the other is too cold. Also, red dwarfs are known to flare a lot, which could spell doom for life on nearby planets.

All seven planets discovered in orbit around the red dwarf star TRAPPIST-1 could easily fit inside the orbit of Mercury, the innermost planet of our solar system. Credit: NASA/JPL- Caltech

The researchers suggest their results could also have implications for theories on how planets develop as they note that all seven of the planets in the Trappist-1 system lie within the "snow line," but the model shows that the likely formed beyond that line and migrated inwards over time.

This graph shows the minimum starting distances of the ice-rich TRAPPIST-1 planets (especially f and g) from their star (horizontal axis) as a function of how quickly they formed after their host star was born (vertical axis). The blue line represents a model where water condenses to ice at 170 K, as in our Solar System's planet-forming disk. The red line applies to water condensing to ice at 212 K, appropriate to the TRAPPIST-1 disk. If planets formed quickly, they must have formed farther away (and migrated in a greater distance) to contain significant ice. Because TRAPPIST-1 dims over time, if the planets formed later, they could have formed closer to the host star and still be ice-rich. Credit: ASU

Explore further: TRAPPIST-1 system planets potentially habitable

More information: Inward migration of the TRAPPIST-1 planets as inferred from their water-rich compositions, Nature Astronomy (2018) DOI: 10.1038/s41550-018-0411-6 ,

Multiple planet systems provide an ideal laboratory for probing exoplanet composition, formation history and potential habitability. For the TRAPPIST-1 planets, the planetary radii are well established from transits, with reasonable mass estimates coming from transit timing variations2,3 and dynamical modelling4. The low bulk densities of the TRAPPIST-1 planets demand substantial volatile content. Here we show, using mass–radius–composition models, that TRAPPIST-1f and g probably contain substantial (≥50 wt%) water/ice, with TRAPPIST-1 b and c being significantly drier (≤15 wt%). We propose that this gradient of water mass fractions implies that planets f and g formed outside the primordial snow line whereas b and c formed within it. We find that, compared with planets in our Solar System that also formed within the snow line, TRAPPIST-1b and c contain hundreds more oceans of water. We demonstrate that the extent and timescale of migration in the TRAPPIST-1 system depends on how rapidly the planets formed and the relative location of the primordial snow line. This work provides a framework for understanding the differences between the protoplanetary disks of our Solar System versus M dwarfs. Our results provide key insights into the volatile budgets, timescales of planet formation and migration history of M dwarf systems, probably the most common type of planetary host in the Galaxy.

Press release

Related Stories

More to life than the habitable zone

July 13, 2017

Two separate teams of scientists have identified major challenges for the development of life in what has recently become one of the most famous exoplanet systems, TRAPPIST-1.

Recommended for you

Magnetized inflow accreting to center of Milky Way galaxy

August 17, 2018

Are magnetic fields an important guiding force for gas accreting to a supermassive black hole (SMBH) like the one that our Milky Way galaxy hosts? The role of magnetic fields in gas accretion is little understood, and trying ...

First science with ALMA's highest-frequency capabilities

August 17, 2018

The ALMA telescope in Chile has transformed how we see the universe, showing us otherwise invisible parts of the cosmos. This array of incredibly precise antennas studies a comparatively high-frequency sliver of radio light: ...

Another way for stellar-mass black holes to grow larger

August 17, 2018

A trio of researchers with The University of Hong Kong, Academia Sinica Institute of Astronomy and Astrophysics in Taiwan and Northwestern University in the U.S., has come up with an alternative theory to explain how some ...

Six things about Opportunity's recovery efforts

August 17, 2018

NASA's Opportunity rover has been silent since June 10, when a planet-encircling dust storm cut off solar power for the nearly-15-year-old rover. Now that scientists think the global dust storm is "decaying"—meaning more ...

Sprawling galaxy cluster found hiding in plain sight

August 16, 2018

MIT scientists have uncovered a sprawling new galaxy cluster hiding in plain sight. The cluster, which sits a mere 2.4 billion light years from Earth, is made up of hundreds of individual galaxies and surrounds an extremely ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

1 / 5 (5) Mar 20, 2018
If the conclusions hypothesized by the researchers in this article, are confirmed?

One implication is that "Ocean Moons" such as Enceladus might be sterile. Mot sure if this would apply to Titan?

Which would be a relief that our sloppy procedures that are suppose to prevent biological contamination of extraterrestrial environments are superfluous. Though should always be improving as 'Good Practices'.

The problem remains of course, Human nature. The drive for sensationalist headlines and professional advancement and popular acclaim. Will result in fraudulent claims that contamination by Earth Life must be alien organisms.

Forget about worrying how people will react upon proven discovery of alien life.

Worry instead how badly the Public will react when it is revealed that their expectations of scientific progress were contaminated by fraud and error.
5 / 5 (5) Mar 20, 2018
That raises an interesting question: can a high water-content planet remain tidally locked? If one side of the planet is constantly below freezing while the other side is continually being heated, shouldn't the water slowly accumulate on the far side? Wouldn't this slow accumulation throw off the planet's center of mass sufficiently to force rotation as the body moved to re-balance relative to the star/planet system's gravitational zero point?
5 / 5 (4) Mar 20, 2018
One implication is that "Ocean Moons" such as Enceladus might be sterile. Mot sure if this would apply to Titan?
Ocean moons can get a lot of tidal forces though, which drives geological activity.
Mark Thomas
4 / 5 (2) Mar 20, 2018
I remain more than a little skeptical about this article.
not rated yet Mar 24, 2018
AFAIK the "no landmasses" planets have been found to have no greenhouse runaway scenario when clathrate formation is included and replace geochemical cycles in scavenging CO2. Presumably then they may avoid snowballs with an analogous mechanism (release CO2 as the temperature goes down and water ice formation is promoted).

Ice moons are different, both Enceladus and Europa are believed to have free rock bottoms, as well as local hydrothermal vent oases.
not rated yet Mar 24, 2018
They are going to have to have some sort of atmosphere. With that much water, they will have an atmosphere of at least a water vapor layer if they are warm enough to possibly promote life. That means there will probably also be some level of oxygen and hydrogen mixed in due to solar radiation. Maybe not a lot but there will be some.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.