New dietary guidelines must be sustainable, regardless of politics

Credit: Maliz Ong

The new iteration of the Dietary Guidelines for Americans (DGA) must incorporate sustainability considerations - both for the health and wellbeing of Americans and the world in which we live, urges a new piece appearing in Science Express on Oct. 1.

Co-authored by public health and experts at George Washington (GW) and Tufts universities, the article publishes just days before the U.S. House Agriculture Committee will meet with Department of Agriculture Secretary Tom Vilsack and Secretary of Health and Human Services Sylvia Burwell to discuss the process for developing the DGA. Committee Chairman K. Michael Conaway, R-Texas, believes the sustainability recommendations from an advisory committee to the DGA "greatly exceeded" the group's scope by commenting on "wider policy issues." The authors disagree, saying nothing in the 1990 DGA statute prevents inclusion of sustainability.

"We believe the issue of scope is not the overarching concern, but a political maneuver to excise sustainability from dietary discussions," they write.

Incorporating sustainability in the DGA has become political for a number of reasons, according to the authors:

  • Industry leaders feel under attack and believe sustainability evaluations may lead to future regulation.
  • Sustainability has the potential to change the current food-group guidance (e.g., fruit, vegetables, protein) to one that focuses on specific foods in food groups (e.g., chicken vs. beef vs. fish).
  • New political coalitions may form that further tip the balance in favor of sustainability, particularly when drafting future dietary guidelines.
  • Sustainability considerations may sanction and elevate the importance of sustainable diets, opening the government up to greater demands for sustainability investments and telling consumers that such foods are preferred.

If included, the impact of changes to the DGA would be far-reaching: Nutrition professionals rely on its guidance and it informs meal content for the military, 8.6 million Women, Infants and Children program participants and 31 million children served through the National School Lunch Program.

Explore further

Guide for healthy eating may consider environment

More information: Designing the sustainable plate, … 1126/science.aab2031
Journal information: Science Express

Citation: New dietary guidelines must be sustainable, regardless of politics (2015, October 1) retrieved 21 April 2019 from
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

Feedback to editors

User comments

Oct 01, 2015
Dietary recommendations from the U.S. government have been wrong many times and over a period of many years. From the 1950's until very recently, the U.S. government recommended substituting trans fat for healthy butter. We were encouraged to consume corn syrup. The healthy consumption of eggs was discouraged.

Now we are going to be besieged with demands from the vegetarian PC crowd that we need to stop consuming animal protein because it consumes too many resources to raise animals versus consuming grains directly.

The very best advice is to simply ignore the U.S. government when it makes dietary advice.

Oct 01, 2015
Humans survived for millions of years with NO govt dietary guidelines.

Dietary guidelines were used to promote all the foods the US govt had to buy on its subsidy programs or were protecting for US farmers.
When coconut oil was in short supply because of the Japanese invasion of SE Asia, the US govt promoted soybean oils and transfat oleomargarine.
And then we discover pork lard and coconut oil and butter are good for humans and the govt promoted trans fats are not.
Anyone who trusts the govt to tell them what to eat deserves their health.

Oct 19, 2015
And everyone knows how much all the little kiddies are loving noted dietary expert Michelle O's yummy arugula-centered school cuisine. Only 60% of the kids stopped eating in the cafeteria, there's a growing black market in potato chips in grades 2-12, and the schools limited their food wasted to several billion dollars a week.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more