World Cup robo-suit team dismiss underwhelmed critics

Jun 15, 2014
A 'Brazuca' football is seen next to an exoskeleton at Brazilian scientist Miguel Nicolelis' lab in Sao Paulo, Brazil, on January 1, 2014

The team behind the brain-controlled suit that helped a paraplegic kick a football at the World Cup opening ceremony defended itself Saturday against critics who said the demonstration was underwhelming.

In the buildup to Thursday's opening, much fanfare surrounded the project led by Brazilian neuroscientist Miguel Nicolelis and meant to showcase Brazil's scientific and technological achievements.

The Brazilian government's World Cup website had tantalized visitors' imaginations with a description of how the would enable a paralyzed person to "stand up from his wheelchair, walk for around 25 meters (yards) on the pitch and make the first kick of the World Cup."

In reality, the demonstration was somewhat less spectacular.

Paraplegic Juliano Pinto, standing in the Iron Man-like suit with two handlers appearing to support it on either side, gave a quick tap to a football placed in front of him on a red ramp.

The entire display lasted about three seconds, and left many viewers tweeting their disappointment.

"The concept was great but the footage I've seen of that exoskeleton World Cup kick-off was very disappointing," wrote @quepasanene.

Fellow Twitter user @filipemalafaia agreed: "I was expecting something grandiose, but they barely showed it in the broadcast."

Scientists are seen working at Brazilian scientist Miguel Nicolelis' lab in Sao Paulo, Brazil, on January 1, 2014

Nicolelis, himself an avid social media user with a flare for creating buzz around his research, took to Twitter to defend the demonstration, blaming FIFA for cutting part of it.

"FIFA must answer for the editing of the images, which prevented the demonstration from being transmitted in its entirety," he wrote.

But a spokeswoman for the project later acknowledged the entire demonstration had in fact been broadcast.

"It was just the kick. They showed what happened in its entirety," Caroline Devide from the project's communications team told AFP.

"He didn't take any steps."

Tetraplegic Congresswoman Mara Gabrilli said the demonstration had been a disappointment for paralysis victims.

A paraplegic patient (R) wears an interface helmet at Brazilian scientist Miguel Nicolelis' lab in Sao Paulo, Brazil, on January 1, 2014

Nicolelis "didn't deliver what he promised and misled tons of patients," she told O Estado de Sao Paulo newspaper.

But Pinto, the 29-year-old car crash victim who demonstrated the exoskeleton, said the experience had been "extraordinary."

"It's been seven years since my medulla injury, without being able to move my lower limbs," he told news website G1.

"After all that, to be able to regain control of them, to control the destiny of your feet... The exoskeleton gave that to me again, it brought back the movements I lost."

Nicolelis posted a link to the interview on Twitter, saying: "That's the opinion that counts!"

Explore further: Paraplegic in 'Iron Man' bodysuit to open World Cup

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Paralyzed person to kick off world cup

Jun 12, 2014

(HealthDay)—A paralyzed person who will be strapped into a robotic "suit" with artificial skin will take the first kick-off of the World Cup in Brazil when the tournament starts Thursday.

Biggest World Cup comeback so far: beer

Jun 14, 2014

Brazil fought hard when FIFA insisted it overturn its ban on alcohol in stadiums, but the World Cup hosts lost, and with the tournament now under way it's official: beer is back.

Recommended for you

Robots lending a helping hand to build planes

Aug 26, 2014

Trying to squeeze into small enclosed areas, carrying out highly repetitive tasks, retiring with back injuries even while your expertise is needed: these everyday realities of working in aviation construction ...

C2D2 fighting corrosion

Aug 22, 2014

Bridges become an infrastructure problem as they get older, as de-icing salt and carbon dioxide gradually destroy the reinforced concrete. A new robot can now check the condition of these structures, even ...

Meet the "swarmies"- robotics' answer to bugs

Aug 22, 2014

(Phys.org) —A small band of NASA engineers and interns is about to begin testing a group of robots and related software that will show whether it's possible for autonomous machines to scurry about an alien ...

User comments : 1

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Jumbybird
3 / 5 (2) Jun 15, 2014
They obviously thought it was more important to show ShitBull and Poop-Lo