Lessons from Schon -- the worst physics fraudster?

May 05, 2009

How did a 31-year-old physicist working at Bell Labs in New Jersey, US, get away with possibly the worst case of physics research fraud known? From claims to have made the world's first organic electrical laser to the fictional construction of the smallest ever transistor, the repercussions of Jan Hendrik Schön's fraud are still felt today, seven years after he was found guilty of scientific misconduct and fired by his employer.

Writing in the May issue of Physics World, Eugenie Samuel Reich chronicles how his shook the scientific world, in abridged and edited extracts from her new book 'Plastic Fantastic'. Reich, a journalist in the US, describes how Schön's research developed from colleague-pleasing fibs into world-class deception and asks why the much-celebrated self-correcting nature of did not bring the fraud to light sooner.

In 2000 alone, Schön published eight papers in Science and Nature and became known for his ability to coax materials into superconductors, leading scientists in at least a dozen labs to chase research rainbows, wasting millions of dollars of US government research money.

It was Schön's journal paper describing the construction of molecular transistors that tripped the first domino when two fellow physicists attempted to research that showed that soft lithography could be used to make softer and gentle contact with organic molecules.

Julia Hsu and Lynn Loo were using Schön's paper to show how novel their experimental progress was when they accidentally stumbled across duplicated data and raised an alarm bell that led eventually to Schön's dismissal.

As Reich writes, "Science was corrected in the Schön case, but not by itself - only because individual scientists made corrections. From would-be replicators in dozens of labs to many sceptics, only a couple of researchers were transformed into whistle-blowers by the unlikely pattern of [duplicated] evidence."

Reich continues, "Fraud was able to stifle questions about Schön's lab technique that would otherwise have been asked, and to turn review processes at journals into opportunities for additional fabrication. Other scientists' support of the fraud was unwitting, but the decision to place so much trust in a colleague was a conscious rationalisation that continues to be defended in science to this day."

Source: Institute of Physics (news : web)

Explore further: New insights found in black hole collisions

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Scientists resolve to crack down on fraud

Dec 10, 2008

Public confidence in the honesty of scientists is being harmed by a small minority of researchers who behave badly, a conference heard last week. European research organisations agreed to work more closely to tackle the problem ...

Calif. man charged in Net 'click fraud'

Mar 30, 2006

A California man has been charged with using a "click fraud" scheme to chisel the FreeRide Web site out of reward points used to obtain free merchandise.

Managing computer fraud

May 23, 2008

Shalini Kesar, a computer scientist at Southern Utah University in Cedar City, has devised an antifraud strategy for business. Writing in the International Journal of Business Information Systems from Inderscience Publis ...

U.S. officials hunt Medicare fraud

Nov 07, 2006

U.S. federal investigators are hunting incidents of Medicare fraud, using sophisticated computer technology to determine unusual patterns.

Recommended for you

New insights found in black hole collisions

1 hour ago

New research provides revelations about the most energetic event in the universe—the merging of two spinning, orbiting black holes into a much larger black hole.

X-rays probe LHC for cause of short circuit

1 hour ago

The LHC has now transitioned from powering tests to the machine checkout phase. This phase involves the full-scale tests of all systems in preparation for beam. Early last Saturday morning, during the ramp-down, ...

Swimming algae offer insights into living fluid dynamics

4 hours ago

None of us would be alive if sperm cells didn't know how to swim, or if the cilia in our lungs couldn't prevent fluid buildup. But we know very little about the dynamics of so-called "living fluids," those ...

Fluctuation X-ray scattering

Mar 26, 2015

In biology, materials science and the energy sciences, structural information provides important insights into the understanding of matter. The link between a structure and its properties can suggest new ...

Hydrodynamics approaches to granular matter

Mar 26, 2015

Sand, rocks, grains, salt or sugar are what physicists call granular media. A better understanding of granular media is important - particularly when mixed with water and air, as it forms the foundations of houses and off-shore ...

User comments : 5

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

3 / 5 (2) May 05, 2009
It is human nature to place trust in those others place trust in. All organizations, science, religion, school, or drinking club based function the exact same way.
2 / 5 (2) May 05, 2009
shoen should have his own rock band call it Journey to the IG nobels
1 / 5 (2) May 05, 2009
I love how they point out that "Schon published eight papers in .... Nature" and then wonder how he could have got away with it.

Time to wake up folks, the days of Nature being an honest and true science magazine/organization are long gone.
5 / 5 (1) May 06, 2009
Wow Koen you're a nasty piece of work and no mistake.
not rated yet May 06, 2009
shoen should have his own rock band call it Journey to the IG nobels
Now there's irony. Funny how you would be attracted to comment on a story about physics fraud Farbstein. How's your phony company going? Managed to actually con anyone out of any money lately?

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.