High-tech swimsuits are 'bad news', expert says

Jul 29, 2009
Joel Stager

Joel Stager, director of the Counsilman Center for the Science of Swimming at Indiana University, says it's about time elite swimmers come around to the idea that high-tech swimsuits are bad news.

"There's an overwhelming dissatisfaction by the community that this is turning into an escalating technology war," he said. "Finally, the athletes are getting it into their heads that their efforts are being devalued. It's not about who wins or loses, but what suit they're wearing. It's disappointing."

Stager, longtime swim coach and competitive swimmer, refused to watch the World Championships this week, during which athletes crushed numerous world records and swimming phenom Michael Phelps lost his first major race in four years.

"It's a carnival. It's a joke," Stager said. "I'd like to be able to believe that we've come up with a new protocol for training and preparing our athletes, or we've found some nutritional secret, but that's not the case."

High-tech swimsuits have been credited with a surprising rash of records in 2008-2009. Prior to that time, Stager's research found no bias -- or anything unusual from a historical and statistical perspective -- about swim times at major meets, such as the Olympics.

Stager says the swimming community (around 600,000 competitive swimmers nationwide) has not benefited financially from the new technology, yet it represents a sizable market for the suits, which can cost $280 to almost $580. He said competitive swimmers typically purchase one swimsuit for the season and then a second one for championships. A championship round of suits could cost a high school swimming program around $20,000, which is how much Stager estimates all swimmers combined had spent at Indiana state championships prior to these new costly suits. Now, he estimates Indiana swimmers will spend a combined $100,000 on swimsuits for the state meet. College swimming programs have felt the pinch, too.

"Last year, a lot of college coaches had to call parents up and ask for help purchasing swim suits," Stager said. "That's the only way they can do it. Given all the other costs of going to college, it's ridiculous."

FINA, the international governing body for swimming, has rules that prohibit performance- or buoyancy-enhancing gear. The body decided in June to allow some of the suits. However, in the last week, FINA has changed course, deciding to ban many of the high-tech suits beginning sometime next year, requiring swim suits to be made of textile fabric, not rubberized material, and reducing the coverage allowed by the suits -- no longer allowing full-body coverage.

Stager said the ban is worthwhile but should begin as soon as possible because of the confusion surrounding which swimming records were obtained by athletes wearing controversial swimsuits.

"There is absolutely no rationale for allowing these suits to be used beyond yesterday," he said. "We don't need anymore asterisks on the record books."

Provided by Indiana University (news : web)

Explore further: Oculus Rift users to see Moon live through robot

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Virtual swimmer to speed up athletes

Mar 30, 2006

CSIRO and the Australian Institute of Sport are using mathematics in a bid to speed up our top swimmers by testing changes to swimming strokes. The research will make use of the same software CSIRO uses for other fluid simulations ...

Recommended for you

Oculus Rift users to see Moon live through robot

10 hours ago

A group from Carnegie Mellon wants to send a robot to the Moon to beam live pictures of the Moon to Oculus Rift headset users, reported technology reporter Jane Wakefield of the BBC. Andy the robot is intended ...

Skin icons can tap into promise of smartwatch

Oct 21, 2014

You have heard it before: smartwatches are cool wearables but critics remind us of the fact that their small size makes many actions cumbersome and they question how many people will really have them on their ...

Japan firm showcases Bat-Signal of the future

Oct 20, 2014

A free-floating image created by firing lasers into thin air was unveiled in Japan on Monday, offering the possibility one day of projecting messages into a cloudless sky, as seen in Batman.

User comments : 5

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

x646d63
5 / 5 (2) Jul 29, 2009
Make them all swim naked. That will level the field.
rincewind
not rated yet Jul 29, 2009
Any attempt to 'level playing fields' in modern sports is ultimately doomed to a farce.

Love the technology, love the competition!
Mandan
not rated yet Jul 30, 2009
Make them all swim naked. That will level the field.


Your idea does not hold water. Some women and men have certain larger body parts than others which would increase drag. However, this brings to mind a unique solution! Since steroids would cause a reduction in size of these problematic body parts in both women and men, all swimmers should swim naked, but be required to take steroids.

Problem solved. Next question.
zevkirsh
not rated yet Jul 30, 2009
they should all swim naked.
georgert
not rated yet Jul 30, 2009
With the same thinking, why not race Formula 1 with the cars of the 1950s? And don't cry to me about the cost of swim suits. I'm involved in coaching ski racing, and the annual cost of equipment, training, travel and racing for high-school age students easily runs over $6000 per season.