Fake online reviews get reality check

September 29, 2013 by Rob Lever
A person holding a credit card and a phone with a sales 'app', in front of websites advertsing for winter sales, on January 9, 2013, in Paris

Fake online products reviews have been around for years, fueled by unscrupulous marketers seeking to boost sales.

But a recent by authorities in New York could be the shock needed for the online sector to clean up its act.

The New York state attorney general's office recently ordered 19 companies to halt these practices and pay fines totaling $350,000 to settle charges of manipulating online for sites such as Yelp, Google+ and others.

The settlement stemmed from an undercover investigation in which officials created a fake yogurt shop in Brooklyn and sought help in marketing from so-called "" firms that work to boost a company's online presence.

The investigators discovered online ads such as this one: "Hello... We need someone to post 1-2 reviews daily on sites like: Yelp, Google reviews, Citysearch and any other similar sites. We will supply the text/review... We are offering $1.00 dollar for every post."

The companies hired writers from as far away as the Philippines, Bangladesh and Eastern Europe, according to the .

"Consumers rely on reviews from their peers to make daily purchasing decisions on anything from food and clothing to recreation and sightseeing," state Attorney General Eric Schneiderman said.

"This investigation into large-scale, intentional across the Internet tells us that we should approach online reviews with caution. "

Growth in fake reviews

While the extent of fake reviews is not clear, a 2012 report by the research firm Gartner concluded that between two and six percent of online reviews are "fake or deceptive," and predicted this will grow to around 10 percent by 2014.

The prevalence of fake reviews is due to the high stakes involved.

The Gartner report said some 31 percent of consumers use online review because they find the opinions of a person like themselves to be more credible than advertising.

Gartner said studies from a number of university researchers suggest that positive reviews can provide a shot in the arm for many kinds of businesses, from hotels to restaurants to doctors or lawyers.

"In the hospitality industry, you are more likely to see bookings go up when you have better ratings," said Jenny Sussin, a Gartner analyst and co-author of the report.

"For restaurants, a half-star increase in the review average can cause 7:00 pm bookings to go up 30 to 49 percent."

Sussin said fake reviews can be used by small family operations to Fortune 500 companies. In addition to positive reviews, some fakes are negatives, often aimed at driving business to a competitor.

She said the review business has turned into a cottage industry, with writers in places such as India or the Philippines paid as little as $1 to $5 per review. In other cases, some employees or customers are offered incentives such as gift certificates for reviews, which is also considered deceptive or illegal.

Duncan Simester of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology and Eric Anderson of Northwestern University found that five percent of reviews for a major apparel maker came from people with no record of purchasing that product.

These questionable reviews were "significantly more negative" than the average, the researchers found, but the motivations were not clear.

"These deceptive reviews are written by loyal customers," they wrote in a research paper submitted to an academic journal.

"One explanation for the data is that loyal customers may be acting as self-appointed brand managers... An alternative explanation is that the deceptive reviews are contributed by reviewers who seek to enhance their perceived social status."

Yelp said recently its automatic filtering rejects about 25 percent of submitted reviews: "Yelp has been on guard against these very same reviews from our earliest days," a blog post said.

The US Federal Trade Commission has also issued fines in such cases, based on its guidance that any payment for reviews or testimonials must be disclosed.

But Sussin said the New York case "is the biggest enforcement action we've seen" for this type of activity in the United States, and added that "this might deter people."

Ending anonymity can 'kill some of the truth'

Google recently stopped allowing anonymous reviews, in part due to concerns about fakery.

But Dartmouth University marketing professor Yaniv Dover said there is a downside to ending anonymity, arguing that people may take fewer risks when their identities are known.

"When you kill anonymity and force these social dynamics, you kill some of the truth," Dover said.

"People tend to be more positive (if they are not anonymous). They don't want to be perceived by their friends as negative."

While fake reviews are not always easy to spot, there are warning signs.

Sussin says that for hotels and restaurants, a lack of detail about the location could be a sign for caution.

A reviewer who comments on multiple, unrelated products or services can also be suspicious. Excessive use of superlatives can also be a sign of faking, Gartner said.

Websites often raise flags when they get large numbers of reviews at one time, or if one IP address is tied to multiple reviews in a short time period.

Despite the apparently large numbers of fake reviews, most researchers say the system still works fairly well.

"The faking may be significant, but there are also market correction mechanisms," Dover said.

"Review systems are basically are a good thing. Any user-generated content can better match producers and consumers."

Explore further: NY seeks to delete phony online reviews

Related Stories

Small businesses grapple with handling online image

August 15, 2013

Restaurants, mom-and-pop shops and other small businesses often face an abundance of frustrating complications during start-up - construction delays and supply shortages being among the top obstacles.

Bed bugs, bad service begone, thanks to online reviews

August 2, 2013

Bed bugs, bad service and terrible food used to be inevitable risks when traveling, but a host of online review sites such as Yelp and TripAdvisor are helping savvy consumers pick the best hotels and eat like locals.

Recommended for you

What do you get when you cross an airplane with a submarine?

February 15, 2018

Researchers from North Carolina State University have developed the first unmanned, fixed-wing aircraft that is capable of traveling both through the air and under the water – transitioning repeatedly between sky and sea. ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Sep 29, 2013
80% of good reviews are from people whose products haven't yet broken down prematurely.
1.4 / 5 (10) Sep 29, 2013
Maybe they can crack down on the climate change deniers on this site while they are at it...
5 / 5 (1) Sep 29, 2013
I you replace 'reviews' with 'votes' in the article then you'll find it's pretty spot on in describing a couple of people on this site. Interesting.
One explanation for the data is that loyal customers may be acting as self-appointed brand managers.

deceptive reviews are contributed by reviewers who seek to enhance their perceived social status

large numbers of reviews at one time,
1.8 / 5 (5) Sep 29, 2013
Dishonesty is a free, unregulated marketplace in action.

Corporate dishonesty is what Libertarians and Randites are in business to promote.

The Libertarian Product, is pure poison.
5 / 5 (2) Sep 29, 2013
I find online reviews helpful but you have to read a lot of them to get a real picture. Mostly I read the average to negative reviews and try to filter out the stupidity. reading the 5 star reviews is a waste of time after the first two.

2.1 / 5 (7) Sep 30, 2013
Maybe they can crack down on the climate change deniers on this site while they are at it...

I think a crack down on crackpots such as yourself is of more value
1 / 5 (8) Sep 30, 2013
Climate change deniers are pretty clearly the crackpots.
not rated yet Sep 30, 2013
I found this article informative and well written. I will shop here again and recommend this article to my friends.
It would be interesting to see the algorithm they use to detect false reviews.
2.3 / 5 (3) Oct 09, 2013

Zeph boyo, everyone should give ya BIG fiver for that one. Thanks boyo, I really mean it.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.