World's largest study to date into computer-based financial trading reveals beneficial effects but warns of systemic ris

November 5, 2012, University of Bristol
World's largest study to date into computer-based financial trading reveals beneficial effects but warns of systemic risks

A new Government research project, undertaken by an international team of researchers including experts from the University of Bristol, into the advantages and risks of computer-based trading in financial markets has shown it to have beneficial effects but warned of the risks of greater instability.

have meant that computer-based trading, which enable for buying and selling securities—rather than humans to drive high-speed , now represent the majority of quotes and trades in financial markets.

The two-year study, involving experts from more than 20 countries, aimed to generate evidence on the links between computer-based trading and liquidity, volatility, the likelihood of market crashes and market manipulation.

Evidence from the report, described by the New York Times as 'the most comprehensive effort to date to understand the computerised trading firms that have come to dominate the financial markets and generate anxiety among regulators and investors', suggest that computer-based trading has several on markets.

Results show it helps to maintain liquidity, reduce transaction costs and increase the efficiency of market prices but finds no evidence to suggest it has led to increased volatility or abuse of the market. However, it warns that computer-based trading may lead to episodes of illiquidity and instability, including 'Flash Crashes'.  The study also presents a cost and benefit analysis of each of the tools available to policy makers to curb high-frequency trading (HFT).

Professor Sir John Beddington, the Government's Chief Scientific Adviser, commenting on the findings, said: "Well-functioning financial markets are vital for everyone. They support business and growth across the world and provide important services for investors. This research provides evidence to policy-makers concerning the effect of HFT on financial markets, looking out to 2022.

"There has been a relative lack of evidence and analysis to inform new regulations designed to increase market competition and protect consumers, and so this report provides clear advice on what regulatory measures might be most effective in addressing those concerns in the shorter term, while preserving the benefits that this technology may bring."

Dr Sylvain Friederich, Senior Lecturer in the University's School of Economics, Finance and Management, one of the writers of the project's final report (the key document for policy purposes) also contributed several studies to the 'evidence base' feeding into the document. Three studies, written with Professor Richard Payne of the Cass Business School, focus on the effect of high-frequency trading on liquidity, the likelihood of market abuse, and evaluate order-to-trade ratios as a policy tool.  A fourth study with Dr Mike Yearworth of the University of Bristol's System Centre draws out a 'systems map' of for policy makers to analyse interactions and feedback effects between players.

Explore further: Algorithmic trading to replace humans in the stock market

More information: The full report 'The Future of Computer Trading in Financial Markets – An International Perspective' and evidence base is available at … rts-and-publications.

Related Stories

Algorithmic trading to replace humans in the stock market

September 14, 2011

( -- The UK Government’s Foresight panel, led by Dame Clara Furse, has released a working paper that points out that algorithmic trading, or high frequency trading, will soon replace human decision making ...

US imposes new rules on high-speed traders

July 26, 2011

US regulators on Tuesday announced new rules aimed at shedding light on the secretive industry of computerized high-speed trading, which has been blamed for destabilizing financial markets.

Metric predicts stock market 'flash' crashes

December 3, 2010

The May 6, 2010, stock market crash briefly erased almost $1 trillion in value and plunged the Dow Jones Industrial Average into its biggest intraday fall ever. The market recovered most of its losses within the hour, but ...

High-frequency stock trade risky, unfair: experts

September 21, 2012

The increasing power of computerized high-frequency trades on US markets has been assailed in Congress as dangerous and unfair, as pressure builds to reel in the powerful industry.

Wall Street's super traders come under fire

September 9, 2010

A handful of traders who master stock markets using ultra-fast computers may soon face a clampdown by US watchdogs as they try to prevent freak electronic glitches.

Study links ultrafast machine trading with risk of crash

February 19, 2012

( -- In the United States, ultrafast trading in financial markets between 2006 and 2011 was the underlying factor for over 18,000 extreme price changes, according to a new study. Neil Johnson, a professor in the ...

Recommended for you

Are palaeontologists naming too many species?

March 14, 2018

A comprehensive new study looking at variations in Ichthyosaurus, a common British Jurassic ichthyosaur (sea-going reptile) also known as 'Sea Dragons', has provided important information into recognizing new fossil species.

Pterosaurs went out with a bang, not a whimper

March 13, 2018

Fossils of six new species of pterosaurs - giant flying reptiles that flew over the heads of the dinosaurs - have been discovered by a research team led by the Milner Centre for Evolution at the University of Bath, revealing ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.