Crowdsourcing effort helps researchers predict how a molecule will smell

February 20, 2017 by Katherine Fenz, Rockefeller University
Crowdsourcing effort helps researchers predict how a molecule will smell
Sniff test: To better capture the full range of the human sense of smell, researchers asked volunteers to sniff 476 molecules. Credit: Rockefeller University

You can anticipate a color before you see it, based solely on the length of light waves. Music can be interpreted from notes on a page without being heard. Not so with odor. The only way to tell if something will smell like roses or turpentine, sea breeze or gasoline, is to sniff it.

New research, described in Science on February 24, is making the most mysterious of our senses a little more predictable. A project initiated by Rockefeller University scientists and powered by a crowdsourcing effort has devised a mathematical model that can forecast the scent a molecule will evoke.

"This is a centuries-old problem. People have attempted to work around it in many different ways, as you can see in the perfume section of a department store, when the clerks ask 'do you like something floral?' or 'do you like something musky?'" says study researcher Leslie Vosshall, the Robin Chemers Neustein Professor.

"We haven't completely solved the question of how to predict an odor based on the chemical properties of the that convey it, but this is the furthest anyone has pushed toward an explanation," she adds.

The good, the bad, and the odorless

As head of Rockefeller's Laboratory of Neurogenetics and Behavior, Vosshall studies odor perception in humans and insects. As part of this work, she and Andreas Keller, a research associate in her lab, set out to explore the link between molecules and the scent they give off.

To get the data they needed, they asked volunteers to sniff a carefully curated set of molecules, each contained in a little vial. The possibilities were nearly endless—while the limits on human perception of light and sound are well known, no such boundaries have been established for odor. So in an effort to explore the full range of our sense of smell, Keller assembled a diverse cast of 476 molecules, many of which had never been tested in smell studies before.

He included familiar aromas, like the sweet warmth of vanillin and the reek of methylthiobutyrate, a stinky-cheese molecule. He also selected molecules sniffers were unlikely to recognize—2-isopropylphenol, anyone?—and even those thought to be odorless, like water and glycerol. The 49 study volunteers rated each based on how strong they found it, how pleasant, and to what degree it evoked garlic, flower, urine, and 16 other attributes.

Altogether, this effort generated more than 1 million data points. The researchers then sought to link this perceptual information to more than 2 million additional data points describing chemical features of the smell molecules, such as the number of sulfur atoms they contain. It took a crowd to solve this problem.

A community effort

Twenty-two teams of computationally savvy volunteers hailing from research institutions and companies around the world participated in the DREAM Olfaction Prediction Challenge, which was organized by study researcher Pablo Meyer, a team leader at IBM's Thomas J. Watson Research Center. Using Vosshall's and Keller's odor ratings, one of the largest sets of such data ever collected, these teams devised algorithms that could "learn" to predict an odor's attributes based on a molecule's chemical features.

The best solution didn't appear in any single model. To take advantage of the wisdom of the crowd, DREAM challenges typically merge their submissions into an aggregate model, one that is often more powerful than any individual model.

"A DREAM Challenge is more like hitting a piñata at a party than a normal research project: Everyone swings, and even if your algorithms don't break it open, you still contribute to the solution," Meyer says. "With this approach, a robust set of data, and a little luck, we were able to crack this particularly difficult problem."

Filling in the gap

At the end of the challenge, the researchers tested the performance of the aggregate model using ratings they had held back on 69 molecules as a sort of answer key. A perfect score for matching attribute profiles to molecules would have been 1.0; the model scored 0.83, significantly better than any previous attempts to solve this problem.

The smells that the models could most easily predict were garlic and fish, probably because the sniffers generally agreed on how to apply them while rating odors. Other attributes, such as cold or acid, were more challenging, probably because there is less consensus about what these terms mean for an odor, Vosshall says.

While not yet perfect, the smell prediction model opens new possibilities for perfume chemists looking for more efficient ways to formulate, say, the perfect scent of dusky rose. It also shines new light on the immensely complex biology of smell perception. No one fully understands what happens when waft into the nose and are converted into electrical signals that travel to the brain.

"Once you can associate the input of the chemical structure and the output of an odor, you can start to delineate what might be happening during that translation," says Vosshall who is a Howard Hughes Medical Institute investigator. "This model is an important initial step in that direction."

Explore further: Humans, flies smell alike, neurobiologists find

More information: Predicting human olfactory perception from chemical features of odor molecules. Science. DOI: 10.1126/science.aal0787

Related Stories

Humans, flies smell alike, neurobiologists find

March 26, 2007

The nose knows – whether it’s on a fruit fly or a human. And while it would seem that how a fruit fly judges odors should differ from how a human smells, new research from Rockefeller University finds that at the neurobiological ...

Gene determines whether male body odor smells pleasant

September 16, 2007

To many, urine smells like urine and vanilla smells like vanilla. But androstenone, a derivative of testosterone that is a potent ingredient in male body odor, can smell like either - depending on your genes. While many people ...

What's behind the durian fruit's notorious stench

January 18, 2017

Most people who have tried durian either love it or hate it. The fruit's yellowish flesh is sweet and custard-like, but it comes with an overpowering stench of garbage. Scientists studying the unique fruit have now analyzed ...

A 'time switch' in the brain improves sense of smell

July 8, 2016

When the brain processes olfactory stimuli, it differentiates between similar smells using subtly modulated signals. Brain examinations and behavioral studies in mice have now shown that neurons with inhibiting characteristics ...

Recommended for you

Fish-inspired material changes color using nanocolumns

March 20, 2019

Inspired by the flashing colors of the neon tetra fish, researchers have developed a technique for changing the color of a material by manipulating the orientation of nanostructured columns in the material.

1 comment

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

rderkis
1 / 5 (1) Feb 20, 2017
He included familiar aromas, like the sweet warmth of vanilla and .. a stinky-cheese molecule.

Good thing he was objective and did not have any preconceived ideas about what vanilla or cheese smelled like. :-)

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.