New examination of occupational licensing contradicts decades of research

October 17, 2017, Northwestern University

From doctors to engineers to carpet layers to massage therapists, more than one in three Americans is required to hold a license to work in their occupation. Broad consensus among researchers holds that licensure creates wage premiums by establishing economic monopolies, but according to Northwestern University research, licensure does not limit competition nor does it increase wages.

A new study, which is based on a new occupational dataset covering 30 years, contradicts decades of research on the impact of occupational licensing. The most comprehensive examination of licensing to date, the study relies on more than 4.5 million workers across 500 occupations.

The most substantial growth in professional licensure has been in blue-collar occupations, particularly the production and transportation sector, which has more than doubled its licensed workforce over the past 30 years.

"I argue that licensure, instead of increasing wages, creates a set of institutional mechanisms that enhance entry into the , particularly for historically disadvantaged groups, while simultaneously stagnating quality," said Beth Redbird, assistant professor of sociology in the Weinberg College of Arts and Sciences at Northwestern and author of the study.

Redbird said her study is different from previous examinations as it relies on two important innovations.

"By tracking licensing legislation across all 50 states, through an exhaustive search of statutes and administrative codes, licensed hairdressers in one state are compared to unlicensed hairdressers in another state, within that same year, licensed occupational therapists are compared to unlicensed occupational therapists, and so on.

"The second major innovation is that, for the first time, the effect of licensing can be studied over time. Using a longitudinal approach, this study examines wages in the years following enactment and sees exactly how they change when a law is passed," said Redbird, a faculty fellow with Northwestern's Institute for Policy Research.

Redbird said the typical weekly wage declines by between 0.19 percent and 1.23 percent due to licensure. Furthermore, results of the study show that after licensing, the number of workers in the occupation increases by an average of more than seven percent over original levels.

Redbird said the research could have implications for changing how workers enter an occupation.

"Through the lens of licensure, occupational elites can define the 'proper' way to practice, since license requirements are essentially comprehensive lists of ways to be excluded or removed. However, this may also limit innovation, reduce experimentation and perhaps hinder growth in knowledge. While practitioners in unlicensed markets are free to compete on all aspects of their occupations, licensed workers must obey legal limitations on both what they do and how they do it.

"On a broader scale, this formalization may rigidify the reward structure of an occupation, solidifying ," Redbird said. "Current research into wage gaps shows that, while more women enter licensed occupations, also tends to increase the wage gap as it reduces mobility for women."

Explore further: Licensing, motor vehicle crash risk among teens with ADHD

More information: "The New Closed Shop? The Economic and Structural Effects of Occupational Licensure" was published recently in the American Sociological Review.

Related Stories

Licensing, motor vehicle crash risk among teens with ADHD

June 12, 2017

Adolescents with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) are licensed to drive less often and, when this group is licensed, they have a greater risk of crashing, according to a new study published by JAMA Pediatrics.

Interstate medical licensure compact formed

June 4, 2015

(HealthDay)—Nine states have enacted the Interstate Medical Licensure Compact law, with the seventh state's enactment triggering formation of a commission to administer a process for physicians seeking licensure in multiple ...

'Credential creep' bad for health care practitioners, consumers

January 28, 2015

The outcome of a case argued before the U.S. Supreme Court last fall could potentially slow the trend of the ever-increasing number of occupations subject to state licensing, says a University of Illinois expert in the regulation ...

California's low-wage workers now earn less than in 1979

April 30, 2015

Over the past 35 years, California's high-wage workers have seen steady increases in their paychecks. But low-wage workers, 4.8 million strong and about one-third of the state's workforce, earned less in inflation-adjusted ...

Recommended for you

Coffee-based colloids for direct solar absorption

March 22, 2019

Solar energy is one of the most promising resources to help reduce fossil fuel consumption and mitigate greenhouse gas emissions to power a sustainable future. Devices presently in use to convert solar energy into thermal ...

EPA adviser is promoting harmful ideas, scientists say

March 22, 2019

The Trump administration's reliance on industry-funded environmental specialists is again coming under fire, this time by researchers who say that Louis Anthony "Tony" Cox Jr., who leads a key Environmental Protection Agency ...

2 comments

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Bongstar420
not rated yet Oct 17, 2017
Licensing should be about competency and free. The "pool" limiting factors should be the IQ level required to actually be able to pass the test. Too many licenses are just pay to play schemes.
Jeffhans1
not rated yet Oct 17, 2017
Licensing should be about competency and free. The "pool" limiting factors should be the IQ level required to actually be able to pass the test. Too many licenses are just pay to play schemes.

They are simply another method of restricting competition and innovation with the only winners being the ones controlling who gets the licenses.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.