'Peeling the onion' to get rid of odors near wastewater treatment plants

April 2, 2017, American Chemical Society
water
Credit: George Hodan/public domain

Powerful nuisance odors from sewage and wastewater treatment facilities are a worldwide problem, but finding and eliminating the sources of such unpleasant aromas can be difficult. Scientists have compared the search to peeling an onion—one layer is found and removed, but then a second and third emerge, ready to make their odoriferous presence known. Scientists have now developed a system to sample, measure, categorize and control these smells and are applying it from Seattle to Sydney.

The researchers will present their results today at the 253rd National Meeting & Exposition of the American Chemical Society (ACS). ACS, the world's largest scientific society, is holding the meeting here through Thursday.

"Vomit, burnt matches, canned corn, musty odors, fecal matter, rotten eggs—all of these scents have been reported in areas near plants," Jay Witherspoon, leader of a research team at CH2M, notes. Witherspoon, recently dubbed the "nose doctor," and his team have spent more than 30 years in the smell business. "Each has its own source and is often found in mixtures, making identification of the sources of these smells challenging," he explains.

"People have become more sensitive to odors, and they are living closer to treatment facilities," Witherspoon notes. In the past, plants were built far from where people lived, but today homes are built ever closer to such facilities as cities have expanded. "Smells have become a quality of life issue," he says.

For field testing, Irwin Suffet, Ph.D., a collaborator from the University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA), developed an "odor wheel." It displays public-friendly general descriptions of a range of smells on the outside and the chemical composition of the smelly agents on the inside. The team uses this wheel to ask the public about a bothersome stench. To capture and measure odors, the researchers use plastic bags, metal containers, sorbent tubes, hand held devices and electronic noses. The samples are then analyzed in laboratories using both sensitive detection devices and human panels. One of the detection devices is typically a mass spectrometer, which can help identify the compounds that make up the offensive scent. The human odor panels determine how strong and offensive the smell is to people, based on their experience.

Once identified, the chemical and its aroma can be eliminated with scrubbers, biofilters or the introduction of other chemicals that can mask the offensive one.

Over the years, the most common stink—the odor of rotten eggs from hydrogen sulfide—has been mostly eliminated by extensive chemical and biological odor control equipment. However, Witherspoon notes, other smells can cause concern, such as the odor of rotten vegetables that can come from methyl mercaptan and dimethyl disulfide; the canned corn smell emitted by dimethyl sulfide; the musty smells from 2-methyl isoborneol and 2-isopropyl-3-methoxypyrazine; the fecal odor of skatole and indole; and the pungent smell of ammonia.

The cheapest way to control these chemicals is at their source but that is not always possible, Witherspoon says. For instance, an odor from a chemical emitted by an industrial facility was not apparent until the compound reached a Philadelphia sewage treatment plant. The strong odor of dimethyl sulfide was only released when the chemical was exposed to oxygen and bacteria in the sewage treatment facility's aeration tank.

Right now, Witherspoon and other researchers are working to refine and standardize the technology to measure and control odors. Currently, Witherspoon has to take most of the samples to his collaborator at UCLA for analysis, but he says this technique is being expanded to other laboratories and is spreading throughout the industry as a whole as a viable alternative to traditional methods.

Explore further: What's behind the durian fruit's notorious stench

More information: From Philly to smell A - tracking, measuring, and controlling non-H2S odor nuisances, 253rd National Meeting & Exposition of the American Chemical Society (ACS), 2017.

Related Stories

What's behind the durian fruit's notorious stench

January 18, 2017

Most people who have tried durian either love it or hate it. The fruit's yellowish flesh is sweet and custard-like, but it comes with an overpowering stench of garbage. Scientists studying the unique fruit have now analyzed ...

A 'time switch' in the brain improves sense of smell

July 8, 2016

When the brain processes olfactory stimuli, it differentiates between similar smells using subtly modulated signals. Brain examinations and behavioral studies in mice have now shown that neurons with inhibiting characteristics ...

Recommended for you

Wearable device measures cortisol in sweat

July 20, 2018

The hormone cortisol rises and falls naturally throughout the day and can spike in response to stress, but current methods for measuring cortisol levels require waiting several days for results from a lab. By the time a person ...

Researchers report two-faced Janus membrane applications

July 20, 2018

Named for the mythical god with two faces, Janus membranes—double-sided membranes that serve as gatekeepers between two substances—have emerged as a material with potential industrial uses. Creating two distinct "faces" ...

Chemists characterize the fatal fungus among us

July 19, 2018

Life-threatening fungal infections affect more than two million people worldwide. Effective antifungal medications are very limited. Until now, one of the major challenges is that the fungal cell wall is poorly understood, ...

Infrared sensor as new method for drug discovery

July 19, 2018

Using an infrared sensor, biophysicists at Ruhr-Universität Bochum (RUB) have succeeded in analysing quickly and easily which active agents affect the structure of proteins and how long that effect lasts. Thus, Prof Dr. ...

2 comments

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

ab3a
not rated yet Apr 02, 2017
The location of a plant is a recurring problem. My employer used to have a sludge composting facility that produced a very highly regarded fertilizer. It was sold all over the region, including to the White House. So if you used the toilet in the Washington DC region in the 1980s and 1990s, some of your poo is on the White House lawn. That thought warms my heart no matter who is in office.

Unfortunately, despite building the facility in what was an underpopulated area, despite putting the fermentation piles in sheds, despite an aggressive odor control system, we still got complaints about the smell. It was shut down.

Now we stabilize the sludge and truck it even further away to be applied on to farm fields. I don't see how that was much of an improvement.
Dingbone
Apr 02, 2017
This comment has been removed by a moderator.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.