US visa day sparks new debate on tech workers

April 1, 2013 by Rob Lever
Silicon Valley's capital city San Jose, California, is seen pictured on October 2, 2007. As the US government opened up visa applications Monday for highly skilled immigrants, debate flared anew on the tech sector's demands to be able to hire more foreign workers.

As the US government opened up visa applications Monday for highly skilled immigrants, debate flared anew on the tech sector's demands to be able to hire more foreign workers.

The US has long complained of a shortage of with specialized skills, but the debate is further complicated this year by fresh attention to a broader immigration law aimed at bringing millions of undocumented migrants out of the shadows.

In what has become an annual rite for the tech sector, the US government opened applications for 65,000 spots for highly under the so-called H-1B visa program.

US Citizenship and Immigration Services said it expects to receive more requests than available visas by April 5, and if so will set up a lottery.

"It will be a frenzy, because the cap of 65,000 visas is nowhere near high enough to meet demand," said Robert Holleyman, head of BSA/The Software Alliance.

"If you didn't know better, you might think the H-1B petition-filing frenzy had something to do with April Fool's Day. But it's no joke."

Microsoft general counsel Brad Smith said the squeeze has led to "increased anxiety" at many companies since the visas for the next fiscal year are likely to be filled in the first week.

Smith said in a blog post that the situation highlights a shortage in "STEM talent"—people with degrees in science, technology, engineering and mathematics.

"The creates 120,000 new computer-related jobs annually that require a bachelor's degree, but we are currently producing about 51,000 graduates with a degree in computer science each year," he said.

"We have first-hand experience with the challenges. Currently, Microsoft has 3,400 high-paying, high-skilled job openings in core technology areas that we cannot fill."

But sentiment on the issue is far from universal. Some critics claim the visa program tamps down US wages, while others say the system is abused by companies that outsource jobs to countries like India.

According to the Institute of Electrical & Electronics Engineers, the top 10 users of H-1B visas in the past fiscal year were companies specializing in shipping American jobs offshore.

Vin O'Neill, a spokesman for the IEEE-USA, said there is a long history of companies using the H-1B visas for short-term jobs, only to later transfer those functions elsewhere, often to India's booming tech sector.

"If companies need workers, they should bring people in as legal permanent residents rather than (on) a semi-permanent basis," O'Neill said.

"As legal residents, the workers are able to quit and move around. Their spouses can work. There are a lot of advantages."

O'Neill said using H-1B visas depresses wages because the workers are at the mercy of the employer, unable to seek a new job unless they find a new sponsor.

Senator Chuck Grassley has introduced a measure that would tighten controls for the H-1B program.

"The program was never meant to replace qualified American workers, but it was instead intended as a means to fill gaps in highly specialized areas of employment," Grassley said in a statement.

Grassley's proposal would requires companies to make a good faith effort to hire Americans first, and would bar companies from outsourcing visa holders to other companies.

It is unclear how the broad immigration overhaul will fare in Congress, but many see a high-tech component in any reform package. Analysts say the momentum is positive now that Republicans are anxious to improve their image with Hispanic voters after last year's election loss.

Marshall Fitz, director of immigration policy at the Center for American Progress think tank, said he sees a "synergy" with the tech sector and backers of a more broad immigration bill.

"This is the best opportunity for the tech sector get their provisions addressed and I think they know that," Fitz said.

Explore further: Top 10 H-1B visa companies all specialize in shipping American jobs overseas

Related Stories

Microsoft suggests charging employers for extra worker visas

September 30, 2012

Faced with 6,000 job openings and a Congress unresponsive to admitting more skilled workers from overseas, Microsoft on Thursday offered what it hopes will be a twofer solution: charging employers hundreds of millions of ...

Senate Bill Gives U.S. Workers First Dibs on H-1B Jobs

April 7, 2007

One of the longest-running defenses of the hotly debated H-1B temporary worker visa program is that there are simply not enough U.S. workers to fill out many corporations' programming, engineering and back-office positions, ...

H-1B Scramble Hits Fever Pitch

April 1, 2007

The months leading up to the opening of the H-1B filing season has been more dramatic than ever this year, due in part to the speedy exhaustion of visa supply last year, setting a new record.

Recommended for you

Scientists solve mystery shrouding oldest animal fossils

March 25, 2019

Scientists from The Australian National University (ANU) have discovered that 558 million-year-old Dickinsonia fossils do not reveal all of the features of the earliest known animals, which potentially had mouths and guts.

Earth's deep mantle flows dynamically

March 25, 2019

As ancient ocean floors plunge over 1,000 km into the Earth's deep interior, they cause hot rock in the lower mantle to flow much more dynamically than previously thought, finds a new UCL-led study.


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Apr 01, 2013
Where else can companies get cheap, cheap labor that
undercuts the American workers pay scale.
not rated yet Apr 01, 2013
I think theres more to it than that, holoman. i wonder how us university grads compare with graduates elsewhere...
not rated yet Apr 02, 2013
Labor isnt cheap if they work in US.
Most US grads only want to do the "cool" stuff and have an entitlement attitude.
not rated yet Apr 02, 2013
Labor isnt cheap if they work in US.
Most US grads only want to do the "cool" stuff and have an entitlement attitude.

Don't blame the students.

Students in U.S. High Schools are not prepared, at all, for university level STEM classes.

Part of the problem is htey don't teach "skills" in High School. they teach the high notes of a topic and ignore it. Plus students spend about an hour or two every year learning the high notes of American or World History, which while history is important, it does absolutely nothing for 90% of people's careers. It contributes nothing to their job skills or STEM skills.

Then when you have U.S. college professors who really don't give a damn if they have a 60% drop/fail rate, it's no wonder there aren't enough students graduating with these degrees.

Besides all that, the degree program doesn't teach the needed skills either, because the STEM courses at college are 5 to 10 years out-dated...

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.