Restless stars: High precision study reveals surprising unrest in massive star clusters

Restless stars: High precision study reveals surprising unrest in massive star clusters
Partial view of the giant nebula NGC 3603 with its central, 1 million year old compact starburst cluster. False-colour image based on observations with the "Wide Field/Planetary Camera 2" of the Hubble Space Telescope. The dominant green colour signalizes light emitted as ionized hydrogen regains its missing electron. The image shape is due to the detector placement camera. Image: NASA/ESA/Wolfgang Brandner (MPIA), Boyke Rochau (MPIA) und Andrea Stolte

( -- Using the NASA/ESA Hubble Space Telescope, astronomers from the Max Planck Institute for Astronomy in Heidelberg and the University of Cologne have completed a high precision study of one of the most massive young star clusters in the Milky Way. To this end, the scientific researchers compared two observations that were made ten years apart.

Their unexpected findings: the members of the cluster are in no stable state of balance and have not yet "settled down". (published in the , June 10, 2010)

Open stellar clusters such as the famous Pleiades will be held together forever: in the course of dozens of millions of years their different stars will disperse. Very massive and compact clusters are different. In the long term, this can lead to the development of massive aggregations of globular clusters, whose tightly-packed stars remain gravitationally bound to each other for billions of years.

With a mass of more than 10,000 suns packed into a volume with a diameter of a mere three light-years, the massive young star cluster in the giant nebula NGC 3603 is one of the most compact stellar clusters in the . For comparison, in our immediate cosmic neighbourhood, there is only one single star of the same volume as the Sun. Could this massive open be a globular cluster in the making?

In order to unravel this question, a team of astronomers led by Wolfgang Brandner from the Max Planck Institute for Astronomy, Heidelberg, MPIA, tracked the movement of hundreds of the cluster's stars. Such a study can reveal whether the stars were in the process of drifting apart, or about to settle down, i.e. to achieve a long-term, stable state of balance. What is more, the measurements also serve to distinguish members of the star cluster from unrelated stars that, as viewed from Earth, just happen to fall along the same light of sight.

Measurements of this kind are difficult. Imagine a star moving sideways at a rate of a few kilometres per second, viewed from a distance of 20,000 light-years - the actual distance of NGC 3603 from Earth - such a star's position on the night sky would shift by no more than a few billionths of an angular degree per year, at the limit of the capability of today's most precise observation methods and instruments.

By using two observations, made ten years apart with the same camera aboard the , and by performing an intricate analysis to account for all possible disturbances, Brandner and his team were able to reach the required accuracy. All in all, the astronomers observed more than 800 stars. About 50 of these were identified as foreground stars, which are unrelated to the cluster. From the remaining sample of more than 700 - a quite varied selection in terms of different masses and surface temperatures - the astronomers were able to obtain sufficiently precise speed measurements for 234 cluster stars.

Boyke Rochau (MPIA), the paper's lead author, who performed the data analysis as part of his PhD work, explains: "Once our analysis was completed, we reached a precision of 27 millionths of an arc second per year. Imagine you are in Bremen, observing an object that is located in Vienna. Now the object moves sideways by the breadth of a human hair. That's a change in apparent position of about 27 millionths of an arc second."

The results for the motion of these cluster stars were surprising. According to widely accepted models, which reproduce what is actually observed in older globular clusters, the average stellar speed in a cluster like the one in NGC 3603 should depend on mass. Stars with lower mass should move faster, and those with higher mass should move more slowly. The stars for which precision measurements were possible represent a range of masses between 2 and 9 times that of the Sun. Yet their average speed does not appear to vary with mass at all, with all of them moving at about the same average speed of 4.5 km/s.

Apparently this very massive star cluster has not yet settled down. Instead, the stars' velocities still reflect conditions from the time the cluster was formed, approximately one million years ago.
The intriguing question of whether or not the massive young cluster in NGC 3603 will become a globular cluster remains open. Given the new results, it all depends on the speeds of the low-mass stars, which were too faint to allow for precise speed measurements with the Hubble Space Telescope.

Wolfgang Brandner says: "To find out whether or not our will disperse, we will need to wait for the next generation of telescopes, such as the James Webb Telescope or the European Extremely Large of the European Southern Observatory."

Explore further

Hubble catches stars on the move (w/ Video)

More information: B. Rochau et al. Internal dynamics and membership of NGC 3603 Young Cluster from microarcsecond astrometry, Astrophysical Journal, June 10, 2010
Citation: Restless stars: High precision study reveals surprising unrest in massive star clusters (2010, June 7) retrieved 19 July 2019 from
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

Feedback to editors

User comments

Jun 07, 2010
If you have a lot of observational data on a cluster, you can do a computer simulation and compare the results with what you see.

I did that in my Master's thesis almost 10 years ago.
The computer code is very complex and includes even stellar evolution. I used a PC for the simulations. Good times :-)

Jun 08, 2010
I'd guess, some dark matter thing and violation of relativity manifests here again. These stars are actually repulsing at distance, which results in "quantum noise" of stars inside of dense clusters. Without it the tidal forces and gravitational waves should lead to the gradual slowing of star motion.

No they're not.

A star cluster is formed of dense gas pockets. Typically a very large star will form, and on formation blast the locally accreting material away forming other smaller dense pockets of gas that will contine to generate stars. In some cases these clusters are so dense that they are gravitationally bound to each other on formation. Seeing as these stars are formed by what we would consider utterly massive forces, the chaos of their movement when orbiting each other and otherwise gravitationally interaction appears to be almost like dropping ice cubes into a whirlpool. They bunch up, fly apart, crash into each other... TBC

Jun 08, 2010
[cont] over time, just like in any system, a point of stability will be attained where the velocities and momentum has decreased or increased to create a stable system of moving stars. This is a settled star cluster.

This article is speaking to the fact that we're seeing large star clusters are still in the throes of chaotic creation, ejection, and all the other non-stable activities that a highly dense population of massive bodies will undergo. Eventually, stability will occur and we'll have a rather uninteeresting conglomeration of astral bodies.

There is no violation of any existing tennets, simply a confirmation of our knowledge of star cluster formation.

Then again, if you were anything other than a trollish wanna-be physicist, you'd already know that. Further, you'd know that our star, the Sun, appears to have been ejected from its cluster during a period of instability, and that we're currently trying to verify that hypothesis.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more