Anger as FIFA rejects goal-line technology

Mar 07, 2010
Birmingham's Scottish manager Alex McLeish hit out at FIFA's decision to reject the introduction of goal-line technology. McLeish's team appeared to have been denied a legitimate goal in their FA Cup quarter-finals 2-0 defeat by Portsmouth earlier Saturday, a goal that would surely have stood if replays had been available to match officials.

The International Football Association Board has rejected the introduction of goal-line technology, sparking an angry reaction from some football managers.

The decision was taken after a presentation of experiments during which cameras were placed on the posts and electronic chips inserted in the ball to determine if it had crossed the goal line. Hawk-Eye technology using cameras and computers is already used in tennis and cricket.

A unanimous decision was not reached by board members on goal-line technology, but according to a source close to the dossier, a majority came out in principle against its introduction.

"Concerning goal-line technology, the board concluded that goal-line technology would not be pursued," the sport's world governing body FIFA said in a statement Saturday.

The news brought a sharp reaction from Arsenal manager Arsene Wenger, who said it was "beyond comprehension" that global chiefs had maintained their opposition to goal-line technology.

"For me, it is difficult to understand, for one reason because you want as much justice as possible," Wenger added.

"I do not even think it is linked with the money factor. If you love football you want the right decisions to be made."

Birmingham manager Alex McLeish also hit out at the decision.

McLeish's team appeared to have been denied a legitimate goal in their FA Cup quarter-finals 2-0 defeat by Portsmouth earlier Saturday, a goal that would surely have stood if replays had been available to match officials.

"That is a frustrating decision by FIFA because I think they are doing their officials a disservice," said the former Scotland and Rangers manager.

"It's not easy for their guys to see it in a split second. I know you can't stop every part of the game but certainly for key decisions in a major competition like the FA Cup, your chances of getting to semi-finals and finals are few and far between for a little club like us."

This is not the first time McLeish has spoken out in favour of the new technology.

After last November's incident in which Thierry Henry's controversial handball against Ireland helped France qualify for the World Cup Finals, McLeish said the system would have spotted Henry's offence.

But opponents of such moves argue that video evidence is often inconclusive and that the process of watching would interrupt the flow of the game.

FIFA said that a presentation had also been provided on the experiment with additional assistant referees in the Europa League, after 144 matches played so far.

FIFA added that a special meeting of the board would discuss the final analysis of the experiment on May 17-18, after the May 12 Europa League final.

Explore further: Reflected smartphone transmissions enable gesture control

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Yahoo! provides FIFA Web site

Dec 05, 2005

Yahoo! said Monday it will partner with the Fédération Internationale de Football Association to set up a Web site to cover the upcoming soccer games.

England first as game live on Internet, in cinemas

Oct 05, 2009

England's World Cup qualifier against Ukraine on Saturday is to make history by being the team's first international to be shown live in cinemas and on the Internet but not on TV, media group Perform said.

Robot footballers wow crowd in Germany

Mar 02, 2010

Forget Cristiano Ronaldo, Wayne Rooney or Lionel Messi. With less than 100 days to the World Cup, it was four pint-sized robots that wowed crowds in Germany Tuesday with their footballing skills.

Study: Football coaches are conservative

Feb 27, 2006

A University of California-Berkeley researcher says he's discovered professional football coaches tend toward conservative decision-making behavior.

Study: Football coaches are conservative

Feb 27, 2006

A University of California-Berkeley researcher says he's discovered professional football coaches tend toward conservative decision-making behavior.

Sony signs 3-D video deal for 2010 World Cup

Dec 04, 2009

(AP) -- The 2010 World Cup is going 3-D. Sony Corp. said Friday it has signed a deal with FIFA, the international football governing body, to record up to 25 World Cup games in 3-D - a technology that gives ...

Recommended for you

Google to test cars without a driver

Sep 16, 2014

Google plans to begin testing its new prototype of a self-driving car - which, unlike earlier models, doesn't require a back-up driver - at NASA's Ames Research Center, just a few miles from the tech company's ...

Self-driving cars now need a permit in California

Sep 16, 2014

Computer-driven cars have been testing their skills on California roads for more than four years—but until now, the Department of Motor Vehicles wasn't sure just how many were rolling around.

Index ranks Japan Asia's most efficient innovator (Update)

Sep 12, 2014

A new index ranks Japan as the most efficient among Asian countries in turning the building blocks of creativity into tangible innovations that benefit their economies and people while Myanmar, Pakistan and Cambodia are least ...

User comments : 2

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

RubberBaron
not rated yet Mar 07, 2010
And the game continues flowing because players start arguing with the ref?

FIFA is stuffed with anti-technology old codgers.
poi
not rated yet Mar 07, 2010
FIFA is stuffed with anti-technology old codgers.

then just give it time (on more than one sense), since technology, especially its adoption, is a factor of time.