To be fragrant or not: Why do some male hairstreak butterflies lack scent organs?

To be fragrant or not: Why do some male hairstreak butterflies lack scent organs?
A male butterfly from the newly discovered Thereus lomalarga species was reared in Colombia. Credit: Dr. Robert Robbins & Maria Dolores Heredia

Female butterflies generally choose among male suitors, but in the tropics with hundreds of close relatives living in close proximity, how can they decide which males are the right ones? After all, if she mates with a male of another species, she is unlikely to have surviving offspring. One solution is that males of some species have scent producing organs on their wings, so if a male has the right smell, the female will presumably be receptive to his advances. Strangely, males of some species lack these scent producing organs, which would seem to be a huge disadvantage.

Biologists have theorized that when a species loses a male scent producing organ during evolution, its closest relatives do not occur in the same places. In other words, the female does not have to choose among males of the most closely related species, and the males do not devote energy to producing scents.

A team of researchers, led by Dr. Robert Robbins from the Smithsonian Institution, digs into this question in a small group of Latin American in a study published in the open access journal ZooKeys. Two newly discovered representatives in this butterfly group possess scent pads while their closest relatives do not. The researchers report that scent pads were lost evolutionarily twice in this group, and as predicted, in each case, the species without the scent pad does not co-occur with its closest relative. The present study adds more evidence to accumulating support for the explanation why some lack scent pads.

Evolutionary losses, such as the one observed herein in Thereus oppia and related butterflies, are quite common, as Dr. Robbins and collaborators have observed in a previous research. Such disappearances of male secondary sexual features have been explained by geographic isolation of a from its closest relatives, and the butterflies in this study are no exception.

  • To be fragrant or not: Why do some male hairstreak butterflies lack scent organs?
    A male butterfly, Thereus lomalarga, shows a scent pad, located on the dorsal forewing. Credit: Dr. Robert Robbins & Maria Dolores Heredia
  • To be fragrant or not: Why do some male hairstreak butterflies lack scent organs?
    Natural succession forest in Loma Larga, the type locality of T. lomalarga. Credit: Dr. Robert Robbins & Maria Dolores Heredia

Explore further

Male flour beetles increase their courtship effort and their sperm count if a female smells of other males

More information: Robbins RK, Heredia AD, Busby RC (2015) Male secondary sexual structures and the systematics of the Thereus oppia species group (Lepidoptera, Lycaenidae, Eumaeini). ZooKeys 520: 109-130. DOI: 10.3897/zookeys.520.10134
Journal information: ZooKeys

Provided by Pensoft Publishers
Citation: To be fragrant or not: Why do some male hairstreak butterflies lack scent organs? (2015, September 16) retrieved 20 April 2019 from https://phys.org/news/2015-09-fragrant-male-hairstreak-butterflies-lack.html
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.
17 shares

Feedback to editors

User comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more