'Sweet spot' in sweet material for hydrogen storage

March 12, 2018 by Jade Boyd, Rice University
Thousands of hours of calculations on Rice University’s two fastest supercomputers found that the optimal architecture for packing hydrogen into “white graphene” involves making skyscraper-like frameworks of vertical columns and one-dimensional floors that are about 5.2 angstroms apart. In this illustration, hydrogen molecules (white) sit between sheet-like floors of graphene (gray) that are supported by boron-nitride pillars (pink and blue). Researchers found that identical structures made wholly of boron-nitride had unprecedented capacity for storing readily available hydrogen. Credit: Lei Tao/Rice University

Rice University engineers have zeroed in on the optimal architecture for storing hydrogen in "white graphene" nanomaterials—a design like a Lilliputian skyscraper with "floors" of boron nitride sitting one atop another and held precisely 5.2 angstroms apart by boron nitride pillars.

The results appear in the journal Small.

"The motivation is to create an efficient material that can take up and hold a lot of hydrogen—both by volume and weight—and that can quickly and easily release that hydrogen when it's needed," said the study's lead author, Rouzbeh Shahsavari, assistant professor of civil and environmental engineering at Rice.

Hydrogen is the lightest and most abundant element in the universe, and its energy-to-mass ratio—the amount of available energy per pound of raw material, for example—far exceeds that of fossil fuels. It's also the cleanest way to generate electricity: The only byproduct is water. A 2017 report by market analysts at BCC Research found that global demand for and technologies will likely reach $5.4 billion annually by 2021.

Hydrogen's primary drawbacks relate to portability, storage and safety. While large volumes can be stored under high pressure in underground salt domes and specially designed tanks, small-scale portable tanks—the equivalent of an automobile gas tank—have so far eluded engineers.

Following months of calculations on two of Rice's fastest supercomputers, Shahsavari and Rice graduate student Shuo Zhao found the optimal architecture for storing hydrogen in . One form of the material, (hBN), consists of atom-thick sheets of boron and nitrogen and is sometimes called white graphene because the atoms are spaced exactly like carbon atoms in flat sheets of graphene.

Previous work in Shahsavari's Multiscale Materials Lab found that hybrid materials of graphene and boron nitride could hold enough hydrogen to meet the Department of Energy's storage targets for light-duty fuel cell vehicles.

"The choice of material is important," he said. "Boron nitride has been shown to be better in terms of hydrogen absorption than pure graphene, carbon nanotubes or hybrids of graphene and boron nitride.

"But the spacing and arrangement of hBN sheets and pillars is also critical," he said. "So we decided to perform an exhaustive search of all the possible geometries of hBN to see which worked best. We also expanded the calculations to include various temperatures, pressures and dopants, trace elements that can be added to the boron nitride to enhance its hydrogen storage capacity."

Zhao and Shahsavari set up numerous "ab initio" tests, computer simulations that used first principles of physics. Shahsavari said the approach was computationally intense but worth the extra effort because it offered the most precision.

"We conducted nearly 4,000 ab initio calculations to try and find that sweet spot where the material and geometry go hand in hand and really work together to optimize hydrogen storage," he said.

Unlike materials that store hydrogen through chemical bonding, Shahsavari said boron nitride is a sorbent that holds hydrogen through physical bonds, which are weaker than chemical bonds. That's an advantage when it comes to getting hydrogen out of storage because sorbent materials tend to discharge more easily than their chemical cousins, Shahsavari said.

He said the choice of boron nitride sheets or tubes and the corresponding spacing between them in the superstructure were the key to maximizing capacity.

"Without pillars, the sheets sit naturally one atop the other about 3 angstroms apart, and very few can penetrate that space," he said. "When the distance grew to 6 angstroms or more, the capacity also fell off. At 5.2 angstroms, there is a cooperative attraction from both the ceiling and floor, and the hydrogen tends to clump in the middle. Conversely, models made of purely BN tubes—not sheets—had less storage capacity."

Shahsavari said models showed that the pure hBN tube-sheet structures could hold 8 weight percent of hydrogen. (Weight percent is a measure of concentration, similar to parts per million.) Physical experiments are needed to verify that capacity, but that the DOE's ultimate target is 7.5 weight percent, and Shahsavari's models suggests even more hydrogen can be stored in his structure if trace amounts of lithium are added to the hBN.

Finally, Shahsavari said, irregularities in the flat, floor-like sheets of the structure could also prove useful for engineers.

"Wrinkles form naturally in the sheets of pillared nitride because of the nature of the junctions between the columns and floors," he said. "In fact, this could also be advantageous because the wrinkles can provide toughness. If the material is placed under load or impact, that buckled shape can unbuckle easily without breaking. This could add to the material's safety, which is a big concern in storage devices.

"Furthermore, the high thermal conductivity and flexibility of BN may provide additional opportunities to control the adsorption and release kinetics on-demand," Shahsavari said. "For example, it may be possible to control release kinetics by applying an external voltage, heat or an electric field."

Explore further: Scientists say boron nitride-graphene hybrid may be right for next-gen green cars

More information: Rouzbeh Shahsavari et al. Merger of Energetic Affinity and Optimal Geometry Provides New Class of Boron Nitride Based Sorbents with Unprecedented Hydrogen Storage Capacity, Small (2018). DOI: 10.1002/smll.201702863

Navid Sakhavand et al. Synergistic Behavior of Tubes, Junctions, and Sheets Imparts Mechano-Mutable Functionality in 3D Porous Boron Nitride Nanostructures, The Journal of Physical Chemistry C (2014). DOI: 10.1021/jp5044706

Related Stories

3-D nanostructure could benefit nanoelectronics, gas storage

July 15, 2014

A three-dimensional porous nanostructure would have a balance of strength, toughness and ability to transfer heat that could benefit nanoelectronics, gas storage and composite materials that perform multiple functions, according ...

Nano-hybrid materials create magnetic effect

January 13, 2016

Developing novel materials from the atoms up goes faster when some of the trial and error is eliminated. A new Rice University and Montreal Polytechnic study aims to do that for graphene and boron nitride hybrids.

Recommended for you

Semimetals are high conductors

March 18, 2019

Researchers in China and at UC Davis have measured high conductivity in very thin layers of niobium arsenide, a type of material called a Weyl semimetal. The material has about three times the conductivity of copper at room ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

1.8 / 5 (5) Mar 12, 2018
"...It's also the cleanest way to generate electricity..."

No, hydrogen production isn't a way to generate energy;
It takes more energy ("more" because energy conversion isn't 100% energy efficient) to produce hydrogen from water than the energy released from its oxidation or burning.
3 / 5 (2) Mar 12, 2018
humy - the quote says "to generate electricity." If you use a hydrogen fuel cell - and you feed hydrogen into that fuel cell - and electricity comes out of that fuel cell - you are indeed generating electricity. https://en.wikipe...uel_cell
1 / 5 (3) Mar 12, 2018
humy - the quote says "to generate electricity." If you use a hydrogen fuel cell - and you feed hydrogen into that fuel cell - and electricity comes out of that fuel cell - you are indeed generating electricity. https://en.wikipe...uel_cell

Yes, I already know all this. They implied hydrogen is a source of energy to replace fossil fuels, which it isn't.

3.7 / 5 (3) Mar 12, 2018
...They're just trying to keep their jobs and the actual solutions are ignored for decades.


The people working in the fossil fuel industry are just trying to keep their jobs and don't provide actual solutions thus, by your own same stupid logic, we should reject fossil fuels because of this.
People's motivation to keep their jobs is TOTALLY IRRELEVANT to which energy sources we should choose to eventually use in the long term.
3.2 / 5 (5) Mar 12, 2018
They implied hydrogen is a source of energy to replace fossil fuels, which it isn't.
No they didn't. They said -
.It's also the cleanest way to generate electricity..
That does not necessarily imply that hydrogen is a 'source' of energy. It asserts that hydrogen can be used to generate electricity. This is true - it can. You can get the hydrogen from methane, or water. Either way - it can be used to generate electricity. Sure - the overall EROI may be negative. The hydrogen may be being used as storage. But when it is put through a fuel cell - it will GENERATE electricity....
1 / 5 (1) Mar 13, 2018
but contemporary western people are just plain imbecile like bacteria
oddly enough - there is part of me that agrees with you. But I also see that there are some who are interested in pushing the boundaries - and seeing if we can do better. You have to be grounded in truth. Believing in magic is nice - but you have to understand truth in order to make progress. The point above is just a technicality. Sometimes we want to store energy - and as you know - a battery has an EROI of less than 1. Understanding that - does not make you an imbecile. Believing in magic makes you an imbecile - and as you probably know - the vast majority of humans believe in magic. For some - magic is god. For others it is over unity....
1 / 5 (1) Mar 13, 2018
we have at least one verified example of it
I read your article. Interesting. Did not say anything about over unity. Article says it is about utilizing brownian motion. Article also says
Thibado has taken the first steps toward creating a device that can turn this energy into electricity
So we don't actually have an example of a working prototype yet. I hope it pans out - but that article does nothing in terms of shedding any light on your magic over unity..
not rated yet Mar 14, 2018
Prediction: when they start "applying an external voltage, heat or an electric field", increased energy levels in the contained hydrogen will cause a sort of hot air balloon effect having the appearance of "anti-gravity," also known as gravity transparency. Continuous loss of mass equivalence, in the form of ambient light pumping through the stimulated hydrogen will cause radiation pressure, or thrust-equivalent and diminish the effect of gravity.
5 / 5 (1) Mar 14, 2018
Prediction: when they start "applying an external voltage, heat or an electric field", increased energy levels in the contained hydrogen will cause a sort of hot air balloon effect having the appearance of "anti-gravity," also known as gravity transparency.

Prediction: you are wrong.

Anyone want to offer me odds on a bet?

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.