Later supper for blackbirds in the city: Artificial light gives birds longer to forage for food
Artificial light increases foraging time in blackbirds. Birds in city centres are active not just considerably earlier, but also for longer than their relatives in darker parts of the city. That is the result of a study of around 200 blackbirds in Leipzig, which was carried out in the framework of the "Loss of the Night" research project. The study showed that artificial light has a considerable influence on the activity times of blackbirds in the city and therefore on their natural cycles, according to scientists of the Helmholtz Centre for Envi-ronmental Research (UFZ) and the Leipzig University, published in the special-ist periodical Journal of Ornithology.
One year ago, the scientists were able to demonstrate that street noise and artificial light affect birds in the city centre of Leipzig to become active up to five hours earlier in the morning than their conspecifics in quieter, unlit parts of the city of Leipzig. The scientists chose the blackbird (Turdus merula) because this species of bird was originally a forest dweller, but has adjusted well to conditions in the city since the early 19th century. Since then, it has become widespread in cities and easily identifiable through its distinctive song. In the years 2011 to 2013, over 200 blackbirds were caught in an area in Leipzig covering 215 hectares, with the permission of the authorities. The research area covered a 3 km-long gradient oriented towards the South West, from the city centre, through the Clara Zetkin Park and to the seminatural remains of a floodplain forest called Leipziger Auwald. Due to the street lighting, it is considerably lighter in the green areas within the inner-city ring-road than in the Auwald.
Caught birds were measured, individually ringed and released. On 35 days between March and July, some of them were specifically observed during their foraging activities. "On the short days in March, the blackbirds in the forest stopped foraging almost one hour before their counterparts in the well-lit city. The longer the days grew, the smaller the difference became. In the summer, there were just a few minutes' difference between city and forest birds," says Anja Ruß of UFZ.
The observations showed that in the illuminated city centre, the males are considerably more likely to be last to leave the foraging grounds, whilst there was no deviation from the general gender ratio in the forest. The researchers attributed this to the differing sensitivity to light of each sex. It is known that male blackbirds tend to be slightly larger than females. This is also true of their eyes. "Larger eyes lead to better vision in poor light conditions. This makes it easier for males to forage for food in the twilight than females. The artificial light in the city exacerbates this difference between the sexes even further, meaning that the males can remain active for longer in the evenings", Dr Reinhard Klenke of UFZ explains.
The study underlines the fact that artificial light at night has a major part to play in the biorhythms of city blackbirds. It allows the birds to extend their daily activities. This effect, however, decreases with the lengthening of the days in summer. Contrary to earlier assumptions, city blackbirds do not appear to benefit physically from the artificial light and the extra time; the scientists were unable to establish a significant difference in physical conditions between the two groups during the period of extended foraging time. They therefore assume that as well as light, the availability and quality of food and the risk of being eaten are also important factors.
Whilst pollution of air, noise and water have been anchored in the minds of the public for a long time and have been scientifically researched to a corresponding extent, awareness of the problem of the loss of the natural darkness of the night due to artificial light and the far-reaching changes in natural processes is coming to the fore much more slowly. This is relevant not only for the natural ecosystems but is already affecting the human society considerably. Over the last three years, the interdisciplinary research project "Loss of the Night", led by the Leibniz Institute of Freshwater Ecology and Inland Fisheries (IGB), has carried out pioneering research. In the sub-project "BILL" (Birds in ILluminated Landscapes), a working group led by Dr Reinhard Klenke of UFZ was focusing on comparative studies of different influences of artificial light on bird populations. "There have already been several studies on the effects of light or noise on birds. For the first time, however, our study has analysed the complex interplay in the combination of the two factors, which create stress not only for us humans, but also for the animals of the city", the biologist emphasised. He was behind the original idea for the study and hopes to continue to study the effects on bird fitness.
Light does not just influence biorhythm of organisms in the city. Even in many conservation areas, the sky has become considerably lighter than originally at night, due to neighbouring cities. Human population growth and growing urbanisation will exacerbate this problem in many regions of the world. On top of this come technological trends, such as the increasing use of LED lights with spectra partly different from those of natural light, or the increasing use of light as a design element in the cityscape. This makes it all the more important for research to be carried out into the knock-on effects of these developments on humans and animals.
Ommo Hüppop, Reinhard Klenke and Anja Nordt: Vögel und künstliches Licht , in: Thomas Posch, Franz Hölker, Thomas Uhlmann, Anja Freyhoff (Hrsg.): Das Ende der Nacht. Lichtsmog: Gefahren – Perspektiven – Lösungen. Second edition, revised and expanded, September 2013. 232 pages, 50 colour illustrations, hard cover, WILEY-VCH, Weinheim, ISBN 978-3-527-41179-5 www.wiley-vch.de/publish/dt/bo … rjjcvm4mqtbr07l10175
Nordt A, Klenke R (2013) Sleepless in Town – Drivers of the Temporal Shift in Dawn Song in Urban European Blackbirds. PLOS ONE 8(8): e71476. dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0071476