Securing large crowds a 'vexing problem'

May 24, 2017 by Molly Callahan, Northeastern University

Late Monday, an explosion at the end of an Ariana Grande concert at Manchester Arena in England killed 22 people and injured nearly 60 others. The New York Times reported Tuesday that British authorities had identified the bomber who carried out the attack; the deadliest in Britain since 2005.

Attacks of this sort often raise the question, 'How did this happen?' We asked Carey Rappaport, Distinguished Professor in the College of Engineering and an expert in , sensing, and surveillance systems, just that. Rappaport is deputy director of the Awareness and Localization of Explosive-Related Threats, or ALERT Center, a multidisciplinary and multi-university-led organization whose research is helping to improve the detection, mitigation, and response to explosive-related threats worldwide. The ALERT Center was also designated a Center of Excellence by the federal Department of Homeland Security.

Protecting thousands of people in a large public space without infringing on their privacy rights is "a vexing problem," Rappaport said. Indeed, even with a "dream" security device in place, there are still challenges.

What are some of the challenges authorities face trying to secure large venues?

Security in these large public places is a real challenge. England in particular has lots of in place already—they'll watch people in downtown London much more than we watch people in cities in the U.S. It's almost too much to watch, though. It's hard to make a determination about whether something is unusual or if someone is nefarious or bent on being destructive. Using video analytics to see if someone is acting differently from other people walking by is imperfect.

In this instance, you also had people leaving the arena and getting to the train station—those are people going from one secure area to another, but how do you protect those people when they're out in public?

When considering , there are privacy issues that have to be worked out, as well. We don't want to turn the whole world into a surveillance state. Indeed, it's a vexing problem.

What might be the ideal security measures to have in place?

The dream device, so to speak, at this point, is a hallway detector system, wherein pedestrians would walk between a pair of detection panels. The sensing and processing would occur fast enough that the person wouldn't have to stop to take off their jacket or empty their pockets, they wouldn't even have to break their stride. A combination of advanced interpretation algorithms and efficient scanning and computation would all have to work together to provide alerts of unusual concealed items.

Even in this scenario, however, you need people to make the final decision to pull someone aside and determine the risk. It would also be difficult to implement in a venue where there are thousands of people pushing through the doors at the same time, like you might have at a large arena.

Currently, metal detectors will detect handguns, machetes, or pocket knives, things of this nature. They won't detect an explosive. Meanwhile, security personnel are trying to keep the peace and keep pace with 10,000 people streaming in and out of a venue. It's extremely difficult to discern shady people, even with the best security.

What do you make of the target—in this case, a pop music concert?

This was a performance for teenagers and children—it wasn't a political rally, it wasn't even something where you have two sides, like a sporting event. For someone to cause this much carnage just shows that nothing is immune to these situations.

It hurts when someone goes after children. Unfortunately, in a world where things are a lot less safe than they perhaps used to be, it's not a matter of just throwing money at a problem; at its most basic level, this is knowing who your neighbor is, and what he or she is willing to do.

Explore further: Helping ease kids' fears after Manchester terror attack

Related Stories

Helping ease kids' fears after Manchester terror attack

May 23, 2017

(HealthDay)—As reports of the carnage at Monday's Ariana Grande show in Manchester, England, continue to pour in, many teens with tickets to concerts during the coming summer music season may be reluctant to attend an event.

How safe are U.S. airports?

September 5, 2016

The Transportation Security Administration is finding more firearms than ever at airport checkpoints. Over the past decade, gun seizures have taken off, rising from 660 in 2005 to 2,653 in 2015. And the number of confiscated ...

Recommended for you

Powering a pacemaker with a patient's heartbeat

February 20, 2019

Implantable pacemakers have without doubt altered modern medicine, saving countless lives by regulating heart rhythm. But they have one serious shortcoming: Their batteries last only five to 12 years, at which point they ...

The global impact of coal power

February 20, 2019

Coal-fired power plants produce more than just carbon dioxide, which contributes to global warming. Coal burning also releases particulate matter, sulphur dioxide, nitrogen oxide and mercury—thus damaging the health of ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.