# Mathematicians find new solutions to an ancient puzzle

##### Mar 14, 2008

Many people find complex math puzzling, including some mathematicians. Recently, mathematician Daniel J. Madden and retired physicist, Lee W. Jacobi, found solutions to a puzzle that has been around for centuries.

Jacobi and Madden have found a way to generate an infinite number of solutions for a puzzle known as 'Euler’s Equation of degree four.'

The equation is part of a branch of mathematics called number theory. Number theory deals with the properties of numbers and the way they relate to each other. It is filled with problems that can be likened to numerical puzzles.

“It’s like a puzzle: can you find four fourth powers that add up to another fourth power" Trying to answer that question is difficult because it is highly unlikely that someone would sit down and accidentally stumble upon something like that,” said Madden, an associate professor of mathematics at The University of Arizona in Tucson.

The team's finding is published in the March issue of The American Mathematical Monthly.

Equations are puzzles that need certain solutions “plugged into them” in order to create a statement that obeys the rules of logic.

For example, think of the equation x + 2 = 4. Plugging “3” into the equation doesn’t work, but if x = 2, then the equation is correct.

In the mathematical puzzle that Jacobi and Madden worked on, the problem was finding variables that satisfy a Diophantine equation of order four. These equations are so named because they were first studied by the ancient Greek mathematician Diophantus, known as 'the father of algebra.’

In its most simple version, the puzzle they were trying to solve is the equation:
(a)(to the fourth power) + (b)(to the fourth power) + (c)(to the fourth power) + (d)(to the fourth power) = (a + b + c + d)(to the fourth power)

That equation, expressed mathematically, is:
a4 + b4 +c4 +d4 = (a + b + c + d)4

Madden and Jacobi found a way to find the numbers to substitute, or plug in, for the a's, b's, c's and d's in the equation. All the solutions they have found so far are very large numbers.

In 1772, Euler, one of the greatest mathematicians of all time, hypothesized that to satisfy equations with higher powers, there would need to be as many variables as that power. For example, a fourth order equation would need four different variables, like the equation above.

Euler's hypothesis was disproved in 1987 by a Harvard graduate student named Noam Elkies. He found a case where only three variables were needed. Elkies solved the equation: (a)(to the fourth power) + (b)(to the fourth power) + (c)(to the fourth power) = e(to the fourth power), which shows only three variables are needed to create a variable that is a fourth power.

Inspired by the accomplishments of the 22-year-old graduate student, Jacobi began working on mathematics as a hobby after he retired from the defense industry in 1989.

Fortunately, this was not the first time he had dealt with Diophantine equations. He was familiar with them because they are commonly used in physics for calculations relating to string theory.

Jacobi started searching for new solutions to the puzzle using methods he found in some number theory texts and academic papers.

He used those resources and Mathematica, a computer program used for mathematical manipulations.

Jacobi initially found a solution for which each of the variables was 200 digits long. This solution was different from the other 88 previously known solutions to this puzzle, so he knew he had found something important.

Jacobi then showed the results to Madden. But Jacobi initially miscopied a variable from his Mathematica computer program, and so the results he showed Madden were incorrect.

“The solution was wrong, but in an interesting way. It was close enough to make me want to see where the error occurred,” Madden said.

When they discovered that the solution was invalid only because of Jacobi’s transcription error, they began collaborating to find more solutions.

Madden and Jacobi used elliptic curves to generate new solutions. Each solution contains a seed for creating more solutions, which is much more efficient than previous methods used.

In the past, people found new solutions by using computers to analyze huge amounts of data. That required a lot of computing time and power as the magnitude of the numbers soared.

Now people can generate as many solutions as they wish. There are an infinite number of solutions to this problem, and Madden and Jacobi have found a way to find them all.

The title of their paper is, “On a4 + b4 +c4 +d4 = (a + b + c + d)4."

“Modern number theory allowed me to see with more clarity the implications of his (Jacobi’s) calculations,” Madden said.

“It was a nice collaboration,” Jacobi said. “I have learned a certain amount of new things about number theory; how to think in terms of number theory, although sometimes I can be stubbornly algebraic.”

Source: University of Arizona

Explore further: Optimising the future with mathematics

## Related Stories

#### Chinese flyby of asteroid shows space rock is "rubble"

Dec 12, 2013

China's first flyby of an asteroid shows that a gigantic space rock which once triggered a doomsday scare is essentially rubble, scientists reported on Thursday.

#### America's top young scientist crafts system to purify water (w/ video)

Dec 20, 2012

(Phys.org)—Deepika Kurup, a 14-year-old high school student from Nashua, New Hampshire, has won this year's Discovery Education 3M Young Scientist Challenge for her solar-powered device designed to kill ...

#### Chip foundry has trouble meeting 28nm demand

Jun 16, 2012

(Phys.org) -- The next big things in mobile devices are being hammered by the next big headache for device makers—the chips at the foundation of their supply chain. High demand for devices is trickling down to the fact ...

#### India vies for elite role in space with Mars trip

Nov 04, 2013

India is aiming to join the world's deep-space pioneers with a journey to Mars that it hopes will showcase its technological ability to explore the solar system while seeking solutions for everyday problems ...

#### US zoo to breed rhino siblings

Jul 27, 2013

In a desperate bid to preserve a critically endangered species, a US zoo is taking the controversial step of trying to mate brother and sister captive Sumatran rhinoceroses.

#### Climate change could deprive Volta Basin of water needed to boost energy and food production

Jul 18, 2013

A new study released today finds that so much water may be lost in the Volta River Basin due to climate change that planned hydroelectric projects to boost energy and food production may only tread water in keeping up with ...

## Recommended for you

#### Giving dangerous employees socialization, close supervision can avoid problems

9 hours ago

Two UT Arlington management professors argue that employers can prevent workplace violence by keeping dangerous employees positively engaged and closely supervising them to ensure they get the help they need.

#### Gift giving 101: When do 'perfect' gifts backfire?

14 hours ago

When it comes to shopping for gifts, we try to select things we think people both want and need. According to a new study in the Journal of Consumer Research, focusing too much on the gift recipient can lead to giving the gi ...

#### What's the upside of feeling too sad for chocolate?

14 hours ago

The instant gratification and the pleasure derived from consuming excessive chocolate and deep-fried foods can lead way to a double-edged sword of negative consequences ranging from weight gain to feelings of low self-esteem. ...

#### Study shows men and women both biased against women's math abilities

14 hours ago

(Phys.org) —A study conducted by business and economic researchers Ernesto Reuben, Paola Sapienza, and Luigi Zingales, has found that both men and women hold biases against women's math abilities. In their ...

#### Power play: Empowered consumers are more likely to switch brands

14 hours ago

As consumers, we form favorite brands and select services providers from a plethora of choices. According to a new study in the Journal of Consumer Research, how powerful we feel in our daily lives may impact our likelihood of swi ...

#### Study finds investors prefer good-looking male backed entrepreneurial ventures

14 hours ago

(Phys.org) —A study conducted by a team of researchers from Harvard, Wharton and MIT has revealed that venture capitalists prefer to back entrepreneurial opportunities when pitched by a man and that they ...

## User comments : 5

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

##### Argiod
1 / 5 (2) Mar 15, 2008
I love it when a solution to a math problem turns out to be this elegant.
##### Doug_Huffman
1 / 5 (1) Mar 15, 2008
Would that its explanation here be as elegant and rise above 'equations as puzzles'
##### quantum_flux
not rated yet Mar 15, 2008
Whatever it is, I'll bet it has to do with 4 dimensional geometries with 3 spacial dimensions and 1 time dimension.

Kind of like the "A^2 plus B^2=(C)^2" rule for right triangles in plane geometry, but for the special case where "C = A plus B".
##### RAL
not rated yet Mar 16, 2008
I love it that an error in transcribing a number was turned into a whole new approach to the math.
##### koalabear3000
1 / 5 (1) Apr 16, 2008
i love it when i have dorks like u guys do my math homework for me. :]

## More news stories

#### Study shows men and women both biased against women's math abilities

(Phys.org) —A study conducted by business and economic researchers Ernesto Reuben, Paola Sapienza, and Luigi Zingales, has found that both men and women hold biases against women's math abilities. In their ...

#### Study finds investors prefer good-looking male backed entrepreneurial ventures

(Phys.org) —A study conducted by a team of researchers from Harvard, Wharton and MIT has revealed that venture capitalists prefer to back entrepreneurial opportunities when pitched by a man and that they ...

#### Study suggests more than two hours of homework a night may be counterproductive

Education scholar Denise Pope has found that too much homework has negative effects on student well-being and behavioral engagement.

#### New analyses verify the use of fire by Peking Man

Zhoukoudian Locality 1 in northern China has been widely known for the discovery of the Middle Pleistocene human ancestor Homo erectus pekinensis ( known as Peking Man ) since the 1920s. By 1931, the suggestion ...

#### Gift giving 101: When do 'perfect' gifts backfire?

When it comes to shopping for gifts, we try to select things we think people both want and need. According to a new study in the Journal of Consumer Research, focusing too much on the gift recipient can lead to giving the gi ...

#### A tailor made molecule against malaria

The malaria parasite is particularly pernicious since it is built to develop resistance to treatments. The lack of new therapeutic approaches also contributes to the persistence of this global scourge. A ...

#### Back surgery offers long-term societal benefits, according to new study

Annually, more than 10 million people experience back pain in the United States. More than 200,000 of these patients undergo surgery to alleviate pain due to a herniated disc. Surgery to remove the disc has been found to ...

#### Infection is the leading cause of failed prosthetic knee joints

The number of total knee replacement (TKR) procedures continues to climb, as does the number of revision total knee replacement (RTKR) surgeries. In the study, "The Epidemiology of Revision Total Knee Arthroplasty in the ...

#### Liver transplant may arrest neurological damage in a rare and progressive form of autism

A patient with a rare metabolic disease that causes liver failure and autistic behavior experienced significant improvements in both her physical and mental health after receiving a liver transplant, according to a new case ...

#### World's first 3-D acoustic cloaking device hides objects from sound

(Phys.org) —Using little more than a few perforated sheets of plastic and a staggering amount of number crunching, Duke engineers have demonstrated the world's first three-dimensional acoustic cloak. The ...