Leiden econophysics model tested best by central banks

June 2, 2017, Leiden Institute of Physics
Credit: Leiden Institute of Physics

A full overview of all loans and debts between banks would prevent a new financial collapse. But banks do not provide this information. An econophysics model by Diego Garlaschelli and collaborators reconstructs the most probable situation and finishes first place in two independent tests.

The 2008 financial crisis made abundantly clear how unpredictable and vulnerable our banking system is. Banks are intertwined in a complex global web of debts and loans, where an initially local financial problem can lead to a cascade of bankruptcies. A detailed map of interbank links worldwide would enable the system to prevent dependencies from becoming too strong. However, banks do not disclose information on who they lend to and borrow from. They are only obliged to disclose their total debit and credit.

Hidden riskiness

For each bank, the lack of knowledge on how its debtors and creditors are connected to the rest of the system often implies a "hidden riskiness." This makes it difficult to decide the interest rate for loans. To circumvent this information deficit, Leiden physicist Diego Garlaschelli and a team of international collaborators built a theoretical based on statistical physics that calculates the probability of each bank borrowing money from another bank. His model was judged as the best probabilistic model by a collaboration of several central banks and by an independent research group.

Best model

These studies compared the performance of several alternative methods in reconstructing real privacy-protected interbank networks from partial information, and the model by Garlaschelli and collaborators was found the best one in both cases. 'Banks determine the interest rate for loans to other banks based on perceived riskiness,' Garlaschelli explains. 'If bank A has lent much money to bank B, which in turn has lent money to an unstable bank C, then bank A becomes unstable, as well. Our model reflects this, and can be used to estimate hidden risks and calculate more realistic interest rates. Correct rates keep the system stable.'

Old model

The old established model was solely based on the bare numbers for total debit/credit. For instance, to estimate the relation between Rabobank and ING, you multiply Rabobank's total debit with ING's credit and divide by the total sum in circulation worldwide. This creates a network where all banks are connected to each other. However, this ignores the fact that in reality, the majority of relations are non-existent; therefore, those that do exist are much heavier than what the old model predicts. And those links are precisely the ones that can propagate financial distress.

Density of links

Garlaschelli: 'Besides providing a reliable estimate of which banks are connected, our model calculates the most probable weight of each relationship, depending on only one unknown factor—the density of links in the system. And because this number appears to be quite stable inside a country, we can easily proxy it and then make a prediction on which links exist, and how heavy they are. Central can use this to better monitor the financial network and implement policies that prevent local instabilities from inflating into a hazard for the whole .'

Explore further: Policies believed to stabilize the financial system may actually do the opposite, study finds

More information: Methods for Reconstructing Interbank Networks from Limited Information: A Comparison DOI: 10.1007/978-3-319-47705-3_15

Kartik Anand et al. The missing links: A global study on uncovering financial network structures from partial data, Journal of Financial Stability (2017). DOI: 10.1016/j.jfs.2017.05.012

Giulio Cimini et al. Estimating topological properties of weighted networks from limited information, Physical Review E (2015). DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevE.92.040802

Giulio Cimini et al. Systemic Risk Analysis on Reconstructed Economic and Financial Networks, Scientific Reports (2015). DOI: 10.1038/srep15758

Related Stories

Big US banks unveil consumer payment app

October 24, 2016

Major US banking groups Monday announced they would join forces for a new person-to-person mobile payment application to counter services like PayPal's Venmo and Square Cash.

Recommended for you

Muons spin tales of undiscovered particles

April 20, 2018

Scientists at U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) national laboratories are collaborating to test a magnetic property of the muon. Their experiment could point to the existence of physics beyond our current understanding, including ...

Integrating optical components into existing chip designs

April 19, 2018

Two and a half years ago, a team of researchers led by groups at MIT, the University of California at Berkeley, and Boston University announced a milestone: the fabrication of a working microprocessor, built using only existing ...

1 comment

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

1 / 5 (2) Jun 03, 2017
President George W. Bush dried up the American money supply just when it was increasingly in demand by red Chinese communists wishing to escape their brutal regime as wealthy men. It was the lack of this fiat money that cratered the economy. The intensional harm done to the American economy was decided upon early in Bush's first administration in order to forward the political career of his mole successor, Barack Obama.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.