Molecular rings mystery solved after 20 years

Molecular rings mystery solved after 20 years
The two benzene rings in a benzene dimer can have one of two configurations: flat on top of one another (left) or one flat and the other upright on top (right).

Although the double benzene molecule tried to reveal its structure in experiments in 1993, chemists at the time were unable to find an explanation for the spectral peaks they saw. Now, 20 years later, Nijmegen theoretical chemist Prof. Ad van der Avoird has come up with a theory that exactly describes the position of two benzene rings in relation to one another and their possible motion. Together with colleague Prof. Gerard Meijer and an experimental group in Berlin, he will publish the model in a 'Very Important Paper' in Angewandte Chemie International Edition on April 15.

Benzene is a molecule that has a structure in the shape of a hexagonal ring. Two can form a stable bi-molecule (a ). There are two different ways in which they can be positioned relative to one another: one flat on top of the other or one lying flat and the other upright on top. If the rings are part of a larger molecule their configuration influences the folding of the molecule or the binding between two such molecules, which in turn greatly affects the molecule's .

Molecular rings mystery solved after 20 years
The two benzene rings in a benzene dimer can have one of two configurations: flat on top of one another (left) or one flat and the other upright on top (right).

From experiment to theory

A spectrum of the benzene dimer was first recorded in 1993, with the aim to find out more about its structure and dynamics. The experiments produced characteristic patterns with four peaks, which no one could decipher for 20 years. Scientists from Berlin, Hannover and Hamburg recently repeated the experiments using the most advanced equipment in the hope that this, together with calculations made by van der Avoird, would clarify the issue. However, the problem remained unsolved. Now, using a new theoretical model and the experimental data gathered in Berlin, the spectral patterns have been successfully deciphered and the dynamics that cause them explained.

Making choices

Van der Avoird explained: "The old model was not wrong, but it was very complicated. As a result, the made using the model were too inaccurate to be able to calculate the peak patterns. I therefore needed to pare the model down to the basics, after which the spectral patterns just rolled out of the calculations. The key to success was the insight that the rings rotate in synchronisation. They work together to switch rapidly between one energy minimum and another. This results, via the quantum tunnelling process, in the recorded peak patterns."

Molecular rings mystery solved after 20 years
The insight that the two benzene rings rotate in synchronisation, led to a new theory that could explain the peak structure from 1993.

Van der Waals forces

The van der Waals forces described in the model are certainly one of the cornerstones of chemistry, says van der Avoird, though he dare not say whether his observations will make it into the chemistry text books. Even so, there are certainly practical applications. "For example, large-scale simulations are often used to develop new drugs in the pharmaceutical industry and these require an understanding of the van der Waals forces between the receptor and the potential drug molecules."

Van der Avoird will publish the article together with the experimental researchers from Berlin, Hannover and Hamburg. Co-author Gerard Meijer, currently President of the Executive Board at Radboud University Nijmegen, was director of the Department of Molecular Physics at the Fritz Haber Institute in Berlin at the time the research was conducted there. The article was accepted very quickly (within two weeks) and marked VIP (Very Important Paper).

Explore further

First single-molecule measurement of Van Der Waals interactions at metal-organic interface

More information: Schnell, M. et al. Die Struktur des Benzoldimers – die Dynamik gewinnt, Angewandte Chemie International Edition. DOI: 10.1002/ange.201300653
Citation: Molecular rings mystery solved after 20 years (2013, April 16) retrieved 18 October 2019 from
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

Feedback to editors

User comments

Apr 17, 2013
This is consistent with Art Winfree's Law of Coupled Oscillators, which he articulated circa 1967. The law states that in any system of limit cycle oscillators, the oscillators will synchronize their oscillations in precise patterns. The simplest such patterns are two oscillator systems, which will form one of two patterns--either exactly synchronous or exactly antisynchronous.

The benzene rings are limit cycle oscillators. They rotate. They are a two oscillator system--dimers. They either synchronize (left picture, flat on top) or antisynchronize (right picture, bottom one flat and other one upright on top). Exact outcome predicted by Winfree, 46 years ago.

See "Coupled Oscillators and Biological Systems," by Steven Strogatz and Ian Stewart, Scientific American, Dec. 1993, describing Art Winfree's theory and its application to biological systems. Copy available online at a site.

See also my many Macksb posts on PhysOrg, most of which involve Winfree's law.

Apr 17, 2013
Which spectrum they are talking about? Not 1H NMR for sure, nor FTIR. It must be some relatively new method, if benzene has been analyzed with it for the first time as late as 1993.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more