You can't write a CV on a smartphone – digital literacy is no help to unemployed youth

August 21, 2014 by Helen Thornham, The Conversation
How do I do a bullet point on this? Credit: Shutterstock

Concerns have been raised for some time about the UK government's "digital by default" approach to welfare reforms. More and more public services are being shifted online and many fear that this will marginalise people who are not computer literate.

But our research demonstrates that even the so-called digital generation – young people who seem to spend half their life online – are struggling just as much. They may be incredibly digitally literate in terms of , and ; they may be highly discerning about the apps they use, but their digital culture is no help when they try to find a job.

It is becoming clear that more and more people are being affected by welfare reforms. In a survey conducted by Advice Leeds in 2013, for example, 68% of respondents said the reforms had affected their ability to meet living costs or pay bills; 50% said their ability to pay for food was affected, and 44% said fuel costs had been affected.

For our research, we spent time in Leeds with young NEETS – the term used to refer to people who are not in education, employment or training. We were involved in two ethnographic projects with community arts organisations and young people on benefits, and we have been interviewing charities and public sector organisations who help them.

It became clear that for these 17 to 25-year-olds, adult life has been an experience entirely characterised by careful budgeting, little money, bridging loans and constant rationalisations around spending. Funding for projects that seek to help NEETS is also increasingly scarce and the demographics affected by unemployment are increasingly diverse. It is not the case that those on allowance are the perpetually unemployed. It is not the case that all those on job seekers allowance are content, unwilling to work or uneducated.

One of the most frustrating aspects of the digital-by-default philosophy is experienced daily by young people seeking work. People looking for a job are now expected to devote up to five hours a day to the task and apply for between 10 and 15 jobs a week. If they fail to meet certain quotas, a jobseeker might have their benefits stopped. Many of the people we spoke to had seen their benefits stopped, usually for between three and six months but sometimes for up to a year.

But job searching and submitting an application are both now very much online activities. That means people who are out of work and often out of money need to somehow find a way to spend large portions of their day if they want to break the cycle.

The young people we worked with told us that their homes don't have broadband for a variety of reasons. Some families simply can't afford it, while others don't have a credit rating and some saw arguments break out over who pays the bill when they did get connected. If tenants move around a lot, it's also difficult to keep a contract with an internet service provider.

In Leeds, libraries often only allow visitors to spend between 15 minutes and an hour using their internet services – and the same is probably true in other areas. Even under these rules, they are struggling to cope with demand.

At the same time, the smartphone is the tool most young people use when they access digital welfare services. But while smartphones are already the device of choice for so many young people, they are by no means ideal for writing a CV or applying for a job. Aside from basic formatting issues, these activities require a very different kind of literacy.

The young people were incredibly digitally literate when it came to tariffs and consumer rights. They knew exactly which tariff was best at any particular time across service providers, for example. But their credit for making actual phone calls often fluctuated or was non-existent. This made it difficult to keep in touch with social or youth workers and especially to have sustained conversations with them.

It is clear from working with these young people that even while smartphones are compulsively taken in and out of pockets, checked, and engaged with, they are inadequate devices for what is required by the welfare system.

Young people appear to have a vast knowledge of digital technologies and in some cases far outstrips that of adults. But this knowledge and literacy does not empower them when faced with a job search or application, a court order or email exchange with a social or youth worker. These are, clearly, digital by default, but their digital literacy is also – like the phones they use – often smashed or broken.

Explore further: New generation is happy for employers to monitor them on social media

Related Stories

Young people face double penalty in a slow job market

February 29, 2012

The latest official unemployment figures show that unemployment among young people has soared to 22.3 per cent, higher than the recession of the 1990s, while the overall unemployment rate is nine per cent. New research from ...

Recommended for you

Unprecedented study of Picasso's bronzes uncovers new details

February 17, 2018

Musee national Picasso-Paris and the Northwestern University/Art Institute of Chicago Center for Scientific Studies in the Arts (NU-ACCESS) have completed the first major material survey and study of the Musee national Picasso-Paris' ...

Using Twitter to discover how language changes

February 16, 2018

Scientists at Royal Holloway, University of London, have studied more than 200 million Twitter messages to try and unravel the mystery of how language evolves and spreads.


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

5 / 5 (1) Aug 21, 2014
But while smartphones are already the device of choice for so many young people, they are by no means ideal for writing a CV or applying for a job. Aside from basic formatting issues, these activities require a very different kind of literacy.

If you have a smartphone with 3G internet connection, you technically have a broadband connection for your computer.

I have in the past used a regular candy bar phone with EDGE instead of 3G for internet by simply tethering it to a laptop over bluetooth and then opening it up as a data modem. It's basically a point & click deal unless you have some super locked down apple phone or something stupid like that. You don't need to be any sort of super linux nerd to do it.

It may not be fast, but you can certainly write and upload a CV without any issues.

The biggest issue here is indeed that the people don't know anything about computers, phones, or the internet. They're simply throwing money at them and using them for toys.
5 / 5 (1) Aug 21, 2014
It's a bit depressing to notice that people are so ignorant about the technology they're using that you are often considered a "hacker" when you use your devices in a way they were designed to work.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.