New discovery may help engineers design quieter jet airplanes

April 26, 2016
Contours of decibel levels of the sound emitted from a supersonic jet. The nozzle exit is located at the magenta dot in each figure, and the jet flows from the nozzle to the right. Jet noise is computed using high-fidelity large eddy simulation (LES) in the top panel, using one wavepacket computed from the parabolized stability equations (PSE) in the middle panel, and through a superposition of input-output (I/O) modes from the new analysis technique in the bottom panel. While all three methods capture the peak jet noise at an angle of 30°, I/O modes also recover sideline noise as observed in the high-fidelity simulation. Credit: Joseph W. Nichols /University of Minnesota

If you've ever experienced the exceptionally powerful and reverberating sounds of a jet during takeoff, you likely won't be surprised that the noise produced by jet engines is ranked among the loudest of human-generated noises.

Understanding is an intriguing fundamental problem of fluid physics—beguiling researchers for more than 60 years. Some of this fascination with jet noise stems from the fact that seemingly random fluctuations associated with flow turbulence produce strikingly ordered acoustic fields. In other words: If we can understand how turbulent jets make noise, it will in turn provide a fundamentally new understanding of the turbulence behind it.

As a group of University of Minnesota researchers report in Physics of Fluids they developed a new approach to studying turbulence in jets. Their approach led to the discovery of new coherent modes—parts of the fluid that flow in predictable patterns—associated with the dynamics of high-speed jets. The finding helps explain why jets are so loud, and could suggest new approaches for bringing down the volume.

"Back during the 1960s, it was shown that coherent parts of turbulent fluctuations inside jets are connected to instability wavepackets, which are linked to noise radiation," said Joseph W. Nichols, an assistant professor of aerospace engineering and mechanics at the University of Minnesota. "A wavepacket is an oscillation that repeats if you look at it over short time and length scales, but when you zoom out you can see it varies slowly over a long distance."

This slow variation, for example, may be caused by the jet spreading out downstream. "The same basic principle applies to amplitude modulation [AM] radio, where modulation of a high-frequency carrier wave communicates information about low-frequency speech patterns," he explained. "In jet noise, this carrier wave is driven by fluid instabilities that feed on the energy contained inside the jet. Instead of encoding speech patterns, however, the amplitude modulation of instability wavepackets determines the efficiency and spatial direction at which sound is released from jet turbulence."

In recent years, other researchers computed instability wavepackets and found that they predicted peak jet noise for supersonic jets. "For high-speed subsonic jets, however, the theory breaks down—underestimating sound pressure levels by at least two orders of magnitude," Nichols said. "A prevailing view underlying current industry-standard jet noise prediction codes is that fine-scale turbulence is responsible for this missing sound, and that this phenomenon can only be modeled statistically."

In stark contrast, Nichols and colleagues looked at turbulent jets through the lens of the whole system, rather than individual components—an approach with roots in electrical engineering and control theory. "We treat high-speed turbulent jets as amplifiers that take turbulent fluctuations inside the jet as inputs and give back sound in the region far away from the jet as outputs," said Mihailo Jovanovi? an associate professor of electrical and computer engineering at the University of Minnesota. "And we use this mathematical framework to identify modes that induce large input-output amplification and generate loud noise."

The interdisciplinary research team confirmed the existence of these new modes using high-fidelity simulations of high-speed jets. The researchers numerically solved the compressible Navier-Stokes equations—which describe the motion of viscous fluids—by subdividing a high-speed jet flow into hundreds of millions of small pieces. "Each of these small pieces communicates with neighboring pieces to build up a picture of the large range of scales of turbulent motion," said Jinah Jeun a graduate student in aerospace engineering and mechanics at the University of Minnesota.

Running such a simulation can require hundreds of thousands of computer processors, simultaneously, on some of the most powerful supercomputers in the world—housed at the Argonne National Laboratory and at Department of Defense supercomputing centers. "Although high-fidelity simulations consume millions of CPU-hours, we apply our new analysis to extract from them information needed to construct accurate reduced-order models that can be run in minutes on a laptop useful for aeroacoustic design," Jeun said.

In terms of applications for the group's work, reducing jet noise has a large impact on the health and safety of airport personnel as well as on communities surrounding airports.

Their computations also enable an understanding of physics phenomena that are inaccessible experimentally, for example because they happen in an extreme environment that can't be outfitted with sensors. "Input-output analysis, for example, may be applied to figure out how upstream turbulence inside the nozzle affects flow downstream," Jeun noted.

In general, noise is a fascinating way to find structure in otherwise chaotic flows because of its sensitivity to coherence. As such, these simulation and analysis techniques can be applied to "a broader range of problems, such as understanding instabilities in the wakes of wind turbines, investigating acoustic-flame interactions for the design of safer and more efficient combustion, and explaining shock-induced transition in hypersonic boundary layers," Nichols said.

Explore further: Simulations helps scientists understand and control turbulence in humans and machines

More information: "Input-output analysis of high-speed axisymmetric isothermal jet noise," Physics of Fluids, DOI: 10.1063/1.4946886

Related Stories

UC discoveries could help quiet the world's cities

August 14, 2012

They’re sleek. They’re fast. They’re powerful. And, they are deafening. Furthermore, those Top Gun military jets need to be up in the air in the wee hours – over land – to simulate their landings ...

Magnetic fields in powerful radio jets

December 28, 2015

Super-massive black holes at the centers of galaxies can spawn tremendous bipolar jets when matter in the vicinity forms a hot, accreting disk around the black hole. The rapidly moving charged particles in the jets radiate ...

Researchers break million-core supercomputer barrier

January 28, 2013

Stanford Engineering's Center for Turbulence Research (CTR) has set a new record in computational science by successfully using a supercomputer with more than one million computing cores to solve a complex fluid dynamics ...

Recommended for you

Astronomers use bubbles to look for WIMPs

May 23, 2017

Invisible, imperceptible and yet far more common than ordinary matter, dark matter makes up an astounding 85 percent of the universe's mass. Physicists are slowly but steadily tracking down the nature of this unidentified ...

Weyl fermions exhibit paradoxical behavior

May 23, 2017

Theoretical physicists have found Weyl fermions to exhibit paradoxical behavior in contradiction to a 30-year-old fundamental theory of electromagnetism. The discovery has possible applications in spintronics. The study ...

Turmoil in sluggish electrons' existence

May 22, 2017

An international team of physicists has monitored the scattering behavior of electrons in a non-conducting material in real-time. Their insights could be beneficial for radiotherapy.


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.