How small does your rice pudding need to get when stirring jam into it?

December 22, 2017, Springer

Have you ever tried turning the spoon back after stirring jam into a rice pudding? It never brings the jam back into the spoon. This ever-increasing disorder is linked to a notion called entropy. Entropy is of interest to physicists studying the evolution of systems made up of multiple identical elements, like gas. Yet, how the states in such systems should be counted is a bone of contention. The traditional view developed by one of the fathers of statistical mechanics, Ludwig Boltzmann - who worked on a very large number of elements - is opposed to the seemingly disjointed theoretical perspective of another founding scientists of the discipline, Willard Gibbs, who describes systems with a very small number of elements.

In a new study published in EPJ Plus, Loris Ferrari from the University of Bologna, Italy, demystifies this clash between theories by analysing the practical consequences of Gibbs' definition in two systems of a well-defined size. Ferrari speculates about the possibility that, for certain quantities, the differences resulting from Boltzmann's and Gibbs' approach can be measured experimentally.

This debate centres around the notion of negative absolute temperature (NAT), seen as a misleading consequence of Boltzmann's definition of . In contrast, Gibbs' theory prohibits NAT and makes the energy equipartition rigorous in systems of arbitrary size. The two approaches, however, converge when the systems have a very large of elements. So the issue here is to define the minimum size system for which both theories agree.

To test the two approaches against each other, the author examines two models; namely a gas of N atoms which do not interact chemically and another system with N interacting spins. His numerical simulations show that it is possible to assess which of the two models is the most accurate using experimental proof.

Explore further: It's a negative on negative absolute temperatures

More information: Loris Ferrari, Comparing Boltzmann and Gibbs definitions of entropy in small systems, The European Physical Journal Plus (2017). DOI: 10.1140/epjp/i2017-11756-5

Related Stories

It's a negative on negative absolute temperatures

December 20, 2013

The concept of a perpetual motion machine is an enticing one: Imagine a machine that runs continuously without requiring any external energy—a feat that could make refueling vehicles a thing of the past.

Recommended for you

Mechanism helps explain the ear's exquisite sensitivity

January 16, 2019

The human ear, like those of other mammals, is so extraordinarily sensitive that it can detect sound-wave-induced vibrations of the eardrum that move by less than the width of an atom. Now, researchers at MIT have discovered ...

Understanding insulators with conducting edges

January 16, 2019

Insulators that are conducting at their edges hold promise for interesting technological applications. However, until now their characteristics have not been fully understood. Physicists at Goethe University have now modelled ...

0 comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.