New study finds timing is key in keeping organic matter in wet soils

New study finds timing is key in keeping organic matter in wet soils
Periodically wet soils, such as farm fields that flood for a few days or weeks at a time, may not retain organic matter as well as once believed, according to new research. Credit: Steven Hall

When it comes to keeping organic matter contained in wet soils, timing is everything. At least, that's what a new study led by an Iowa State University ecologist suggests.

The findings, published recently in the peer-reviewed academic journal Nature Communications, show periodically flooded soils may actually lose organic at accelerated rates, said Steven Hall, an assistant professor of ecology, evolution and organismal biology and corresponding author of the study. The findings contradict the widely held view that soils with high water content necessarily accumulate organic matter better than dry soils, which could have implications for agricultural and wetlands conservation practices, Hall said.

Keeping organic matter, or the remains left behind after crops and other plants die or are harvested, in the leads to two important benefits. First, optimal levels of organic matter in the soil improve fertility, Hall said. The second benefit concerns carbon sequestration. If the carbon that makes up much of the organic matter remains stored in the soil, then it doesn't get into the atmosphere where it can contribute to climate change.

Hall said wet soil cuts off oxygen to many of the microorganisms that break down organic matter, leading to slower decomposition and better retention in the soil. That's led to the belief that do a better job of keeping organic matter in place. But Hall's findings showed that the absence of oxygen in wet soils gives rise to some bacteria that respire iron, which break down the minerals that protect a significant portion of organic matter from decomposition. These bacteria then have free reign to decompose the organic matter and release carbon into the atmosphere as the greenhouse gases carbon dioxide and methane.

The study found timing plays a key role in how well wet soils retain organic matter. While soils with consistently high moisture content do retain organic matter over the long term, soils may actually lose organic matter during shorter spans of flooding. The findings have implications for agricultural fields that are poorly drained or flood for a few weeks of the year before drying out, Hall said. The study also shows that wetlands, considered a useful tool for conservation and carbon sequestration, may require consistent flooding to realize environmental benefits from organic matter accumulation.

"We found that periodically wet soils don't necessarily protect organic matter from decomposition and may lead to losses, at least over a timescale of weeks to months," he said.

The study drew on research conducted in an ISU laboratory. The researchers took soil samples from a central Iowa cornfield and subjected the sample to various conditions before conducting chemical analyses.

Hall said future research should widen in scope and include field experiments as well as laboratory-based work. He said he wants to test how various drainage techniques influence loss as well as pinpoint the length of time required for wet soil to realize environmental benefits.

Explore further

Researchers study organic matter processes in rice fields

More information: Wenjuan Huang et al. Elevated moisture stimulates carbon loss from mineral soils by releasing protected organic matter, Nature Communications (2017). DOI: 10.1038/s41467-017-01998-z
Journal information: Nature Communications

Citation: New study finds timing is key in keeping organic matter in wet soils (2017, November 28) retrieved 20 September 2019 from
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

Feedback to editors

User comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more