New research shows why cats are more independent than dogs

September 3, 2015 by Elizabeth Allen, University of Lincoln
Ginger tabby cat. Credit: Public domain

Domestic cats do not generally see their owners as a focus of safety and security in the same way that dogs do, according to new research published today.

The study by animal behavior specialists at the University of Lincoln, UK, shows that while dogs perceive their owners as a safe base, the relationship between people and their feline friends appears to be quite different.

While it is increasingly recognized that are more social and more capable of shared relationships than traditionally thought, this latest research shows that adult cats appear to be more autonomous – even in their social relationships – and not necessarily dependent on others to provide a sense of protection.

The research, published in the scientific journal PLOS ONE, was led by Professor Daniel Mills, Professor of Veterinary Behavioural Medicine at the University of Lincoln's School of Life Sciences, along with Alice Potter – who studied as a postgraduate at Lincoln and now works with the Companion Animals Science Group at the RSPCA.

Professor Mills said: "The domestic cat has recently passed the dog as the most popular companion animal in Europe, with many seeing a cat as an ideal pet for owners who work long hours. Previous research has suggested that some cats show signs of separation anxiety when left alone by their owners, in the same way that dogs do, but the results of our study show that they are in fact much more independent than canine companions. It seems that what we interpret as might actually be signs of frustration."

The Lincoln researchers carefully adapted the Ainsworth Strange Situation Test (SST), which has been widely used to demonstrate that the bond between young children or with their primary carer can be categorised as a 'secure attachment' – where the carer is seen as a focus of safety and security in potentially threatening (or unfamiliar) environments.

The study observed the relationships between a number of cats and their owners, placing the pets in an unfamiliar environment together with their owner, with a stranger and also on their own. In varying scenarios, it assessed three different characteristics of attachment; the amount of contact sought by the cat, the level of passive behaviour, and signs of distress caused by the absence of the owner.

"Although our cats were more vocal when the owner rather than the stranger left them with the other individual, we didn't see any additional evidence to suggest that the bond between a cat and its owner is one of secure attachment. This vocalisation might simply be a sign of frustration or learned response, since no other signs of attachment were reliably seen. In strange situations, attached individuals seek to stay close to their carer, show signs of distress when they are separated and demonstrate pleasure when their attachment figure returns, but these trends weren't apparent during our research," said Professor Mills.

"For pet dogs, their owners often represent a specific safe haven; however it is clear that are much more autonomous when it comes to coping with unusual situations. Our findings don't disagree with the notion that cats develop social preferences or close relationships, but they do show that these relationships do not appear to be typically based on a need for safety and security. As far as we could tell, the cats of owners who considered them to be highly attached did not differ from the others in this regard."

The results of the study reveal that while cats might prefer to interact with their owner, they do not rely on them for reassurance when in an unfamiliar environment, and the researchers believe this is because of the nature of the species as a largely independent and solitary hunter.

Explore further: Study finds pet owners reluctant to face up to their cats' kill count

More information: "Domestic Cats (Felis silvestris catus) Do Not Show Signs of Secure Attachment to Their Owners." PLoS ONE 10(9): e0135109. DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0135109

Related Stories

Stress in pet cats—how it manifests and how to manage it

June 22, 2015

A variety of day-to-day events - from conflicts with other cats to changes in their daily routine - can cause cats to become stressed. This can trigger a number of behavioural changes and be detrimental to their welfare.

Test may help decrease yearly pet vaccines

August 13, 2015

Scientists at Kansas State University's Veterinary Diagnostic Laboratory have modified a test that measures an animal's immune response to the rabies virus, a change that will cost pet owners less money and may help reduce ...

Stroking could stress out your cat

October 7, 2013

A new study by an international team of animal behaviour specialists suggests that cats who reluctantly allow their owners to stroke them could be more stressed out than moggies who carefully avoid being petted.

Helicopter parenting better for pets than for kids

January 14, 2015

Helicopter parenting may not be the best strategy for raising independent kids. But a healthy measure of clinginess and overprotectiveness could actually be advantageous when rearing dogs and cats, according to new research ...

Recommended for you

Revealing the mysteries of early development

May 23, 2018

Zebrafish embryos are transparent and develop outside the mother's body, enabling scientists to get a detailed view of early development. A research team led by Lila Solnica-Krezel, the Alan A. and Edith L. Wolff Distinguished ...

Study bolsters bats' reputation as mosquito devourers

May 23, 2018

It's a common assumption: Bats are important because they feast upon those pervasive warm-weather pests known as mosquitoes. You want to see bats flying above, cleaning up the night sky and ridding you of itchy bites and ...

Why birds don't have teeth

May 23, 2018

Why did birds lose their teeth? Was it so they would be lighter in the air? Or are pointy beaks better for worm-eating than the jagged jaws of dinosaur ancestors?

'Virtual safe space' to help bumblebees

May 22, 2018

The many threats facing bumblebees can be tested using a "virtual safe space" created by scientists at the University of Exeter. Bumble-BEEHAVE provides a computer simulation of how colonies will develop and react to multiple ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

1 / 5 (3) Sep 03, 2015
It's really simple, when you get to the overarching factor that is seemingly ignored. Cats can crap in the house, so they can crap at will.

Dogs cannot. Small children have the same issue as the dog. A feeling of independence, cannot arrive for either the dog or the small child, and the reminders of that, the reinforcement of that, happens multiple times a day. To the point that the arc of a day happens around those considerations.
3.4 / 5 (5) Sep 03, 2015
So let's breed cats with the same loyalty as dogs. And make them the size of great danes.
Sep 03, 2015
This comment has been removed by a moderator.
3 / 5 (2) Sep 03, 2015
Why wouldn't a cat show separation anxiety? I babysat a cockatiel for a week once and you never saw a happier bird when the owner came back.
3 / 5 (4) Sep 03, 2015
Canine intelligence resides in the pack. Feline intelligence resides in the individual. You can't directly compare the personalities.
3 / 5 (2) Sep 03, 2015
Canine intelligence resides in the pack. Feline intelligence resides in the individual. You can't directly compare the personalities
Both canids and felids can express either behavior.

"A pride of lions consists of related females and offspring and a small number of adult males. Groups of female lions typically hunt together, preying mostly on large ungulates."

"Most canids are solitary animals, hunting alone; however, there are four species, the Wolf, African hunting dog, Asian dhole, and the bush dog, that form packs."

-The trick in producing effective watchcats is in eliciting the right behavior either through breeding or engineering.
4 / 5 (1) Sep 03, 2015
This is like comparing apples to oranges.. or introverts to extroverts. Making conclusions about cats because cats don't act like dogs is inane.

Domestic cats are NOT little dogs.. nor are they lions, nor are domestic dogs lone hunters.. you can't make comparisons on what they COULD be if you 'bread them right' .

I thought this was a place for science, not this drivel..
not rated yet Sep 05, 2015
Given the basis of small cats' social group is the 'nest', from which individuals range variously, having a couple of nest-members go off 'on patrol' is normal. If an individual breaks their pattern and stays out late, that's their call. Takes a day or two before the rest of the clan need be concerned...

Article does skim over degrees of relationship. Cats, like people, may have 'close friends', whose absence is sorely missed...

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.