'Darwin's puddle' shows how new species can emerge without geographic separation

December 18, 2015
‘Darwin’s puddle’ shows how new species can emerge without geographic separation
The researchers discovered two significantly different forms of a common species of cichlid fish: one, known as littoral, has yellow-green males and lives towards the shores of the lake... Credit: Bangor University

Cichlid fish from a tiny volcanic crater lake in Africa have been caught in the act of sympatric speciation, whereby a new species evolves when there is no geographic barrier to physically separate the new species from the old. The study, led by the Wellcome Trust Sanger Institute and co-authored by the University of Bristol, is published today in Science.

Scientists studied the whole-genome sequences of 146 small in the 700m-wide Lake Massoko in Tanzania in order to answer two of the most debated questions in evolutionary biology: is sympatric speciation possible and, if so, what are the genetic and physical traits that drive this form of evolution (sexual attraction or specialisation in lifestyle, diet or other ecological factors)?

Senior author, Professor George Turner of the School of Biological Sciences, Bangor University said: "The idea of sympatric speciation has divided evolutionary opinion for a long time. It has been difficult to substantiate that new species can arise when genetic variations can be exchanged easily between the two evolving groups. But we have caught this form of evolution in the act by identifying two different forms of that are separating from each other within a lake that is only 700m wide."

Cichlid fish are a valuable model of evolution. In nearby Lake Malawi, many hundreds of cichlid species have been found, differentiated by size, shape, colour, feeding habits and ecological preferences such as living towards the surface of the lake or at the bottom. Because of this vast diversity the lake is known as 'Darwin's Pond'. In contrast Lake Massoko is 'Darwin's puddle': a much simpler place with many fewer species and fewer factors to drive speciation.

‘Darwin’s puddle’ shows how new species can emerge without geographic separation
...the other, known as benthic, has dark blue-black males and lives towards the bottom of the lake where the light levels are much lower. Credit: Bangor University

In the lake, researchers discovered two significantly different forms (ecomorphs) of a common species of cichlid fish. One ecomorph – known as littoral – has yellow-green males and lives towards the shores of the lake. The other form – benthic – has dark blue-black males and lives towards the bottom of the where the light levels are much lower. There are many other measurable differences between the ecomorphs, for example in body shape, jaws and diet.

These differences are reflected in the genetic differences observed when whole genomes from the two ecomorphs were sequenced and compared. The majority of significant genetic variation lay in a small number of genomic regions associated with sight (such as rhodopsin and other twilight-associated genes), hormone signalling, size and shape.

First author Dr Milan Malinsky of the Wellcome Trust Sanger Institute and the Gurdon Institute, University of Cambridge said: "One of the most striking characteristics of this diversification is that less than 1 per cent of the genome appears to be involved. Previous expectations were that speciation involved changes across the whole genome. However, in this example of nascent sympatric speciation, we find that the differences are confined to localised regions of the genome – known as genomic islands – that are associated with specific traits."

Confusingly, no single factor – either genetic or physical – seems to separate the two morphs: although they prefer different depths, the yellow and blue fish are frequently found together. One theoretical model for sympatric speciation is that sexual selection can reinforce differences via mate preference. The investigators also carried out mate-choice experiments between the ecomorphs in a controlled laboratory setting and found some differences, but again not enough to explain the separation by themselves.

Senior author, Dr Martin Genner of Bristol's School of Biological Sciences said: "We seem to be seeing a complex combination of ecological separation and mate-choice preference that jointly has allowed the two ecomorphs to separate even in the presence of some genetic exchange. These fish have much to tell us."

An exciting prospect is that these findings in a simple system will be relevant to understanding the much richer and more dramatic evolutionary radiation in Lake Malawi and the other African great lakes, and indeed beyond.

Senior author, Dr Richard Durbin from the Sanger Institute said: "The same genes are found in many species, both in fish and in other vertebrates. So the mechanisms at work in Lake Massoko are likely to have been involved in speciation more widely over history, driving evolution in which species can separate genetically to exploit new ecological niches even when there is no physical separation."

Explore further: Sediment study of African lake may help explain huge number of related fish species

More information: M. Malinsky et al. Genomic islands of speciation separate cichlid ecomorphs in an East African crater lake, Science (2015). DOI: 10.1126/science.aac9927

Related Stories

Competition breeds new fish species, study finds

February 28, 2014

Competition may play an important role during the evolution of new species, but empirical evidence for this is scarce, despite being implicit in Charles Darwin's work and support from theoretical studies.

Fish species in Lake Tana genetically surprisingly similar

October 9, 2015

The different species of barbels in Lake Tana in northern Ethiopia have evolved from a common ancestor. When biologists from Wageningen University first described the fifteen species over twenty years ago, it was not yet ...

Sandcastle-building fish offer evolution clue

December 6, 2013

(Phys.org) —In Lake Malawi, East Africa, there are around 200 different species of cichlid fish that once or twice a year build large sand structures (known as bowers) on which the fish mate. Each different species constructs ...

Recommended for you

Ten months in the air without landing

October 27, 2016

Common swifts are known for their impressive aerial abilities, capturing food and nest material while in flight. Now, by attaching data loggers to the birds, researchers reporting in the Cell Press journal Current Biology ...

Study shows mixed fortunes for Signy penguins

October 27, 2016

A forty year study on a remote Antarctic island shows that while populations of two penguin species are declining, a third is increasing. Analysis of census data from Signy Island in the South Orkney Islands reveals that, ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

5 / 5 (1) Dec 18, 2015
Here is the objections that speciation specialist Jerry Coyne has raised on similar research:

"The data, summarized in my book Speciation with Allen Orr (now a decade old), suggest that geographic isolation is usually necessary, but there are a few cases implying speciation without any geographic isolation. These are hard to demonstrate unequivocally, largely because closely related species that now live in the same area could have speciated in allopatry (different areas), and then come into secondary contact after the reproductive barriers evolved in isolation. Since it's harder to form species sympatrically, to demonstrate this process one must rule out that ancestral populations were ever isolated geographically. Since that's hard to do (speciation takes thousands to millions of years to complete), convincing cases are rare."

5 / 5 (1) Dec 18, 2015

"... the species in the lakes [seemingly isolated crater lakes in Cameroon, with cichlids] are not convincingly monophyletic [as per phylogenetic data discussed by Coyne], and also exchanged genes not only with each other, but with some species outside the lake.

How could this happen? In several ways, all of which violate the notion that speciation (the generation of largely reproductively isolated entities within the lake after an invasion by a single ancestor) occurred with free gene flow. "

5 / 5 (1) Dec 18, 2015

"All the data to date suggest that while sympatric speciation with free gene flow is a theoretical possibility, there is little evidence for it occurring in nature. There are certainly some cases (everything possible happens at least once in evolution), and of course getting good evidence for those cases would be hard. What we can say, though, is that there are not enough data to support the frequent assertion that sympatric speciation is common."

[ https://whyevolut...-part-1/ ; https://whyevolut...-part-2/ ]

TL;DR: These types of results have often a very long way to go to demonstrate that they purport to demonstrate. [But I haven't read the paper yet...]
Whydening Gyre
not rated yet Dec 18, 2015
My takeaway, TL, is that you are "from Missouri"
(Meaning - you'll believe it when you see more concrete evidence of it)...:-)

This is a tuff hypothesis to follow, altho "mate preferences" could play a significant role...
not rated yet Dec 18, 2015
Cichlid fish seem to have a knack for rapidly diversifying into multiple niches.

I suppose the 'speciation' test applies-- If you put a 'niche A' male with a 'niche B' female in a tank, what happens ??

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.