Top news outlets see more risks than benefits in employees' use of social media

Top news outlets see more risks than benefits in employees' use of social media
Lehigh University assistant professor of journalism Jayeon "Janey Lee" finds in a new study that top news organizations focused more on risks than benefits of employees' use of social media. Credit: Lehigh University.

Realizing the risks of social media, major news organizations have created guidelines for employees regarding how to use these outlets, separate from the companies' existing codes of conduct. Little scholarly attention has been paid to the guidelines so far.

Now, Jayeon Lee, assistant professor of journalism at Lehigh University, has analyzed the and finds that are more concerned about the current social media environment than excited about it at least when it comes to their employees.

She details her findings in a study called "Opportunity or risk? How news organizations frame social media in their guidelines for journalists," set to be published in the print edition of The Communication Review in the fall.

The study, a content analysis of the social media guidelines of nine American news organizations—The New York Times, The Associated Press, Bloomberg, Los Angeles Times, The Wall Street Journal, The Washington Post, CNN, and NPR—and three British news organizations—BBC, The Times, and The Daily Telegraph—investigates how these employers frame messages about employee social media usage.

"I was wondering what approaches news organizations take when it comes to their own employees' social media uses," Lee said. "In particular, knowing both positive and negative implications of journalists' social media uses, I wanted to see if their guidelines were dominantly positive, negative, or neutral in their framing of the implications."

Overall, Lee found that the guidelines focus primarily on the risks and challenges presented by the use of social media rather than the opportunities and advantages for media.

"As some media critics point out, overreaching rules can stifle creativity and morale and even discourage overall social media use itself," she explained.

According to the study, news organizations are most concerned about: accuracy, breaking objectivity, inappropriate online behaviors, and harming news organizations' principles and credibility. Accuracy—sourcing or redistributing false information from social media without sufficient fact verification—was the most frequently raised topic and accounted for 17.8 percent of the total sentences studied.

"The results show that the prevention-focused approach is more common than I would have predicted," she said. "Although I expected that the guidelines would include various warnings related to risky social media activities, I was surprised to find little comment about how to use social media wisely or effectively to derive full benefit from it."

Lee recognized that news organizations are actively utilizing various social media to reach a wider audience and build brand loyalty. "However, it seems they are keen on keeping their own employees from actively engaging in ."

Explore further

New study reveals television newsroom social media practices policies lag behind

More information: Jayeon Lee, Opportunity or risk? How news organizations frame social media in their guidelines for journalists, The Communication Review (2016). DOI: 10.1080/10714421.2016.1161328
Provided by Lehigh University
Citation: Top news outlets see more risks than benefits in employees' use of social media (2016, July 12) retrieved 23 September 2019 from
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

Feedback to editors

User comments

Jul 12, 2016
News networks only promote FEAR! News networks only promote the negative! Why has every news network since the Great Recession warned the people of an upcoming recession? Why have the economy and the U.S. stock markets gone straight upward the entire time the news has been warning us of a looming recession on the horizon? The news is far from the truth, the news is actually the anti-truth! It is easy to go back and research the history of predictive news headlines and see how the news has misguided the people throughout history. We now have Google and the internet's web history to thank for the ability to research the news' harmful ways! We the People will not be misguided and fooled by smoke and mirrors any longer! Join the fight!!

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more