For virtual reality creators, motion sickness a real issue

March 18, 2016 by Derrik J. Lang
For virtual reality creators, motion sickness a real issue
In this Jan. 6, 2016 file photo, Peijun Guo wears the Oculus Rift VR headset at the Oculus booth at CES International in Las Vegas. PlayStation VR's debut will follow the respective launches of the Oculus Rift and HTC Vive consumer versions. The Rift will be available March 28 for $599, the company announced Tuesday, March 15, 2016, during the Game Developers Conference. (AP Photo/John Locher, File)

If the controls and movement in a traditional video game aren't natural, it's merely annoying to players. For designers of virtual reality experiences, the same mistake could make users sick.

With the release of a trio of high-definition headsets on the horizon, many VR aficionados in attendance at this week's Game Developers Conference in San Francisco are confronting that issue head on.

The low-latency headsets from Oculus, HTC and Sony are intended to right the nausea-inducing wrongs of their VR predecessors from 20 years ago, but many users still report feeling woozy after using souped-up systems, such as the Oculus Rift.

"The challenge is that people's sensitivity to motion and simulator sickness varies wildly," said Evan Suma, an assistant professor who studies VR at the University of Southern California, during a talk at the 30th annual gathering of game creators.

It's a unique design challenge for game makers accustom to crafting interactive entertainment appearing on flat screens in front of gamers, not completely encasing them.

Despite the advancements made in VR over the past four years, there's still concern the immersive technology may force players to lose more than a battle with an alien. They could also lose their lunch.

For virtual reality creators, motion sickness a real issue
This June 11, 2015, file photo, shows the new Oculus Rift virtual reality headset on display following a news conference in San Francisco. Virtual reality is big at South by Southwest Interactive, the annual Austin, Texas, tech festival wrapping up Tuesday, March 15, 2016. It's a big business opportunity, a big technological development, and also a big experiment, as everyone tries to figure out how to use it. Facebook's long-awaited Oculus Rift begins shipping to the public later this month, and new headsets from Samsung and Sony are also on their way. (AP Photo/Eric Risberg, File)

"It's been a huge focus of development," said Hilmar Petursson, CEO of CCP Games, which is developing several VR games, including the sci-fi dogfighting simulator "EVE: Valkyrie." ''We want super comfort all the way."

Petursson said the developers of "Valkyrie" opted to surround seated players with a virtual cockpit to ground and shelter them from the effects of appearing to whiz through space past asteroids, missiles and ships.

Other designers are attempting to tackle the problem by limiting movement in virtual worlds and not inundating players with head-spinning stimuli.

"If you have something for your brain to fixate on as the thing that matches similar inputs you're given when sitting in the real world, you're going to be feeling a lot better," said Palmer Luckey, co-founder of Oculus, which ignited the latest VR revolution in 2012.

Oculus and Sony both posted health and safety warnings outside their booths on the GDC show floor, cautioning attendees trying the Rift and PlayStation VR that they may feel motion sickness, nausea, disorientation and blurred vision. Those effects were felt by many attendees.

"After a morning's worth of different Rift games, I felt disorientated, a touch nauseous and distinctly headachey," wrote Keza MacDonald on the gaming site Kotaku. "After five hours, I felt like I needed a lie-down in a dark room."

For virtual reality creators, motion sickness a real issue
In this March 19, 2014 file photo, Marcus Ingvarsson tests out the PlayStation 4 virtual reality headset Project Morpheus in a demo area at the Game Developers Conference 2014 in San Francisco. Sony's version of virtual reality will cost a few hundred dollars less than competitors when its headset is released in October. the company announced Tuesday, March 15, 2016, during the Game Developers Conference. (AP Photo/Jeff Chiu, File)

Kimberly Voll, senior technical designer at Radial Games, noted during her GDC speech about the effects of VR on the brain that more academic research about VR should be conducted.

"We really need to look hard at the effects of long-term exposure to VR, the psychological effects and what we can say about the power of our VR experiences," said Voll, who has studied computer and cognitive science.

With hype for VR at an all-time high and pre-orders for the Rift and HTC Vive sold out, it's no longer a question of if consumers will want to experience VR. They do. It's now becoming a matter of how long it's safe to keep it on their noggins.

Would two hours in VR be too much?

"With the current technology, it's iffy," said Luckey. "It's all technologically solvable. It's not like we're saying, 'Oh no. We can't get any better. This is a dead end.' We have tons of ways to make this higher resolution, lighter weight and more comfortable. Eventually, the goal is to make something that's not much heavier than a pair of sunglasses."

For many who've tried VR, it's not an issue at all. Hidden Path Entertainment founder Jeff Pobst said he recently spent 15 hours wearing the Rift headset while playing the VR version of his strategy game, "Defense Grid 2."

"I was happy," said Pobst. "I even did it with glasses on and didn't take the headset off to put in my contacts. It all depends on the person and the experience. When there's not a lot of movement and the controls aren't tiring, I think you can be in VR indefinitely."

Explore further: VR's future to become clearer at video game conference

More information: www.gdconf.com

Related Stories

Oculus unveils new prototype VR headset

September 20, 2014

Oculus has unveiled a new prototype of its virtual reality headset. However, the VR company still isn't ready to release a consumer edition.

Recommended for you

Dutch open 'world's first 3D-printed bridge'

October 17, 2017

Dutch officials toasted on Tuesday the opening of what is being called the world's first 3D-printed concrete bridge, which is primarily meant to be used by cyclists.

2 comments

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

KBK
not rated yet Mar 18, 2016
The issue issue that one is completely relearning eye parameters... tied to balance, vestibular canals, and all that as connected to muscle function. All as a set.

Re-learning a secondary path, at the deepest levels that the body has.

Each game and each headset is encoded/built differently.

Thus we have not just one problem, but many problems, across platforms and across software.
ShotmanMaslo
not rated yet Mar 19, 2016
The issue is not eye parameters (whatever that means). The main issue is indeed just one problem: sensory mismatch between visual and vestibular system. Eyes are telling you that you are moving, while inner ear registers no acceleration.

This is not something that could be solved with better VR headsets, unless those headsets include things like galvanic vestibular stimulation (not going to happen anytime soon).

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.