Beyond six nines: Ultra-enriched silicon paves the road to quantum computing

Aug 12, 2014 by Joshua Pomeroy
Inside the silicon deposition chamber. The glowing piece of unenriched silicon in the center can be heated above 1200 °C to clean the crystal and aid the process of growing layers of crystalline 28Si on its surface. Ions enter the chamber from the tube looming directly behind the glowing piece of unenriched silicon.

( —Using a relatively straightforward technique, a team of NIST researchers has created what may be the most highly enriched silicon currently being produced. The material is more than 99.9999% pure silicon-28 (28Si), with less than 1 part per million (ppm) of the problematic isotope silicon-29 (29Si). Many quantum computing schemes require isotopically pure silicon, for example to act as a substrate in which qubits – the quantum bits that store information – are embedded. In reaching "five nines" (99.9998%) last year and better than "six nines" this year*, the NIST team has surpassed its own enrichment goals.

"I think if you ask most people in the community if six nines was sufficient for purposes, they would say, 'Yeah! By a factor of a hundred!'" says team leader Josh Pomeroy of PML's Quantum Processes and Metrology Group. "The real challenge now is to make this amorphous enriched into a form that is equivalent to what you would get if you bought a wafer or epitaxial layer," which will eventually be needed to build practical systems. Pomeroy's team has already had some success in tackling this next step, which involves growing the ultra-enriched silicon as a nearly perfect crystal.

Currently, there is no reliable commercial source for sufficiently enriched silicon, which should consist of at least 99.99% 28Si to be useful for most quantum computing purposes. Unenriched silicon naturally contains about 92% 28Si, but there are other isotopes in there too, including 29Si at about 4.7%. The presence of 29Si is a problem in quantum computing because it dominates the breakdown of quantum information, or "decoherence,"** of the qubits.

"It has to do with unpaired nuclear spin states," Pomeroy says. The 29Si "essentially becomes the equivalent of people talking on their cell phones in the audience of a movie theatre. It messes everything up."

It's been demonstrated over the past decade or so that the elimination of unpaired spins can improve the fidelity of quantum information. Every factor of ten reduction of 29Si results in a factor of ten improvement in coherence time. The success of quantum information schemes that rely on silicon therefore strongly depends on finding a reliable way to realize this material.

To isolate the 28Si, the researchers employ a technique similar to mass spectrometry. Silicon atoms from natural abundance silane gas (SiH4) are ionized, extracted at high voltage, and then shot through a magnetic field, which causes the ions' trajectories to curve. The radius of their curvature depends on their mass, so 28Si and 29Si diverge into separate beams. To collect the 28Si ions, researchers direct the beam of the preferred ions onto an unenriched silicon substrate about 1 square cm.

NIST researcher Kevin Dwyer with the silicon enrichment apparatus. The process begins at the left, where natural-abundance silicon in the form of silane gas (SiH4) is ionized. The ions pass through a magnetic field (top left), which causes their paths to curve to different degrees based on their mass. The silicon-28 ions, now separated from the other silicon isotopes, are decelerated through an ultra-high vacuum chamber (top center) and into the deposition chamber (top right).

This is much less complicated than other state-of-the-art methods currently in use for producing ultra-enriched silicon such as that used for the International Avogadro project, whose purpose is to create a kilogram standard from a highly enriched sphere of 28Si. There, enrichment requires the use of several facilities located in different countries, whereas with the NIST experiment "we have literally microseconds from the point at which the separation happens to the point at which the deposition and growth has occurred," Pomeroy explains. "It's a lot simpler and I think that's really the reason why it's successful."

Two years ago, Pomeroy and NIST colleague Kevin Dwyer used a version of this setup to reach "three nines," creating silicon that was 99.9% 28Si. To achieve the new record, the team made improvements to their system such as decreasing the vacuum pressure, which reduced incorporation of 29Si from the silane gas, and increasing the distance the particles travel after passing through the magnetic field from about 10 cm to about 1 meter.

Another recent improvement is that they have moved on from producing amorphous silicon, a form that is unusable for quantum information. Amorphous silicon is filled with dangling bonds, oxygen molecules, and other impurities that result in poor electrical properties that are important for both classical and quantum information. Instead, researchers need enriched silicon with a regular, crystalline structure. Pomeroy believes they have already created a couple of examples: high-resolution transmission electron microscopy (TEM) images of the silicon crystal structures they've made show the films have the same ordering as the single crystal substrates on which they are grown.

To create the crystalline samples, the researchers grew the 28Si on a substrate heated to as high as 1250 ͦC. At these high temperatures, they found that the enriched films mimic the structure of the unenriched crystalline silicon substrate almost perfectly. If the sample is too cold, there's not enough thermal energy for the atoms to order themselves properly.

The team had expected that this step of raising the temperature might decrease the enrichment of the wafer. Instead, they found an unexpected benefit: for a sample heated to 600ͦC, the enrichment increased ten times, giving them their sixth nine, probably due to improvements in the vacuum pressure.

Schematic diagram of laboratory set-up.

"We were expecting to move backwards, to lose enrichment due to some thermal processes that were going to kick in, and it was rather surprising to us that we actually improved," Pomeroy says.

Applications for this super-high enrichment include all strategies for silicon-based qubits.

"The coherence problem is universal to all of quantum information," Pomeroy says. "Any scheme using silicon that involves spin or even potentially charge is going to suffer from a coherence problem due to the 29Si." Silicon-germanium (SiGe) is another popular medium that has the same problem, and the team has plans to do multi-component enrichment of this compound.

Meanwhile, Pomeroy's group plans to improve and validate its highly enriched silicon by testing the electronic performance, particularly whether their silicon supports coherence as it should. They may also partner with industry to make this technique more widely available to other laboratories. But their primary responsibility, he says, is to "keep pushing forward the frontiers of quantum information."

Explore further: Superconducting-silicon qubits: Using a bottom-up approach to make hybrid quantum devices

More information: * An earlier result, which describes 99.9998% enrichment with amorphous silicon, was published recently in the Journal of Physics D (J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys.47345105; ). The more recent measurements – 99.99996% enrichment and efforts to produce highly enriched crystalline silicon – are part of an ongoing project.

** Conventional binary digits (bits) can have one of two values: 0 or 1. Quantum bits (qubits), by contrast, can contain a superposition of different values at once as long as they are kept in a fragile condition called coherence. Breakdown of that state is called decoherence.

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Could silicon be ideal in quantum computing?

Sep 16, 2011

( -- "Quantum computing could provide a way to significantly speed up the way we process certain algorithms," Malcolm Carroll tells "The primary issue, though, is that you need a well controlled two-le ...

Researchers prove stability of wonder material silicene

Aug 12, 2014

An international team of researchers has taken a significant step towards understanding the fundamental properties of the two-dimensional material silicene by showing that it can remain stable in the presence ...

Recommended for you

Why seashells' mineral forms differently in seawater

30 minutes ago

For almost a century, scientists have been puzzled by a process that is crucial to much of the life in Earth's oceans: Why does calcium carbonate, the tough material of seashells and corals, sometimes take ...

Giant virus revealed in 3-D using X-ray laser

1 hour ago

For the first time, researchers have produced a 3-D image revealing part of the inner structure of an intact, infectious virus, using a unique X-ray laser at the Department of Energy's SLAC National Accelerator ...

Magnetic vortices in nanodisks reveal information

1 hour ago

Researchers at the Helmholtz-Zentrum Dresden-Rossendorf (HZDR) and Forschungszentrum Jülich (FZJ) together with a colleague at the French Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique (CNRS) in Strasbourg ...

User comments : 2

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Lilly Anne
not rated yet Aug 12, 2014
I'm really happy that this work was done by NIST! They are my favorite US federal government entity, even more than NASA. I worry about future funding for NIST now that there are so many science research budget cut-backs proposed, or maybe in effect.

I noticed that physical proximity was considered critical to the discovery:
"It is much less complicated than other state-of-the-art methods currently in use for producing ultra-enriched silicon such as that used for the International Avogadro project...There, enrichment requires...several facilities located in different countries, whereas with the NIST experiment 'we have literally microseconds from the point at which the separation happens to the point at which the deposition and growth has occurred,' Pomeroy explains."

I recall that NIST has several facilities. I wonder where this work was done. Was it mentioned?
not rated yet Aug 13, 2014
Fantastic development in quantum computing.
Aug 14, 2014
This comment has been removed by a moderator.
Aug 14, 2014
This comment has been removed by a moderator.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.