Social media link to attacks poses conundrum

December 15, 2015 by Sophie Estienne
It remains to be seen how much can be done by social networks designed for sharing updates and which have hundreds of millions o
It remains to be seen how much can be done by social networks designed for sharing updates and which have hundreds of millions of users

Pressure is growing on social networks to play a bigger role in finding and weeding out jihadists and others looking to recruit members and plot deadly attacks.

But it's more complicated than it sounds: networks like Facebook and Twitter support free expression, and filtering our bad actors is challenging both from a technical and perspective.

Still, US and European officials are pressing social media to do more following deadly attacks over the past few weeks in Paris and southern California which have been linked to supporters of the Islamic State organization.

A White House statement earlier this month called for "a dialogue" with Silicon Valley and others on the subject, saying more should be done "when the use of social media crosses the line between communication and active terrorist plotting."

The European Commission has also called for dialogue with the major .

And France passed emergency measures that could shut down websites or social media accounts which encourage terrorist actions.

Concerns have been rising amid increased presence on social networks of radical groups that seek to recruit fighters and communicate for planning.

FBI Director James Comey said the Islamic State organization, also known by the acronym ISIL, "has persistently used the Internet to communicate, and its widespread reach through the Internet and social media is most concerning."

Comey said that through social media, "the message of radicalization spreads faster than we imagined just a few years ago."

In Congress, Senators Dianne Feinstein and Richard Burr proposed legislation to require online communications services to report potential terrorist activity.

"That information can be the key to identifying and stopping terrorist recruitment or a terrorist attack, but we need help from technology companies," said Feinstein, from California.

Consequences for freedom

Concerns have been rising amid increased presence on social networks of radical groups that seek to recruit fighters and communi
Concerns have been rising amid increased presence on social networks of radical groups that seek to recruit fighters and communicate for planning

But it remains to be seen how much can be done by networks designed for sharing updates and which have hundreds of millions of users. And some say even if they could help in the fight against radicalization, the civil liberties price would be too high.

"Having government pressuring, or encouraging companies to do more, carries with it a lot of consequences for individual freedom," says Emma Llanso, a free speech specialist at the Center for Democracy and Technology.

An open letter from technology organizations including the Internet Association, which represents major social networks, warned of the negative consequences of the proposal known as the Requiring Reporting of Online Terrorist Activity Act.

Such a law "would impose a new government mandate requiring a broad spectrum of companies to report users' activities and communications to the US government, ultimately not achieving national security gains," the letter said.

The proposal "risks chilling free speech, including counterterrorism speech, and also chilling innovation" and "it contradicts and undermines 20 years of federal Internet policy that remains the legal foundation of the Internet's transformative role in promoting democratic values and free speech worldwide."

Although online companies are able to detect and report child pornography using algorithms and a database of inappropriate content, applying this to terrorism is more challenging.

"Millions of pieces of content are received every day, making the idea of proactive monitoring and viewing before posting and uploading completely impossible," Llanso said.

Voluntary efforts

Social media groups say they already do what they can to avoid being used to spread hate and violence.

"There is no place on Facebook for terrorists, terrorist propaganda or the praising of terror," said Monika Bickert of the world's biggest social network, saying it employs a global team which works around the clock in numerous languages for monitoring.

France has passed emergency measures that could shut down websites or social media accounts which encourage terrorist actions
France has passed emergency measures that could shut down websites or social media accounts which encourage terrorist actions

"Our community standards make this clear, and we work aggressively to ensure that we do not have terrorists or terror groups using the site."

Twitter says it has a similar policy and also actively monitors its network.

"Violent threats and the promotion of terrorism deserve no place on Twitter and our rules make that clear," a spokesman said.

The video-sharing service YouTube, owned by Google parent Alphabet, "has a strong track record of taking swift action against terrorist content," a spokesman said.

"We have clear policies prohibiting terrorist recruitment and content intending to incite violence and quickly remove videos violating these policies when flagged by our users. We also terminate accounts run by terrorist organizations or those that repeatedly violate our policies."

US and European officials are pressing social media to do more following deadly attacks over the past few weeks in Paris and sou
US and European officials are pressing social media to do more following deadly attacks over the past few weeks in Paris and southern California which have been linked to supporters of the Islamic State organization.

But mandatory legislation raises a risk that firms will overreport to remain in compliance, said Sophia Cope of the Electronic Frontier Foundation, and in doing so raises suspicion on many law-abiding citizens.

"These people will be under the cloud of government suspicion for exercising their First Amendment rights," she said.

Michael Beckerman, president and chief executive of the Internet Association, agreed, saying the Burr-Feinstein measure would lead to "a vague and unworkable standard for reporting and a massive new liability regime that could chill and innovation online.

He added: "The legislation incentivizes Internet platforms to overreport, even poor quality information, to authorities, making it more difficult to find credible threats."

Explore further: Lawmakers want social media companies to report extremists (Update)

Related Stories

Could Twitter stop the next terrorist attack?

July 24, 2015

Social media giants including Twitter, Yahoo, Facebook and Google are pushing back against Senate legislation that would require them to alert federal authorities of any terrorist activity, according to industry and government ...

Senator objects to anti-terrorism rules for online sites

July 28, 2015

Sen. Ron Wyden, an Oregon Democrat and skeptic of broad government surveillance, objected Tuesday to a bill that would have required social media and online sites like Google, Yahoo, Twitter and Facebook to alert federal ...

Recommended for you

Google, EU dig in for long war

July 20, 2017

Google and the EU are gearing up for a battle that could last years, with the Silicon Valley behemoth facing a relentless challenge to its ambition to expand beyond search results.

Strengthening 3-D printed parts for real-world use

July 20, 2017

From aerospace and defense to digital dentistry and medical devices, 3-D printed parts are used in a variety of industries. Currently, 3-D printed parts are very fragile and only used in the prototyping phase of materials ...

Swimming robot probes Fukushima reactor to find melted fuel

July 19, 2017

An underwater robot entered a badly damaged reactor at Japan's crippled Fukushima nuclear plant Wednesday, capturing images of the harsh impact of its meltdown, including key structures that were torn and knocked out of place.

0 comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.