Social media complaints can be alternative to market discipline, study shows

Nothing inspires consumer frustration quite like an airline flight delay. Researchers from the University of Toronto's Rotman School of Management have used those meltdown moments – and the complaints they produce via the social media platform Twitter – to study how consumer "voice" may influence business behaviour.

"We thought were an important part of the economy but, until now, we haven't had a systematic way to measure them," says study co-author Mara Lederman, an associate professor of at Rotman.

The accepted idea among economists is that markets act to discipline companies for poor performance as consumers will withdraw their business if they are not happy. Complaining – as opposed to switching – has been suggested as an alternate mechanism but, to date, has received much less attention.

The public nature of , however, now makes it possible to track consumer complaints, the market circumstances under which they're made and how companies respond. This opens the door for studies that examine the purpose and impact of customer voice.

Not surprisingly, the researchers found that passenger complaints via Twitter increase when an airline's "on-time" performance worsened.  This was based on an analysis of approximately four million Tweets made to or about the top seven American airlines over a two-year period.

What was more interesting is that the same deterioration in on-time performance generated about 50 percent more complaints when the airline was the dominant carrier in the passenger's local market. Airlines also responded more often when competition was limited and when the passenger mentioned the airline's loyalty program in their tweet.

These finding suggest that companies in low competition markets may have the most to lose from ticked-off customers because these customers generate high margins yet have the ability to go elsewhere if they are not happy, says Prof. Lederman. The same goes for customers who are invested in a company's loyalty program– these are the very customers that are costly for the company to lose.

"In markets where you don't have a lot of competition, but you have some, voice might be effective because this precisely when companies will care to retain customers who have been made unhappy," she says.

Prof. Lederman carried out the study with fellow Rotman researchers Joshua Gans, a professor of strategic management and Avi Goldfarb, a professor of marketing.

Their results suggest using social media to complain can be worthwhile, so long as a company values the customer enough to respond and offer some incentive for them to stay (whether monetary or simply a promise to do better in the future). Companies, meanwhile, may want to consider setting up dedicated complaint channels as a way of retaining valuable customers who might be at risk of leaving, says Prof. Lederman.


Explore further

New model shows companies how to tailor call center service to different customer types

More information: Gans, Joshua S. and Goldfarb, Avi and Lederman, Mara. Exit, Tweets, and Loyalty (December 23, 2016). dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2889388
Citation: Social media complaints can be alternative to market discipline, study shows (2017, March 2) retrieved 26 June 2019 from https://phys.org/news/2017-03-social-media-complaints-alternative-discipline.html
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.
5 shares

Feedback to editors

User comments

Mar 10, 2017
It can, but when you make it so you become victim of astroturfing.

Social media is best handled as anecdotal evidence.

Mar 10, 2017
Any smart company would look for early signals so they could correct course before running aground. Market performance is a following indicator--if your performance is down, you have already lost market share or profits. Customer complaints are a leading indicator--you still have the customers, so you still have their money and concomitant profits, but you are at risk of losing them. Investors should pay attention to the corporate response to predict future performance.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more