Molecular mirror images assigned: Safer drugs thanks to a new solution to a 150-year-old chemistry problem?

September 13, 2013
The big balls show the structure of the molecule, the small ones show the measured fragmentations after explosion. The path of these small particles is determined by the molecular structure. Credit: Goethe University Frankfurt

Just like gloves, molecules come in so-called left-handed and right-handed versions. Until now, however, it could be determined only with great difficulty whether a certain molecule is right-handed or left-handed. In medicine, this would be a big step forward because, for example, the unwanted side effects of drugs could be avoided. In the current issue of the journal Science, a team of researchers from Germany, Canada and Switzerland reports a new solution to a 150-year old problem.

The phenomenon of molecules with handedness is well known in yogurt: the produce levo- or dextrorotatory lactic acid; of these two types, one form has a more favorable influence on than the other. In other substances, the second version is less harmless and causes damage: for example, while one form of penicillamine is effective against arthritis, its is more toxic.

"Enlargement" due to explosion

But how can we determine whether molecules are right- or left-handed? Until now, it was possible to directly determine handedness only in solid, crystalline substances using a special process in which the was analyzed using X-rays. "The problem with this method is that it is not easy to crystallize every substance or to simply incorporate it into a suitable crystal. Therefore, we investigated a method in which the handedness can be determined directly in the " explains Prof. Robert Berger of the Clemens-Schöpf Institute at TU Darmstadt.

A laser beam makes the molecule burst, the positively charged particles created by the laser are guided in direction of a particle detector (blue board) on the left side. A computer records the points of their position of impact and starts the back tracing of the molecular structure. Credit: Goethe University Frankfurt

It is based on "enlargement" due to explosion. Imagine inflating a rubber glove until it bursts. If you follow the trajectory of each finger in the opposite direction, you obtain the original glove and can see whether it is a right or left glove. The researchers proceeded in a similar way for the molecules that they studied.

Their test subject was bromochlorofluoromethane, an easily evaporable liquid carbon compound with four different bonding partners. The molecule has the shape of a tetrahedron, with carbon in the middle and hydrogen, bromine, chlorine and fluorine at the corners. The handedness results from the distribution of the bonding partners on the four corners.

To determine this, an intense laser beam is used to remove one type of electron from all the atoms at once. The molecule, which now has five positive charges, explodes due to the high repulsion between the positively charged modules. The particles then collide with a detector that determines the duration of the flight and the location of the impact, thus allowing the flight path to be established. From this, the spatial arrangement of the atoms in the molecule before the explosion can be reconstructed.

A variety of applications

"This method opens new perspectives for the investigation and analysis of handed molecules in physics, chemistry and pharmaceutics" predicts Dr. Markus Schöffler of the Institute of Nuclear Physics at Goethe University. For example, drugs could be produced in which only the molecules of the desired handedness are present. As a result, the dosage could be reduced. But other industries would also benefit: in carvone, a component of essential oils, for example, the handedness determines whether it smells like spearmint or caraway. In other substances, the flavor changes from bitter to sweet, for instance.

"However, being able to work only with the desired molecular type is a long-term goal" Berger points out. "We now have for the time being proved, for the textbook example of a handed substance, that direct assignment in the gas phase is possible."

Explore further: Genes linked to being right- or left-handed identified

More information: Pitzer, M. et al. Direct Determination of Absolute Molecular Stereochemistry in Gas Phase by Coulomb Explosion Imaging, Science, 2013. DOI: 10.1126/science.1240362

Related Stories

Unique method creates correct mirror image of molecule

May 22, 2013

Many molecules have a right and a left form, just like shoes. In pharmaceuticals, it is important that the correct form of the molecule is used. Researchers at the University of Gothenburg, Sweden, have been able to produce ...

Recommended for you

Slippery liquid surfaces confuse mussels

August 17, 2017

It all began with a bet at a conference in Italy in 2013. Nicolas Vogel, Ph.D., then a postdoctoral fellow in Joanna Aizenberg's lab at the Wyss Institute for Biologically Inspired Engineering at Harvard University and Harvard's ...

Researchers find a way to combat pharmacoterrorism

August 17, 2017

Using a novel molecular analysis technique, scientists at The Scripps Research Institute (TSRI) have identified the chemical underpinnings of Captagon, also known as fenethylline, an illegal amphetamine-type stimulant that ...

1 comment

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

1 / 5 (7) Sep 14, 2013
I would call this method the "Mythbusters Method" as it consists in blowing up stuff ;)

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.