# Professor quantifies how 'one thing leads to another'

##### August 15, 2014 by Anne Ju, Cornell University

(Phys.org) —"One thing led to another," people often say. Events, discoveries and relationships are triggered by something previous. The iPhone case was designed only because the iPhone was invented first. A song became popular only after someone liked it.

Mathematicians always want to quantify things, and Steven Strogatz, Cornell's Jacob Gould Schurman Professor of Applied Mathematics, is trying to quantify the commonsense concept of "correlated novelties" – that one new thing sometimes (but not always) triggers another. He and three researchers from Italy's Sapienza University, where he spent three months on sabbatical leave, published a paper in Scientific Reports July 31 on their first crack at it.

"This concept of correlated novelties had only been phrased in verbal or conceptual terms," Strogatz said. "It seemed like a really intriguing idea, with room for creativity to make it testable."

Correlated novelties are everywhere: in economics, or perhaps most obviously, in , where traits evolve over time from a cascade of tiny events.

In this era of big data and supercomputing, going back to find patterns in outcomes is easier than ever. Strogatz and his colleagues used four data sets as test cases, each consisting of a sequence of elements ordered in time: texts, where the elements are words, and the novelty occurs when a word appears for the first time; online music, where the novelty is the first time a listener hears a song or artist; Wikipedia, where novelties are the first edit of a given wikipage; and social annotation in tagging sites, where novelties are the introduction of a new tag.

The researchers quantified the rate at which novelties occurred by focusing on the growth of distinct elements in an ordered sequence. They discovered that the rate at which novelties occur decreases over time.

They proposed a simple mathematical model that mimics the process of exploring a physical, biological or conceptual space that enlarges whenever a novelty occurs, according to the paper. The model is based on Polya's Urn, familiar to mathematicians. An urn filled with black and white balls churn like lottery balls; whenever one color is picked, more of the same color are added back. That enhances the likelihood of that original color being picked at the next turn.

The concept has an echo of the familiar, Strogatz says. For example, the urn could be considered a simplification of the "rich get richer" concept – that socioeconomic stratification isn't random, but strongly correlated with previous events.

Such insights hint at the possibility of a sophisticated building on the one proposed to address an endless list of human problems in economics, biology and epidemiology, to name a few. For example, applying the model to 100 years of influenza data, epidemiologists could perhaps learn to predict how the flu will spread going forward, Strogatz said.

Explore further: UMSL scholar examines evolution of learning

## Related Stories

#### UMSL scholar examines evolution of learning

August 14, 2014

Why do monkeys learn to be afraid of snakes and not flowers? Is this knowledge the result of evolution by natural selection? Did the monkeys that couldn't learn that association quickly die and not reproduce?

#### New model shows how often to review material for flashcard programs

January 26, 2012

(PhysOrg.com) -- A challenge for students and teachers -- and today, for designers of educational software: How often should material be reviewed for best learning? Wait too long to review and it fades away; review too soon ...

#### Going batty for jumping DNA as a cause of species diversity

April 1, 2014

The vesper bats are the largest and best-known common family of bats, with more than 400 species spread across the globe, ranking second among mammals in species diversity.

#### Researchers propose a better way to make sense of 'Big Data'

February 18, 2014

Big Data is everywhere, and we are constantly told that it holds the answers to almost any problem we want to solve. Companies collect information on how we shop, doctors and insurance companies gather our medical test results, ...

#### Mathematical model shows how groups split into factions

January 4, 2011

(PhysOrg.com) -- The school dance committee is split; one group wants an "Alice in Wonderland" theme; the other insists on "Vampire Jamboree." Mathematics could have predicted it.

#### A vexing math problem finds an elegant solution

November 14, 2013

(Phys.org) —A famous math problem that has vexed mathematicians for decades has met an elegant solution by Cornell researchers. Graduate student Yash Lodha, working with Justin Moore, professor of mathematics, has described ...

## Recommended for you

#### A call to add a well-being index to national economic measures

October 19, 2018

A trio of economists is suggesting that it is time to add a well-being index to national economic measures. Carol Graham with the Brookings Institution, Kate Laffan with the London School of Economics and Sergio Pinto with ...

#### Study shows gender preferences differ more in countries that are more affluent and gender equal

October 19, 2018

A pair of researchers, one with the University of Bonn, the other the University of California, has found evidence that shows gender preferences differ more in countries that are more affluent and gender equal than in countries ...

#### Method predicts reliable patterns in violent events occurring within wars and terrorism

October 18, 2018

A new paper written by academics at Royal Holloway and George Washington University, predicts reliable patterns in violent events occurring within wars and terrorism, regardless of geography, ethnicity and religion.

#### University choice and achievement partly down to DNA

October 18, 2018

Research from King's College London has shown for the first time that genetics plays a significant role in whether young adults choose to go to university, which university they choose to attend and how well they do.

#### Extinction is forever—and ecosystem recovery takes a really, really long time

October 17, 2018

Researchers from the University of Leeds studying fossil data surrounding the Permo-Triassic (P-Tr) extinction of 252 million years (Ma) ago found that a marine ecosystem, in comparison with the taxonomic genera that comprise ...

#### New Pompeii evidence rewrites Vesuvius eruption history

October 16, 2018

A newly-discovered inscription at Pompeii proves the city was destroyed by Mount Vesuvius after October 17, 79 AD and not on August 24 as previously thought, archeologists said Tuesday.