Cultural history colors thought about bioethics, evolution

February 21, 2010, Duke University

Cultural views of evolution can have important ethical implications, says a Duke University expert on theological and biomedical ethics. Because the popular imagination filters science through cultural assumptions about race, cultural history should be an essential part of biomedical conversations.

Amy Laura Hall, associate professor of Christian ethics at Duke University, argues that many popularized ideas about evolution assume that some human groups are more evolved than other human groups.

"I believe that , as depicted in the popular press, too often uncritically reinforces ideas about race that privilege white, Western bodies and cultures. I see this at work today in new arguments for paternalism in Haiti, for example" says Hall, who appears on a Sunday morning panel at the AAAS annual meeting called "Genetics and Ethics: Different Views on the Human Condition."

The panel of scholars from the fields of genetics and theology will focus on how genetics and its medical applications are communicated to the general public.

Hall's current research looks at ways evolutionary biology is conveyed in the popular media. She cites examples of television documentaries about evolution that portray commencing in Africa, using images of dark-skinned people "almost as living icons" to represent humanity at our genesis. "When evolution is depicted as an upward slope, those representing the origin are also often perceived as the nadir," she says.

Hall is looking at how these popular portrayals are reinforced in recent media coverage of the earthquake disaster in Haiti, coverage that she says depicts Haitians as more primal and less developed, and how this may influence relief efforts that are more paternalistic in nature.

"In order to seek more collaborative, less hierarchical models of international engagement or relief work, we need to discuss head-on the racist ways evolutionary biology has become dispersed," she says.

"In order to collaborate, you have to consider your potential collaborators as adults, rather than as people further down a slope of human development, thus assuming a kind of tacit paternalism," says Hall, whose training is as a moral theologian.

Hall's research in this area will be part of her forthcoming book on "muscular Christianity," a movement that crystallized during the Victorian era to reinforce virile Christianity and social Darwinism.

Hall is also involved in a project on neurobiology, poverty, virtue and vice with a group of researchers from Vanderbilt and Marquette Universities. Her most recent book is "Conceiving Parenthood: American Protestantism and the Spirit of Reproduction" (Eerdmans, 2008).

Explore further: Reflecting on the social implications of human genetics research -- past, present and future

Related Stories

Stem cell research from an ethical point of view

June 25, 2008

Stem cell research and the potential use of human embryonic stem cells in clinical therapy is a controversial issue which splits both scientific and public opinion. The current conflict over embryonic stem cells throughout ...

The changing facebook of genetic

January 19, 2010

(PhysOrg.com) -- Social factors such as what we eat and where we live influence how natural selection acts on human genes, according to a research that is bringing the worlds of genetics and human sciences closer together.

Anthropologist researches evolution of Darwin’s theory

September 2, 2009

(PhysOrg.com) -- New research by University of Notre Dame anthropologist Agustin Fuentes, published recently in the European journal Anthropology Today, states that although Darwin’s basic ideas still form the core of our ...

Recommended for you

3 comments

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

bobsully
not rated yet Feb 21, 2010
"assume"? Pigmentation has evolved from both natural environmental selection and as influenced by sexual selection to a lesser extent.
Caliban
1 / 5 (2) Feb 22, 2010
I dunno, marjon-
I think if you investigate a little further, you'll find that slavery was, is, and always has been based on superior force of arms, rather than Race.
I agree with you though, that this good doctor is overstating the case. At the same time, I think she's right about the Haiti crisis. At this point, it bears all the hallmarks of an imposed, top-down, remake/remodel. But that may well be the only way to manage it. Only time will tell.
Caliban
1 / 5 (2) Feb 22, 2010
Marjon-
Pretty much every culture in the entirety of recorded(and, we assume, pre-) history has practiced slavery. Slaves are taken primarily by force of arms, although there is the time-honoured practice of selling yourself or a family member to satisfy an obligation, earn income, or reduce expenses as well. Barring that one exception, however, slaves had to be subdued and abducted, and were then placed in bondage service to the state or retailed on the slave market. Europeans, Asians, Africans, North and South Amerindians, and Australian Aboriginals- all at one time or another, in greater and lesser numbers: Slaves.
Oreo Star Trek Frank Gorshin was on a tv show.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.